It’s finally back

Loving this so far! Only a few episodes in but super excited! Love the content and really love your voice. It’s perfect for helping calm my anxiety 💙

Really enjoy falling asleep to your voice and stories. I always rewind and listen to what I missed falling asleep.

I dint know HOW IN THE WORLD my 5-Star review of Blood On The Rocks got posted to your podcast by mistake - but I am however elated at the gods of fate for leading me hereto Good Nightmare where I’ve just recently become a fan of YOUR podcast as well - you can well imagine my disbelief as I was stunned to see my review below for a completely different program ... but thankfully I get this chance right now to leave a five star review for you, for YOUR work - and cut &paste the other one, to where it’s supposed to go ~ Cheers Sarah. I’m well embarrassed at the mishap and mystified over how & why it happened but I am much relieved at this God-given chance to fix it - AND to have found another great podcast: I love your show!!

This podcast gives me Coraline vibes . I loved her voice and the story’s . The intro music is so cute 10/10!!

I appreciate how the hostess does this as a labor of love. I have enjoyed all of the topics she has covered and have been binging all of the episodes since I found it last week. Thank you for all of your hard work putting this together! It makes my own work go by much faster. Keep it up!

I was shocked to hear the host actually repeat the same sentences and phrases on at least two separate occasions during the piece on The Stanley. How in the world could this slip through the cracks- did no one even bother to review the piece before publishing? Very sloppy work. It’s a shame, as this was the first episode I checked out since I love “The Shining” and have visited the hotel in Estes Park. But after hearing the 20-second intro consisting of general hotel background immediately repeated, it felt like amateur hour. (1:10-1:50) Then, when it happened a second time at 3:45...wow, how unbelievably bad. What a poor first impression.

Sarah tells great stories! Always with her own wonderful twist and history! She rocks! Sweet Dreams.

Loved hearing from him

You made my day!!! I love creepy movie trivia as well. It’s so fascinating! Happy 50th!!

This podcast is totally a must listen, way fun and entertaining, one of my favorites

I am here because Desertdog6 left such a lame review. Don’t let the incels influence what you listen to! They’re usually wrong. This podcast has some unique and well-researched episodes and the host poses some fun questions and concepts to think about. I’m 5 episodes in and very much looking forward to the rest!

I just listened to the Elizabeth Bathory episode. The host first makes the assumption that everyone has heard of Bathory, therefore she doesn’t provide many details. She then goes on to state that Bathory was set up by a political rival due to a large debt - and that there is no way witnesses could be possible. The host fails to consider that a person in Bathory’s could get away with a great many things - especially if that person had a mental illness which caused them to believe that bathing in the blood of virgins would help her look young. I prefer podcasters to provide actual facts, then give their analysis. Or to give both sides of a story. Unfortunately the host is more concerned with making a female serial killer look better instead of acknowledging that women are possible of having mental health issues and killing scores of people. Red Handed and Dark Histories are better alternatives than this nonsense.

I love love this podcast! I just wish the episodes were longer so I could listen longer!

Sarah’s voice is rich and velvety and soothing as hell as she gives a good overview of a lot of things from the darker side of life, both well known and not. Fairy tales, true crime, urban myths, this show has it all. Even if she does give the Bothell Hell House time it absolutely does not deserve. A+ best non-egg.

This show is as insightful as it is creepy. Sarah packs so much context and nuance into every little episode—without sacrificing the storytelling one bit. It’s easy listening and totally worthy of your binge time. Gonna recommend this one to all my nerdiest (and creepiest) friends.

I just discovered you and can't stop listening. Send help!

I love this podcast! I’ve been binge listening and it’s perfect while I’m at work or home.

The fairy tales and dark stories are delivered by a lovely narrator. I love that I can easily listen to several of these episodes at once. I don’t have a lot of time to listen to long episodes in one sitting, so these are great!

Nice new show I recently discovered. Episodes are quick and get to the details without rambling. Entertaining and the voice is calming

I love everything about this pod. The pacing, the host, the subject matter, it's all top marks.

I normally don't listen to podcasts with such short episodes but the host has the most inviting, warm and soothing voice. Even when telling a story I've heard a million times I find myself enchanted and actually enjoying the story as if for the first time. A great podcast that is well worth the binge.

Check your closet twice. This podcast brings the fright.

This is a great podcast I discovered via twitter. The episodes are short and sweet—perfect for a quick break. Highly recommend.

A nice variety of topics that fits well into my podcast line up and a great voice too!

Nice and short. Filled with great information and I could listen to Sara read the phone book and it'd be fantastic!!

These concise tales are creepy and fun. The host has an amazing voice and does such a good job telling the stories. Must listen! Love from @2girlsonabench

Love the host and the topic! A fresh take on something we all are curious about

I love the show, the topics are extremely interesting, and the narrative style is very good. My one complaint is about the audio quality. The bass is a bit heavy making it a little difficult to hear through speakers. Otherwise, I highly recommend this podcast.

MORE, MORE, MORE. Can't get enough. I just can't wait for the next drop..

I could listen to this podcast for days. Her voice and story telling style is captivating and the stories are fascinating and concise.

Good Nightmare is a lovely podcast covering a range of creepy and fairy tales, some of which we've heard, but, even when we have, Sarah, places a new twist, provides new information, and or discusses theories related to the story. These tales are interesting and sometimes terrifying, but Sarah's heart and concern for the health of her listeners carries through every single episode. I highly recommend this podcast because I get my fill of creepiness, and I hear them from a person with a heart of gold. Alysa, Best Forevers: A Podcast for Kindred Spirits

I really love this podcast. It's soothing, yet creepy and loveable, if all of those things can possibly be said in one sentence. ;) I love the host's voice as well. Plus, she seems so real and genuine.

I love her voice and accent. I enjoy the stories she tells. Short but super enjoyable. From the well known stories to the not so well known. Keep it up!!!

I love the combination of true crime, fairy tales, legends, etc.

I love Sarah's soothing voice and cool re-workings of some older stories. I binged all the episodes last week! Some notes: the Lizzie Borden story was great; I learned voodoo is not witchcraft; someone else loves the movie Ever After; I've been to the Winchester House and it's creepy af, but the Cecil Hotel is a local place I still need to visit. I appreciate a lot about the episodes, including some subtle aspects like how much she can communicate in far less than an hour, and her incredible, empathy-driven, storytelling. For being what seems to be a one-person show, there's A LOT of quality work and audio entertainment here. Keep up the good work! -linzi

Sarah does such a lovely job at telling these stories so beautifully and simply. Her topics are always so interesting, too! You’ll be hooked after your first listen. Wonderful!

I love the mixture of topics, from true crime to just plain creepy stuff. It's fun, fascinating, and covers topics I haven't heard a lot in other podcasts.

This is a great podcast with an awesome host! She has very interesting topics so give it a listen & then subscribe!

Gotta love gruesome info told in such a characteristic manner.

Such an amazingly researched podcast that has a amazing variety of topics. I can't wait to see where this podcast will go. It will definitely be a top podcast!

I subscribed! The host is an engaging storyteller and I've enjoyed the topics of choice so far. I think audio quality is a little poor though and could use a better mic and pop filter. I see a lot of potential here-- looking forward to the rest!

Currently binging on this podcast. I enjoy the short episodes. Perfect for when I have a brief amount of time. I especially like the fairy tale episodes! Keep up the good work, lady!

This podcast is like a snack for my creepy side. Sarah has a great delivery and wonderful accent and I like that she isn't afraid to let her emotions fly. So many podcasts come off as wooden and dry because they are trying to be NPR. I enjoy the interesting take on creepy and weird topics! Make more episodes!! LOL!

This show is entertaining, enlightening, and sounds great! I’ll be sharing this one with all my friends. Keep up the great work.

Keep up the good work!!

A good assessment of spooky themes and subject matter, that delves deep into the respective histories. Sarah gives good NPR voice and it's more to-the-facts than Lore.

Whenever I need a quick and scary listen I always put on Good Nightmare. I love that I'm able to get interesting stories, in such a short time. The host has a great voice and keeps the listener engaged.

There are SO many good things that I could say about this podcast. It is beautifully written and voiced. I could listen to this host for 24 hours, and not get tired of her! Even when she talks about well-known cases or stories, they sound brand new.

This is a very charming podcast with excellent narration. Sarah does a great job bringing her listeners stories that are truly disturbing on the surface, but reveal something even more sinister about what’s hiding in the dark corners of our minds. Highly recommended!