Howie’s Substack Podcast (private feed for howielisnoff@gmail.com)
Howie’s Substack Podcast (private feed for [email protected])
Howie Lisnoff
Intolerance in the Berkshires of Massachusetts
14 minutes Posted Apr 29, 2024 at 11:59 am.
0:00
14:38
Download MP3
Show notes

Intolerance in the Berkshires of Massachusetts

With an opening on the Egremont, Massachusetts select board, I wonder if, in a community with a decidedly liberal electorate, can a liberal run and get elected to a board and government with which I have had several encounters and is authoritarian? In another time with money valued differently, this may have been the $64,000 question.

I was not surprised when I read the letter to the editor in the Berkshire Edge about the issue of the school merger of several local towns (“Hostile environment in Egremont during school merger meeting,” October 16, 2023). Here is an excerpt from that letter:

‘How mistaken I was about the nature of that Egremont meeting. As I entered, I was told by a selectboard member ‘I know you’ve already made up your mind’. As someone intrigued by the idea of a high school merger, I felt entirely unwelcome. The environment was hostile. My husband and I left part way through.

The following morning, in a disparaging email to the Egremont Neighbors group, that same selectboard member referred to my husband and me as ‘a young couple new to Egremont’ [who didn’t understand proper town etiquette]. I am not new to Egremont. I was born and raised here, I went through both the SBRSD [a local combined school district] and the BHRSD [a local combined school district], and after being gone for about 15 years, I returned in 2021.

“Hitler should have killed all the Jews!” I walked in my neighborhood in Narragansett, Rhode Island when I encountered a neighbor with whom I had a series of discussions regarding the endless barking of his dog. A casual observer might recoil at my neighbor’s words, but hate speech, unless it leads to violence, is protected by the Constitution, and specifically Article 1 of the Bill of Rights. As a writer, I can appreciate the protections that the founding document gives me, but who wants the kind of reaction that resulted from a simple discussion? The neighbor also referred to my writing, letters and commentary that appeared in the state’s major newspaper, the Providence Journal, in his verbal attack. Intolerance involves many issues and many reactions, but someone who speaks out and is considered different can be the target for hate. What the neighbor’s reaction did to me made me very leery of speaking to anyone in a similar situation and that situation came up once again soon after my wife and I moved to Egremont.

The hate speech I encountered in Rhode Island has morphed exponentially in the intervening years across the US and has led to some horrific and deadly outcomes in Virginia and Pittsburgh, to name just a few of the places hate has become violent, but national and global issues are beyond the consideration of this commentary. However, those issues do have an effect.

Soon after moving to Egremont, the same situation happened as I had experienced in Rhode Island with hours of barking by a neighbor’s dog. With my Rhode Island experience in mind, I asked the police to intervene, and they did. My reticence in discussing that issue was more than justified when I got up to address an issue at the annual town meeting nearly six years ago. When I began speaking, the neighbor just mentioned began laughing hysterically at me. That was the last time I attended a town meeting and it reinforced my beliefs about how far some in this society have come from any form of tolerance. Forget acceptance: this is bald-faced intolerance. We live in a do your own thing society and to hell with everyone else.

During that encounter, I thought of Norman Rockwell’s illustration, in response to President Franklin’s “Four Freedoms” speech. That illustration shows a person standing and addressing a public meeting. I am allowed no such similar freedom here because of intolerance.

Intolerance is different in the Berkshires and it may have to do with the number of my coreligionists, fellow Jews, who either live here, or have second homes here. The term “New Yorker” is used as a kind of substitute here for registering displeasure with a specific group, the group of which I’m a member. My “neighbor” in Rhode Island knew the group to which I belong.

Section 11H of Massachusetts general laws lays out what constitutes bullying in the state:

‘Whenever any person or persons, whether or not acting under color of law, interfere by threats, intimidation or coercion, or attempt to interfere by threats, intimidation or coercion, with the exercise or enjoyment by any other person or persons of rights secured by the constitution or laws of the United States, or of rights secured by the constitution or laws of the commonwealth, the attorney general may bring a civil action for injunctive or other appropriate equitable relief in order to protect the peaceable exercise or enjoyment of the right or rights secured.’

With Massachusetts law in mind, for years, similar and unending harassment has taken place where I live. Bullying is the norm, or at least for me who some town employees/officials see as different and a valid target for harassment and bullying. When I asked the son of a town official to consider slowing down on an abutting driveway near our property because of several hours during which huge plumes of dust covered our property caused by a huge truck that person drove, the bullying and harassment by another town official began within days. It was a simple request, not done in any threatening or menacing way and the results have gone on for years now.

The town official began a three-pronged targeted harassment, which included speeding up and down the same driveway, repeatedly sounding the horn on his truck, and blasting his truck’s radio. That harassment continued for three months.

Naysayers in the town’s government will say this is all sour grapes because I applied for a vacant school committee position and later a job as personnel director. I applied for the first job to enable me to use 40 years of experience in education, and the second job to see if a pattern of discrimination did exist. The results of both applications were illuminating. A select board member wrote to me that the select board had preselected a candidate for the school committee position and the personnel director’s job was removed from the town’s list of available positions soon after I applied. The personnel director job was eventually filled sometime later. The Massachusetts Commission Against Discrimination agreed to file a complaint about the town’s denial of both jobs, but the hassle in going forward with those complaints would have been daunting.

During the time I applied for these jobs, I walked into a room at the town offices and said hello to a member of the select board who sat at a table in the room. That person said, and I paraphrase here, that I was the kind of person in Egremont who did not know how to go about getting things done in the proper way. Here, think about the recent words of a select board member: “a young couple new to Egremont [who didn’t understand proper town etiquette].” There are ways in which to address issues in Egremont, and none of those “ways” include the right of free speech.

I worked as a community college instructor when I applied for the jobs noted above and applied because I wanted to use my experience in education positively. I wanted to make a contribution, however small.

Fast forward to shortly after Thanksgiving in 2022, when nine months of construction began on the same property from which the original harassment took place in 2015, the construction sometimes extending to both Saturdays and Sundays.

In July 2023, the same town employee, acting in a private role, who harassed me in 2015, continued his harassment while I walked up the driveway on the neighboring property. I needed to discuss the removal of stumps with the head of the construction company, tree stumps that were from borderline trees on both my property and the property described above. The town official, still acting in a private capacity, repeatedly said that he was the person to speak with regarding the construction company. I said I would continue walking up the driveway to speak to the construction manager. He, the town official, called me a “near shit,” and compared me to a person who was involved in a committee dealing with affordable housing in the town. He called the person on the affordable housing committee a “total shit.” Even a casual observer can figure out what’s going on here, and what’s going on is authoritarianism and harassment by officials. The same town employee, still acting in a private role, then verbally attacked me for complaining to the neighbors, who own the land I stood on, about the construction company beginning work too early each day on their property. My wife said, to the two owners, that work had gone on on some Saturdays and Sundays during the past eight months.

Most chilling in this town employee’s verbal attack was his comment that I was “known to the police” in Egremont. All of this was witnessed by a second man who was in the truck, but I did not recognize him.

I went up the driveway at the request of workers from a fence company erecting a fence on our property. The fence company needed to have the stumps removed before the fence construction continued. The construction company working on the neighbor’s land requested the stumps be removed earlier that day hours before the interaction took place with the town official.

The harassment I describe above happened at the same time as seven years of harassment I’ve experienced at a town facility I use. I complained about that treatment to a former police chief, who said that the manager of that facility was a “good guy” and that his behavior could not be questioned, because he, the manager, had been harassed by a select board member. The harassment toward me involves the facility’s manager going into the facility’s main building and remaining there until I leave. That manager interacts with other people, but retreats to the facility’s main building if I’m there alone. Recently, that town employee hollered at me for not using the facility properly, but it’s difficult to use a facility “properly” when the person managing it goes indoors when I arrive there. When I asked the facility manager why he had treated me this way he answered: “Well.”

The authoritarianism of some elected officials is not reflective of the liberal makeup of the town. Egremont is a liberal place with a town government, it seems to me, out of step with the open-mindedness of most people.

These incidents are the tip of the proverbial iceberg of the gross intolerance I’ve experienced here. It is too late to deal with any of these issues because to counter them, or work them out, would mean working with people who have some sense of fairness and compassion. I thought that tolerance, and even acceptance, would be different from Rhode Island, but intolerance and hate is just different here.

Howard Lisnoff is a freelance writer.

Please subscribe to Howie’s Substack Here’s the link to subscribe: howielisnoff2024.substack.com

Thank you!



Thank you for subscribing. Share this episode.