Reviews
via Podcasts
Excellent analyses
I’m a scholar of South Asia and I still learn so much from these excellent episodes. Thank you!
Lalindia
Propaganda podcast
This is an anti India propaganda podcast. The host chooses guests who are subtly anti India. The host also takes a line of questioning that deliberately highlights the anti India side of an issue and leaves the pro India argument under or un explored. The only positive thing I can say about this podcast is that at least it is not full on Jihadi.
RD2017
Glorified Book Review Stop
A very talented and knowledgeable host, but way too many episodes are book reviews on esoteric topics. The latter point robs the show of its focus and impact, in my view.
RJG179
A good but flawed podcast
Nicely constructed—just the right length, anywhere between 30 and 45 minutes, which is optimal—and a nice balance in topic selection between India’s external posture and its domestic achievements and challenges. However, the host, Milan Vaishnav, could benefit from adopting a less earnest tone. Too often, he sounds as if he is too eager to please, or maybe just wants to come across as unthreatening to the interviewee. Also can he drop the sentence filler “right?” with even the blandest declaration. This is a disingenuous device to extract an agreement with the interviewee. I wish someone would reply “no, not right”
Read more
sidneyhart
A terrific podcast
Milan Vaishnav and his team produce a first rate presentation each week of the latest trends in India. The podcast should appeal not only to people following developments in India, but also to those concerned about South Asia and developing countries generally. Each week, Vaishnav interviews knowledgeable experts on what’s happening in India and its neighboring states, and he does it with intelligence and a keen knowledge of India’s past and what’s happening today. I look forward to each week’s discussion, and I’m grateful to the Carnegie Endowment and the Hindustan Times for sponsoring the podcast.
Read more
Mikorff
Sync with YouTube
Very informative and engaging. My only quibble is that there are more episodes of Grand Tamasha on YouTube lately than on the podcast so I can’t listen while walking or driving. But that’s a “good problem”—your audience wants more!
Bubba83467
Good overview of Indian politics and foreign policy
I started following this podcast around April of this year. Milan interviews some of the key players and commentators who influence foreign policies of India primarily. He provides a balanced viewpoint. I’ve enjoyed it and as an Indian living in US and Canada I can relate to the viewpoints provided outside in.
SXM on the road
Highly recommended
If you are interested in Indian politics, this is the podcast for you. Informative, entertaining, and timely. Five stars.
Indian Politics Junkie
Insightful and excellent.
Far from noisy media debates, Grand Tamasha provides experts opinions and in-depth discussion on current Indian politics. Thanks to Milan and HT :)
Jay_V_8
Enjoyed this!
This is an informative and insightful podcast. I particularly enjoy the fact that views are balanced and the host isn’t pushing a particular agenda.
wildcat00
