Reviews
via Podcasts
Great choices and great hosts
These folks have found some great new songs, and their knowledge of so much of the genre is just wonderful. I'm so glad they do it all year round.
WeirdChristmas
I really want to like this podcast
I love Christmas music. Listen to it year round. When I heard the conceit of the podcast I was hooked. I saw the list as it currently stands, realized that shared taste was enough that I wouldn’t be constantly annoyed by where they place my favorite songs, and dived in.
I just finished episode 30. Rather, I should say, I skipped the seconded half of the excessively long episode 30.
For the most part I enjoy the show a lot. But they will often times get fixated on the weirdest things to be annoyed about.
What really grated me and prompted me to write this review was the discussion around the terrible Christmas in the Sand song. Which, as stated, is terrible. But the discussion for that song was so dragged out and just not fun to listen to. RJ was really hung up in particular about the song not rhyming. SONGS DON’T HAVE TO RHYME!! It’s okay for them not to. But even still, that song did rhyme. Slant rhymes count. Rhymes based on assonance count!
There’s been a few examples of this, but as Indo like the show I’m not going to just focus on what bugs me.
The rapport between the two is great, as expected. The discussions of each song are generally just right, and overall I would recommend the show.
I’ll be updating my score and review as I listen to more.
Read more
Akumu813
Listen to this podcast.
Love this PODCAST!
The hosts are a couple whose goal is to listen to, review, and rank EVERY holiday-themed song ever recorded. That is a nearly impossible task; however, they have completed nearly 250 episodes and ranked nearly 500 songs. While I do not always agree with the rankings, I always enjoy the discussion of the songs and the interplay between the hosts, RJ and Ian.
The commentary is humorous, loving, intellectual, liberal, leftist, class conscious, socially responsible, etc Like me, RJ and Ian have an avowed love of Sharon Jones and the Dap Kings. Thanks to RJ's repeated references, I am now hooked on egg nog lattes. I hope that you will check them out. Nick
Read more
XPogue68
Swonderful.
Lovin it.
drrnlaw
Great show!
A favorite.
Hortense13
A wildly entertaining deep dive
I've had a ton of fun catching up with this show. While it might initially seem like the most left-field niche to cover via podcast, RJ and Ian's banter is instantly infectious. Their unconventional song pics are the hooks that'll get you listening, but it's the hosts' analysis that makes the show so great. While they could easily stuff their discussions with endless goofs, RJ and Ian really put a lot of thought into their rankings and analysis. It's surprisingly good music criticism, which is of course coupled by a hilarious dive into a genre that you were always aware of but never really *thought* about. This was the show I never knew I needed in my life. Highest recommendation.
Read more
Dan Mosier
Such a fun way to keep festive year round
I love Hark Podcast. RJ and Ian are fun hosts to listen to as they dissect Christmas songs, both songs I am familiar with and those I've never heard of. Even when I don't agree with the rankings, I enjoy listening to the rationale. I highly recommend these crazy kids.
thomcrowe
Spread Christmas Joy
Don't be a scrooge, Christmas music can be enjoyed all year around. The delightful hosts listen the best and worst holiday songs, criticize them and rate them.
Settlechaos
Made me an Xmas music fan
This is a great podcast for any holiday music fan, and it might make you into one if you're not. I will always enjoy listening to the hosts try to decide if a beloved holiday classic is better or worse than "Pot in the Latkes."
Dave Barbs
A delight for fans of Christmas
The repentant Scrooge says at the end of Dickens's classic: “I will honour Christmas in my heart, and try to keep it all the year. I will live in the Past, the Present, and the Future. The Spirits of all Three shall strive within me. I will not shut out the lessons that they teach!”
RJ and Ian literally keep Christmas all the year, and as Dickens also said, “There is nothing in the world so irresistibly contagious as laughter and good humor," we can also say that they know how to keep it well, if any man alive possess the knowledge. May that truly be said of us, and all of us.
In short: it good
Read more
benito_cereno
Five stars
It good
Firehawk32
