Reviews
via Podcasts
Amazing
Claire and Ashley are so freaking funny!!
Shaywillingham
My weekly digest
Love this pod so much!!! I have been a listener since the early CMBC days, and was apprehensive of the transition to GN at first, but honestly love it way more and look forward to it weekly.
š»šŗ
Not as good as CMBC
They still have some good segments but overall general pop culture podcasts are a dime a dozen and they bring nothing new or worthy to the table here. I also have to say that they are so heavily biased against men that itās hard for me to listen to. Iām not a closet conservative, Im a progressive, Iām fully aware that the patriarchy is alive and well and the world is still an unfair place for women. But they seemingly hate most of men they discuss and are much more willing to give grace to objectively toxic behavior by some of the women they discuss. Idk they are also just kind of hateful in general. Many of their perspectives are just Brooklyn bubble coded and donāt go much deeper than that.
Read more
hbd910
Good noticings, extremely bad vibes
Loved CMBC so I keep trying to love Good Noticings. Most of the topics they cover are things I know nothing about, so I take their very opinionated (and almost always negative) takes at face value. But occasionally they go SO hard on something I actually know about or love- most recently Dax Shepard- and they lose all credibility. Itās insane how confidently they can spread such exaggerated and misleading takes. Ironically very trump-esque.
I get that itās a hot takes style pod but can we sprinkle in a little love? Not everything and everyone needs to be absolutely terrible. A lot of the topics arenāt particularly interesting to begin with but somehow they spiral into wildly over the top psychoanalysis and character assassinations. They take things so far beyond whatās warranted
Read more
Valerie831
Daughter got me interested in this
Thank you for being intelligent and funny. Thank you for your unique takes and for covering a wide variety of topics.
ā***ā999
I love this podcast but
I just do not understand why you guys outright refuse to learn how to pronounce anything. Itās actually not funny or cuteā¦at all. Itās basic respect for your audience and your subject.
Jessica Dare Weaver
Bummer
Really disappointed to hear these two make false judgements and accusations about Zionism - recently about Hila Klein who they misrepresented in their most recent episode. Trisha Paytas has a history of STAUNCH Zionism, and despite many claims, the Klein family does not. Do a little research before spreading harmful rhetoric.
bobbylicious2002
Love the new pod
But wish they werenāt so condescending towards romantasy.
AliciaCat1763
Can claire chill?
Interrupting, screaming, being mean, and using weird voices does not make you funny.
Bounceswer
No direction and mean girl energy
CMBC was so good, but Claire is so mean to Ashley that I just canāt listen anymore. I really tried to give this a fair shake and listened to several episodes but it just feels disorganized and too widely varying in topics for my taste. Lacks any focus or direction.
NoChardonnay
Iād give no stars if i could
These 2 have no idea what theyāre talking about most of the time. Maybe do some research beforehand so you dont sound so uneducated and ignorant. Bring back CMBC, we want celebs not youšššš
Boopy5
Loved CMBC - this is BETTER
Love the new format, they cover such a range of topics and they make even things I donāt care about fun and interesting. Love their thoughtful takes that still allow for humor and fun.
Ddasiissyy
All bark no bite
These two are real āstick it to the manā warriors for social justice and have plenty of criticism for AI and the like, immediately followed by a Google Gemini ad. I canāt take these 2 seriously anymore.
Zangeleus
Please!
Bring back CMBC - so good!
CMBC Lover
Additional star for nostalgia..
WE MISS CELEBRITY MEMOIR BOOK CLUB. Seriously.
Mrs Gourmandise
the claire of it all
Claire is so passive aggressive toward Ashley itās painful
pamela geller
Guys it's really not working
I still pop in here and there hoping to hear "We're bringing back the book club!" But I have zero intrest in this new format.
Ummmmmmm_ok
Love this podcast!
Such a breath of fresh air to hear two smart, funny women chat about such interesting and topical headlines, books, and art. Love how the candid conversations around difficult subjects are balanced with humor.
LHunter122
Love yāall
I feel like yall have really gotten the hang of the new format and Iāve loved the topics. I imagine much of the hate youāre getting is from past CMBC listeners that arenāt fond of the new politically leaning contentā¦ā¦but I for one love it cuz we live in a political world and pop culture is extremely politically. I donāt agree with all your takes and thatās ok?! The purity tests from some of these comments are irritating. Keep it up!!!
Read more
blurrykid28
Mean girls
Mean girls donāt win
Lovesit94929-
Great podcast
Love!
LilyGar24
AI adsā¦
Hi ladies. Iām a big fan of your podcast and enjoy hearing your takes but why do you have AI ads? You discuss how evil AI is in one breath but then have Gemini ads in the nextā¦.
Lee Jenny88
I like this show butā¦
Itās weird to have a segment about the Super El NiƱo and talk about being better to our planet and then turn around with āsupport for the showā from Google Gemini. AI is just going to spread the decline of our planet so whatās your actual message here. Iām an avid listener as I do genuinely enjoy the show but this is misleading.
MandaFC
Worst Show - Worst Women
I hate this show, what it represents & the waste of data it imposes on this universe.
NightriderCat
LOVE
Theyāre both so incredibly thoughtful, cool and funny š«¶š«¶š«¶ Love you two so soooo much!!
Mimi62916
Donāt speak for all please
Since youāre framing antisemitism, to frame the entire history of the ME through a lens of oppressed Palestinians and āIsrael is always the bad guyā is, in fact, deeply antisemitic. Youāre both bright and thoughtful and itās profoundly disappointing you, with laughter, have zero empathy for any of the lived history of your own people, which includes repeated attempts to erase your people from the earth. Its not all or nothing and after a very nuanced and Intelligent discussion about JG that pivot was just profoundly sad.
Read more
BLK228NY
fans switching up
wow iām reading all the mean reviews and wanted to add a postive one. i love this podcast!! ive listened for years and i think its great you guys are exploring other avenues. im sure its tiring being confined to just talking about books (which i love) but you girls are smart and i enjoy all chats. people complaining are the ones who will never read a book lol thanks for always being yourselves and please dont change a thing :) š©·
Read more
Thebestthingabout
Hypocrisy & performative leftism
I donāt understand how they can pretend to be leftists but then all the ads are for AI. Similarly they claim to be avidly supporting Palestine, but then do a sponsored ad for Starbucks. Itās like BDS List 101. Why sign up with ad agencies where you donāt have control over which ads will be attached to your podcast? Performative fake leftism. Not to mention Claire cosplaying as poor starving artist whoās āfor the peopleā with her rich home owning husband in nyc. Money corrupts. Why accept money for evil AI ads when one doesnāt need it? Other leftist podcasts make money from Patreon specifically to avoid this issue. Do better.
Read more
britney smearz
i miss cmbc, this is unbearable
during celebrity memo cloud, I was able to ignore how irritating I found their voices because they were actually saying things of substance but now they have nothing going for them
hhnvkkeieb f
<3
Thank you so much for this reasonable, realistic and straightforward perspective on Jools. Itās so painful to open basically any app and get immediately slapped in the face with transphobia, and I didnāt realize how on edge I am about it until I was deeeply relieved that this correct and normal perspective was the one you two shared.
WdnsdyAdams
Look forward to
One of a few pods I look forward to every week! Like hanging and chatting with friends
AgtGordonCole
Please pivot back to CMBC
Ladies, this isn't working. Take the loss & get back on the Celeb Memoir train. We get you wanted to be seen as more intellectual in the local NYC scene but WE DON'T CARE we just want the good podcast back because this new format honestly sucks.
MissssSasquatch
Iām out
Iām sorry guys, I have to be done. Itās so boring. Youāre droning on and on about the most boring topics, most of the time I zone out and Iām not even sure what youāre talking about anymore. A lot of the topics Iāve already heard covered on Monday or Tuesday. Iām not even convinced you guys care about what you are talking about.
Caesar salad 1980
Not a great pivot
I have been a longtime listener since around 2021/22. Like a lot of people their cmbc to āgood noticingsā rebrand has been a real bummer. I personally find the hosts really ill equipped and unstimulating in their commentary and convos and have also found the tone between them to become uncomfortably terse at times. Idk I want listen to podcasts to learn something interesting and get unique povs not to get uncomfy lol
Read more
AppFan22
Vapid, Mean Girls
I donāt support bullies. Luckily, Iām not missing out on any good content because this podcast is terrible. I lost brain cells while listening to these two. They are so unkind that I donāt even feel bad saying any of this. I never leave bad reviews but ā they suck.
LawyerLove
So good
I love this show so much but I sometimes have to take a break when I hear the twentieth "do you know what I mean?" and I unfortunately could not keep this to myself I'm sorry!!
nicknameajc
CMBC
I miss the old format. You guys are great though! Wish you success but I loved what yall were doing before. It was fresh and new! Yall made me want to read more books! It was helping people so Iād love to see it back in some capacity!
taylor sam boat
Love the new format
Been loving the new format I love the girls takes on celeb culture and popular articles
friedasadie
Would listen to them talk about ANYTHING!
Feels like listening along to great conversation, no matter the topic. Makes my day every week when there is a new episode!
kirsten amber
Bring back CMBC
This is a swing and a miss. I tried it, but still canāt get behind this new show.
Lphphbhhd
Why please
I loved cmbc. I recommended it to everyone and listened religiously. I even re-listened to a bunch of episodes to fall asleep to at night. Today i unfollowed their pod and unsubbed from Patreon bc GN is the worst possible turn this could have taken. C&A went from having a genuinely original and interesting pod idea to trying to do a random recs session every week that is not unique or special to their show alone. Plz listen to your fans
Read more
Nunya00767
Amazing before rebrand
Can you guys go back to doing memoirs (the way you used to) at least semi-regularly? I get you needed a breather but there's so many memoirs coming out i really would have loved to hear u guys cover fully. Even once a month would be nice
Julesxoxo2000
Way too long
Still love the ladies, but this is WAY too long when compared to the actual interesting moments. Itās just boring.
Scp114
Missing CMBC
I really tried but I donāt like this new format. I miss CMBC
20 something gal
CMBC
BRING BACK CELEBRITY BOOKCLUB MEMOIRS !
R/de
But was it preposterous?
I tried.
BiancaAmes
Genuinely gets worse every week
I am actually sincerely asking you to read your reviews and Reddit threads and take the feedback!!!!! Literally no one likes this format or the topics and youāre clearly misinformed
Cberman10005
Insufferable,
The show has turned insufferable, misinformation. Everything good gets ruined..
lynae94
Bad Noticings
What have you noticed today? I noticed that CMBC was a significantly better podcast that highlighted Claire and Ashleyās talents. GN feels like a superficial pop culture news podcast that waters C&A down. Bring back CMBC and maybe inject a few GN in every once in a while. Moral to the story? Sign with Vox, sell the soul of what made your podcast so great.
bunnysmom231
š
These are my fave podcasters but GN is so up and down. Some eps are super interesting, but bummed at how much I skip through these topics or skip the ep all together. Glad we have the CMBC backlog. Will continue to check in in hopes the vibe of GN will become more consistent. Maybe ditch the recsā¦
j_humpy
