Howie’s Substack Podcast (private feed for howielisnoff@gmail.com)
Howie’s Substack Podcast (private feed for [email protected])
Howie Lisnoff
“What Did You Learn in School Today..."
4 minutes Posted Apr 30, 2024 at 12:30 pm.
0:00
4:55
Download MP3
Show notes

“What Did You Learn in School Today…”

The right to assemble peaceably and to seek a redress of grievances to the government is enshrined in the First Amendment to the Constitution. Along with that right is the right of a free press and the right to worship as a person desires. Technically, the right to redress grievances does not extend to a college or university campus that is not public, but decades of established practice makes the right to assemble and protest a necessary part of membership in both public and private colleges and universities. If chosen, the right to protest is part of a person’s intellectual and moral development, and here I mean morality as it relates to the highest of human values in regard to war and peace, equality, and the sanctity of the natural environment. The practice of civil disobedience to right the wrongs of a society and the larger world have come down through history with figures such as Thoreau, Gandhi, and King.

The role of an institution of higher learning is to educate and part of that education is the ability to gather information and make critical assessments about those facts. Thousands of young adults on campuses across the US are now doing these critical assessments of facts and concluding that the war in the Gaza Strip is grotesquely immoral. It is further made immoral by the death and starvation of thousands of children at the hands of Israel and Israel’s allies, including the US.

The rules of human behavior in war developed thousands of years ago in such disparate places as Babylonia and ancient Greece, were refined in the writings of Augustine and Aquinas, and transformed into international and national law as a means of mitigating the worst effects of wars between nations and alliances of nations as civilian populations were drawn into war made worse by technology.   

Columbia University stands at the pinnacle of that righteous protest against war, as its students and faculty have done for decades. Whether it was the Vietnam War, sexism, racism in both the US and South Africa, countless other wars, and now the genocidal war against Palestinian civilians by Israel, Columbia University stands with other colleges and universities across this nation in vehement opposition to that war.

The current administration at Columbia, like an administration of decades earlier, allowed New York City police to arrest those who stood up against grotesquely immoral wars. Columbia University administration now uses expulsion (New York Times, April 29, 2024) and censure of students to make their point about which side of genocide, if that is humanly possible, to be on. There is only one side of genocide to be on. The Holocaust and other genocides teach the side to be on. Both the condemnation and cessation of mass killing through protest are means of addressing the outrageous wrongs of the Israel-Gaza war.

Singer-songwriter Pete Seeger wrote: “What did you learn in school today Dear little boy [sic] of mine.” (“What Did You Learn in School Today?”)

Much has been said about antisemitism on the part of student protesters (New York Times, April 29, 2024). As a Jew, and war resister from the Vietnam era, I have witnessed antisemitism in protest, but not anywhere near more than a small minority.

If antisemitism is viewed as it actually exists in contemporary society, look to the far right, in individuals, groups, and in the political system. It is in all of the iterations and existence of far-right antisemitism that murder occurs.

With protests expanding to places such as schools in Texas, Utah, and Virginia (Guardian, April 30, 2024), there may very well be hope and salvation in the US.

Please subscribe to Howie’s Substack. Thank you.



Thank you for subscribing. Share this episode.