Keithie and Peter are incredible hosts. Peter absolutely cracks me up so much. Sopranos Seinfeld Simpsons and wrestling rolled into one podcast is my perfectly tailored podcast. My only complaint is over listened to most of the entire back log of gfa episodes and now I have to wait weekly for a new episode to upload. Charge me money to record more frequently. Come on, huh?

I enjoy listening to the wrestling reviews of the WWE 88 to early 90s shows. Lots of good wrestling and Simpsons references!

👍

My go to podcast for the best era of wrestling! Been listening since day one n this show always makes me laugh n puts me in a better mood. Pls keep it going n do 85-87 pretty please!!!

Best old school wrestling discussion podcast out there. Funny as hell, always worth the listen.

Pete and Keithie reviewing old wrestling and making each other laugh is my go to wrestling podcast. The guys could bs about anything and make it entertaining. Their friendly banter is the comfort food this longtime wrestling fan needs. Give them a listen and you’ll be glad you did.

Love the pod. Can do without the politics. Why alienate half your audience? We are here to listen about wrestling. Start a liberal podcast of you want to talk about that.

This is my go to 227/Golden Girls/Classic WWF podcast. I need a segment on the show called “Pete’s Corner” where we get a Andy Rooney style rant at the end of each episode.

Keith needs to stop eating during the pod. Gross

Peter and Keithy have a podcast chemistry I haven’t heard since the days of Daves Of Thunder! Perfect mix of wrestling talk and all else, i suggest no nay demand you give this podcast a listen!

Barb and I never had a problem with these guys. Barb and I really like this show.

Flying belly whopper

I’d typically never admit the existence of this thing, but Pete and Keithie are a very fun listen. Some fun bits, non-wrestling chatter, sports talk. Thanks for the hours of entertainment.

It’s great the Keathie and Peter interact with each other . I’ve gone back an listened to the back catalogue . I wish you guys would do more wwf home videos. Agin There’s several I’d like hear thought on The life and times of Lou Albano, The two tapes called grudge matches , And the best of T.N.T tape many I want hear keathie react to Fuji vice . And I like to see you guys cover few wcw tapes Best of bash at the beach , The dangerous alliance tape . Great show keep the good work . See you later space cowboy .🤠

Love these guys !! Best wrestling podcast, I love how they mix in everything lol but I would like a little more NWA but I’ll never stop listening

…”Little Petey” after hearing OVP plug GFA for 100th time and I’m glad I’m did. It really is a great show and easy listen. Guessing we’re close to same age so the references mostly land. Good stuff! UPDATE 10/22/23: Listening to WM 5 part 1 ep…not sure about that Keith guy and some of his takes (Demolition much bigger pop than Road Warriors…Gorilla not really liking Ventura…good thing Pete’s there to set him straight!)

Stick to wrestling is my favorite rasslin podcast, this one has a very similar feeling to it. I will be listening. Good stuff and greetings from the Poconos.

I would do favors for this podcast. The Elizabeth vs Jack Tunney a la Bad News Brown kind.

I listen to all the wrestling podcasts and this one is my favorite ! It is funny and really brings wrestling fans down memory lane to their childhood ! Great chemistry between the hosts ! Awesome !

You guys are very funny reflecting back in the good old days of WWF!

I love the way Peter & Keithie dive into the minutiae of classic WWF programming, interspersed with the drops & references you’ll grow to love. It’s a great wrestling podcast but it’s just an entertaining podcast, period. One second, they’re talking about Gorilla Monsoon. The next, they’re talking about random movie dialogue or some oblique hockey or baseball reference from decades ago. It’s truly an ADD sufferer’s delight - and I mean that as a complement. And when I think about great broadcasting duos, with apologies to Ventura & Monsoon, they’re the closest thing to me to Jerry Remy & Don Orsillo in their prime. We got down. We got up. We got funky. And we got bad. Keep up the good work, fellas.

GFA is an incredible show and I look forward to it like my mother looks forward to whatever it is that older ladies are into. Pete and Keithie feel like old friends at this point and I’d offer up a kidney to either of them if they needed it…or just wanted it. The show rewards long time listeners with running jokes and drops and all that. Just download it and enjoy. C’mon, huh?

I’ve been listening to Pete for 170 episodes now and I guess it’s time to provide social proof of that by leaving a 5-star review. My personal time is valuable so I usually spend it listening to wrestling history (my past) on Pete’s what I’ll call his journey. I hope it continues - with Keithie of course because that MFer is a joy. Cheers!

This is a very fun show that would likely be even better if Peter was more focused. I get it, that's his style (tangents, sports lol) so I understand if he's just going to always.. be that... It's cool! Helps the day fly by and can be pretty funny. Update - i still like this show but it's not the same with only being GFA live lately.

Can I get an Amen? I don’t know if you know this, but this is the best podcast today. Love these two, it reminds me of my brother and I talking old wrestling/movies/pop culture. Look forward to it every week.

I can’t stop listening to these podcasts 😁. Thank You guys.

Not nearly as funny or clairvoyant as they think they are.

Great show

The only way this show could be better is if it were produced in Japan so I can give it seven stars! Pete and Keith join up to look back on old wrestling, plus the occasional movie here or there. I highly recommend GFA Live to anybody!

I’ve listened to other rustling podcasts and nothing cures any mood better than GFA Live. The boys bring me out of the deepest places sometimes, for that even the Meltzer rating of today would go 5 stars! They are the best!

Best podcast because it’s not just wrestling. Peter has a very similar outlook on life that I have. He and Keithie are very funny together. I originally gave it 9 stars, but am docking one for getting rid of “crazy crap from my mother’s house”.

Peter and Keithie provide perhaps the easiest listen in podcasting. Two guys who have been friends for a long time and kinda awkwardly finish each others sandwiches. Also I keep meaning to send this in but my first wrestling experience was the 1990 “that’s Tony Atlas!” Taping and I was like 12. Two older kids came and sat behind me and said the wrestlers were hanging out in the back and my friends ran to go see them. It was Dino Bravo and Kerry Von Erich trying to score weed from teenagers in the smoking area of Hershey Park Arena. That was my introduction to the business. That’s my origin story for this podcast. #darksideofthering #themoreyouknow #canthavethatinthisjoint (is the outer banks trip available on peacack?)

Keep on the topics about wrestling. Too much politics. OK you hate Trump.

If the Beavis impersonator who laughs after each sentence during the live show fades into obscurity where he belongs, I will enjoy it much more

As a fellow New England resident, I love this podcast! Peter Winson drops plenty of references from central and northern NE that I am lucky enough to fully understand. The wrestling covered on this feed lands exactly in my personal “sweet spot”. The criticisms of the political rants are silly, Peter is only telling the truth and speaking common sense. I also am confused about the negative comments regarding the cohost on GFA LIVE. I enjoy Keithey!! If you enjoy 80s and 90s wrestling, this show is for you!!! Two thumbs up and five stars!!!

Absolutely fantastic! Funny and always entertaining. Love Peter going all over the map all the time

Peter is knowledgeable and extremely passionate about old school wrestling. He also has a fantastic sense of humor that conjures up many laugh out loud moments. Unfortunately, like most liberals, the host is utterly incapable of keeping his politics to himself. While I don’t really care which way people lean politically, I turn to things like wrestling podcasts to get away from life and especially politics, even if it’s only for a few minutes. Politics has literally contaminated EVERYTHING else these days. Movies, sports, music, and video games are just a few examples. Is really too much to ask that we not get it crammed down our throats in an old school wrestling podcast too? I’m sick to death of all of it, and I know a lot of people feel exactly the same way. It’s ironic that Peter whines about Adam Corolla alienating half his audience just because he no longer clings to the left wing talking points. That works both ways Peter. Lol.

Both shows GFA AND GFA live are both enjoyable . You might want take a look at power pro wrestling Or this week in wrestling as I don’t think you’ve covered any of those promotion. Or maybe for a GFA live you could check out on of the wcw mtv specials .

This podcast is fantastic. Great audio, insight, humor and production. Refreshing to hear a podcaster who's remained consistent in terms of his vibe since the beginning. Feels like so many other podcasts of a similar ilk ultimately become ad-heavy and redundant, causing me to lose interest over time. Peter does it purely for the love of the game. Happy to provide what is known as social proof that this is my favorite wrestling podcast.

Speaking specifically of the old Coliseum Video reviews: These guys are very clever and extremely likable, and often laugh-out-loud funny. Be warned: If you're not an early-to-mid-40s American guy who's into classic WWF (like the hosts, and like me), you might not get, oh, 90% of the cultural references. (I personally appreciate the quotes from late-'80s SNL sketches.) But if you are one of us, this show is hard not to like.

This is a great podcast about old wrestling with a healthy dose of sports trivia. Peter is easy to listen to and extremely knowledgeable. His love of cats and Bret Hart makes up for his love of Boston sports teams. He’ll also call out his co-host’s ill informed opinions on drummers if you send him an email. What more can you ask??

I recently discovered this podcast thanks to the fellas at OVP. To say I’m hooked would be a serious understatement. I have not laughed this hard in a long time. As much as I love the solo weekly review, the live GFA shows are ever better. This covers two of my childhood obsessions: the Best of the WWF series and the Karate Kid Part 2. And the Goodfellas references definitely don’t hurt. Highly recommended. But what do I know about the podcast business? All I know is how to sit down and listen. Time to go back and listen to some more. No talking!

This is one of the better wrestling podcasts out there. Peter brings his pro wrestling insights week in, and week out. Thrown in is a fair amount of sports, pop culture and politics. The GFA Live podcasts with Keithie are great, as well. The people who are leaving poor reviews need to relax. Pro wrestling should not be taken seriously! It’s a welcome divergence from everyday life. I’m able to look at a favorite part of my childhood, from a different perspective, thanks to these guys! Would love to see a little more ‘85-88 AWA. It’s so bad, it’s good.

The premise of the show is brilliant. The host is not like able.

Very mixed feelings. The original feed is my favorite retro wrestling podcast. Great weekly variety, well researched and prepared, fun mix of humor and nostalgia. The newly added weekly “GFA” series is somehow the worst, by far. The co-host adds nothing but shouting horrific impressions followed by awkwardly giggling at it at high speed. Unlistenable. Five stars for the original, zero for GFA.

I stumbled across this while looking for pro wrestling podcasts dedicated to older years. Each episode tends to include sports and pop culture discussion from the time period of the particular show at hand. I recommend you give it a shot if this sounds at all interesting to you.

I liked this show for a long time, but Peter’s insistence on dragging his personal issues into every episode has poisoned my enjoyment of the show. It’s unfortunate, because when he actually focuses on vintage wrestling he does a great job - it’s just not enough to keep me subscribed.

Love the random episode selection of the show. Peter does a great job by himself , I don’t think people understand how hard that is to accomplish. Love the sports inserts into the episodes. A joy.

I like it!

Yes Memphis!! Thank you