Reviews
via Podcasts
Ok.
Like, this is good and all, but just watching a few videos of it Doesn’t make you know everything about it.
Ben_drownd
Depressing and Annoying
I get that not everyone likes Markiplier or every person of entertainment for that matter. Though facts need to be checked. Watching a few videos isn’t going to give you enough knowledge on a YouTuber. If you had done enough research, you’d know WHY Markiplier is Markiplier.
comfused and frusterated
Great show
Discovered your show fairly recently and have been really enjoying it! Love from a fellow Carl (class of ’00).
(Yes I know that only applies to Noah, but enjoy you both.)
VERIFIED ACCOUNT
Keeping it high and tight
These dudes keep it high and tight and present great and thoughtful debates.
George Bestest
nah
bill is okay, noah is incredibly hateful. way too negative. like geez, just let people do what makes them happy and don’t be bitter that they make more money than you while doing it. listening to this literally depresses me, 11/10 would not recommend.
(also, check your facts, markiplier was not going to med school or trying to become a doctor, he was going to school for engineering.)
ominousboop
Bursting the bubbles of pop culture
Unlike most podcasts about pop culture, the hosts of this podcast don't consume it mindlessly. Instead they sift the fads & brands of the moment for real insights into the modern world. Their approach to each subject is relaxed & informal, but beneath that is a weekly lesson in media literacy. In every episode, they respect the inquiry even when they don't think much of the subject. It helps that Bill Scurry & Noah Tarnow are funny guys with great chemistry & crack timing. But the key to their dynamic is that, unlike most middle-aged white guys, they actually listen to each other. "I Don't Get It" makes for an entertaining & informative listen.
Read more
Aaron Grunfeld
Nope
Markiplier is awesome, you’re upset he makes way more money than you, and is a genuinely better person than both of you. Aquaman was also amazing, you miss the entire point of the movie if you think it was better than Wonder Woman. Y’all are just hateful, you’re voices are really high pitches and annoying, and your jokes are really really bad.
littlekate8
My New Obsession
I absolutely LOVE this podcast. Noah and Bill have me literally laughing out loud with their wry insights into everything from Black Mirror (a favorite) to Jimmy Fallon (the biggest sign of the Apocalypse according to the guys). While I don’t always agree with their musings (all hail Aziz Ansari) I appreciate the thought and research that goes into every show. Full transparency - Noah is a friend of mine - but listening to him talk about buying a bottle of Fireball Whiskey and CBD Oil (when I know he is a diehard teetotaler) to really understand the trends is one of the reasons this resonates. I’m also loving learning about pre-teen Noah and how he became the awesome dude he is. I don’t know Bill but after listening to 2 or 3 episodes a day (I did say I’m obsessed) I can say I love this guy. I don’t know how he does it but he makes his brand of pretension charming. I have 2 main reasons I love this so much. I really enjoy how Noah and Bill play off each other so well. It is very apparent that these two know their way around a microphone. I also love how much they know about pop culture. Every once in a while they will say something about a memory from my childhood that cracks me up. It happened in the very first episode when Noah mentioned the Fotomat in Back to the Future. From that moment on I was hooked. Keep up the good work. Love, your biggest fan!
Read more
pogoevents
Get This Podcast
With I Don't Get It, hosts Noah Tarnow and William Scurry have crafted an expertly focused and engaging podcast that tackles emerging cultural trends from an honest, personal perspective. Sure, the hosts call it a "Get Off My Lawn-cast," taking on the role of Internet Curmudgeons, but they are more eloquent commentators than grouches, as they carefully consider their chosen topics and what the emergence in popular culture of those trends might mean for them personally and society as a whole. Plus, they got jokes and the whole thing is fun to listen to.
Read more
Quasar Sniffer
Cool!
I've met Noah in real life, at a pool party today actually and he is an amazing person!
Taylorswiftrocks220
Bitterly Funny
These two fellas are jealous of everybody...and after listening to a few episodes you'll understand why. :0
e.f. bartlam
I'm a better person for listening.
Bill and Noah do their homework and dive into the experience of each topic before ever hitting the "record" button. Almost every topic is something trendy that I have zero knowledge about, but these guys tell me everything I need to know. I finish each episode SMARTER than when I started, not just because they educate me on something unknown to me, but because they cover things in such a comprehensive, intelligent and well-researched manner. Also, they are very funny and knowledgeable about the world of pop culture and entertainment in general, so this show is on my MUST LISTEN list.
Read more
SmashHansen
I'm a 40 year and I am loving this podcast.
These guys actually totally "get it" and seemed to have hit the nail on the head on every topic so far. The Show seems to only be getting better with each new episode.
Acmanhattan
Fun chemistry
The two hosts of the show sound like they've been working on their act for a bunch of years. The conversations and references are also really funny, while pointing the way to whether or not I'd like the subject of the episode. Very handy.
JaniceErlbaum
I’m an aging white guy too
Not really, but so far I’ve agreed w/ these two 100%. “I Don’t Get It” is one of those things that will make you feel smarter for listening to it.
Mungo181
I make this podcast and I love it!
This is a totally biased review from one of the creators, and I would fully suggest you subscribe and listen every week -- the commentary is amazing, and the rapport is fun.
American Caesar
