I’m giving the pod a 5 star rating because I’ve been listening for years and have loved every show. My issue is that Eliot refuses to address the D-Jax situation. I don’t care that he made the mistake, but I do care about accountability. Whatever Eliot’s stance is, he should take it. Pretending like it’s not here makes me respect him less and overall hinders my want to listen.

ESP still can’t spend 10 minutes to pronounce words correctly. It’s 2024 and he’s a grown adult saying New Orleans wrong. Along with that hes got his article from 2013. It’s a shame he brings James down. The product was much better with BLG…still respect the two of you but it’s getting tough to get behind Eliot. He says everything as if it’s a fact because he thinks it and is turning into a hot take gasbag…I hope I’m wrong but it’s been rough lately

If I could give this show a 0 star I would. No disrespect to James, I still love ya. But ESP??? I can’t believe he was the reason that DJax career was cut short while his exponentially grew based off of LIES! Long time listener and I’ve now lost all respect for ESP.

The fact he did that, hasn’t apologized or been held accountable is beyond me. How can any eagles fan support this garbage human?

Parks make idiotic hot takes and then relies on gaslighting to make himself seem right to himself only because literally everyone else sees right through his nonsense. James is cool.

Is intolerable. Huge Seltzer guy, love the High Hopes. Go Birds.

“Is that a dessert???” - ESP’s response to hearing of green bean casserole. Brutal

Love the show, I've been a real one for years. The dynamic of James' personality with Eliot's just works. It's fun. But guys...."flexing" to your spouse that you made a call to get windows fixed? Do you guys know you can literally do that yourself?

The Philadelphia Eagles 2024 off-season has been a lot like a terrible window. While a bad window lets all of the warmth out of your home during the winter, the Eagles have let all of the talent leave their team. Call window nation and tell them that Eliot has burned a hole in your brain: window nation, window nation, window nation. (Insert abrupt and loud ad)

Thanks boys, been listening to every podcast for what feels like a decade almost….☝️

I have been a listener since the BGN days. You guys used to put up 2-3 shows a week. Especially in the offseason we’d have draft previews, free agent news, it was great content year round. Now for the past couple months everything is cut audio from Eliots calls, appearances on WIP outside your occasional Saturday show which really doesn’t seem you guys have the same focus. I love you guys and hope you can regain focus a lot of us have been here for awhile.

GOOOOOOOOOO BIRRRDDDDSSSSS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Fly eagles fly!

Eliot Shorr Pop-Culture 100% Sheeple 🤣

I have been a fan of James for awhile now. If this was just James...5 stars all day. Elliot is clown shoes. Elliot is going to be the reason any fan with a working brain cell will stop listening. His takes are clearly designed to be contrarian, because he has no ability to compete with legitimate journalists. Hope the paycheck was worth it guys, you have sold your soul for a guy who wants to make a joke out of being a intelligent fan. Every episode Eliot is presented with facts and rebuts with “my feelings” embarrassing, sounds like a moron.

Love you guys, but maybe don’t spend half an episode whining about the poor media getting attacked by the fans. Great podcast with a generally great conversation. A little bit too much of trying to make more podcasts out of what should be a single one, and audio is poor quality far too often. But all that’s to say, I listen to every (actual) podcast.

ESP is great. The other guy's voice should be used at gitmo.

Dude, I heard you mention you went to the George School! I worked at the Starbucks in Newtown from ‘99-01, perhaps our path’s crossed?!? Did you also have a crush on Bookstore Becky from Newtown Book & Record Exchange?!? Admit it! ✌🏼😎 ROADie listener down in Asheville, NC!

Episodes at times feel like they’ve been written by the Eagles PR Team

The dynamic of James as the fan and Eliot as the journalist/level headed one is laughable. Eliot is a dumb hot take personality with awful taste in anything. Please give James his own show and fire Eliot in sun

The only eagles pod that’s an instant download for me every time but they have to hire better help. This audio is too often unlistenable and it’s a huge bummer. Get that radio station to provide some resources. It’s unforgivable for a podcast of this level.

Guys! I think you’re both great both on WIP and this podcast. But please, Eliot, speak up or turn up your mic or something. Your voice dies out at the end of every phrase. It takes another minute after you to speak to figure out what you said from context. And turning volume up doesn’t work because then James’ voice is so loud it shakes the car windows. Please improve sound mixing so your insightful and fun opinions can be heard!!

I was totally cleaning while listening to the pod when y’all said music over pods while cleaning lol

If Sirianni was fired cause of the players that’s totally fair. They see he doesn’t bring anything to the table to help them. Look at DeVonta, he’s hurt cause he was put in a stupid position by the coaches. And again, there was nothing Sirianni did that was impressive that warranted him even getting the job and we're seeing that now. The longer he stays HC the more we’ll see a decline because more than likely as time goes on he’ll have less talent to work with and if he’s running these simple and unimaginative schemes the team is gonna be bad. Get ahead of the problem and fire Sirianni.

It’s exhausting after a win no matter how close that all you talk about is how the Eagles are going to lose in the playoffs and yes anything can happen but won’t win the Super Bowl give me a break Go Birds win lose or tie birds until I die

Eliot and James are the best. Relatable and engaging. No sports broadcasting dual has better chemistry.

There’s no way your going to go woke with that crap about omg there’s no girls in this movie. We know WIP is a democratic station but to bring it now into the podcast is absolutely ridiculous

It’s so annoying and insulting to Elliot how much James interrupts him. Please, James, let him finish a sentence. Please!!

I like the show but I find it boring how the hosts ALWAYS hold opposing views. Every show is so predictable. I’m guessing that the hosts think that if they agree on the main topic of the show, then that makes for bad radio.

Hey fellas, Eric Fielder here from southern PA. I’m a long time listener/auto downloader. My first time reaching out after 3 years of listening at least(back when BGN was around). I absolutely enjoy the both of your content. Usually love Elliot for his ridiculous takes at times, but this one takes the cake. Elliot’s lack of interest in watching goodfellas inspired me to finally write a review! So congrats flip flops! You actually need to watch this one tho. Like your podcast, it’s excellent. Hope to reach out on WIP soon. But most importantly….F Dallas!

Lads is a great word. My 14 year old son and his pals call themselves the lads. And he hates the Cowboys Dan

Can’t wait for the Niners to show yall how overrated yall are.

Is it ok to wear a cowboys sweatshirt to an ugly sweater party. Had the thought, but don’t feel great putting the sweatshirt on.

It’s funny listening to the balance, the hate james has for ESP movie takes is some of the funniest and most tense situations cuz ESP backs down so quickly. Besides him being a man of great takes I’m a real one and listen to the last second of every pod. Called in a few times and its always love. I love the content you both put out. E the new pod is dope as well I can’t wait till it becomes longer. James keep being great I love your enthusiasm for the eagles o feel like I’m u on the pod lol I love y’all keep killing it

Love to listen, but whoever edits this podcast needs to listen through an episode. I heard like 3 separate 1 minute clips play twice when they shouldn’t have… just easy to fix issues.

I love the passion of this podcast. James needs to STOP constantly interrupting ESP!! It’s hard to listen 😡 please let him finish his thoughts. It’s typical of sports talk radio. I stopped listening because of this last year & will again. 😕

The constant interruptions…it’s unbearable.

James talking over elliot makes this pod bush league. It’s crazy. Is it that hard to have one person talking at a time? I used to love it but find myself listening to other eagles pods because of the cutting off and both of them talking at once.

ESP is the bomb. Very insightful, well spoken, etc. seltzer ruins the show with his frequent high pitch yammering, but NEVER, EVER says anything remotely interesting. I just fast forward when he speaks. Get rid of that donkey and I’ll give your show 5 stars.

I listen for Eagles / football talk. If I wanted to hear about the Phillies I would listen to a baseball pod.

Thought id be listening to the best birds podcast. Also picked an episode that was all about the birds next match up. I think i heard of every single philly team other than the birds. Screw this

Love you guys listen daily and have for a long time. The only thing I can’t stand and I don’t know if any one else notices but sometimes James’ mic/audio sounds terrible. I have to turn you guys down because it’s just really loud and crackly. Not always but sometimes and ESP’s audio is perfect. So idk just something I notice and can’t stand. Other then that keep it going 🦅🦅🦅

Love the pod and have been listening for years. But, I would love it even more if Eliot could get a sentence out without being interrupted.

When Elliot is solo and say he’s Elliot I’m James i have to listen to it 5 more times haha

A friend of mine who would have a destination wedding during the Eagles season is no friend of mine. Seriously you have one job. Go see 17-20 football games per year and give your opinion. A friends out of town wedding doesn’t count as a good excuse

James sometimes shut up and let Elliot talk, other than that great

This is one of the greatest Eagles podcasts and I am a real one and listen to pretty much every episode. However, you are audio professionals and it is so jarring when ALL OF A SUDDEN SOMEONE IS YELLING ABOUT WINDOW NATION! I appreciate all this content being free, and I know you need to earn revenue, but all of your audio professionals are speaking 10-15 dB quieter than the ads. Didn’t the FCC outlaw that kind of advertising? Hey Window Nation, I will never consider your product if your ad is 10 decibels or more louder than the hosts. James or your interns, please strongly compress the WHOLE podcast and review it with earbuds before publishing. My ears will appreciate it and I might consider not hating all of your sponsors. Go Birds.

Could do with less Zoey talk

Ex Bills punter Matt Araiza is out there. Thoughts?

love u dudes but seltzer is a producer—need to adjust the mic levels when he’s bringing his energy! -real one

Just to be clear....I love this podcast. I listen to every episode. Every. Single. Episode. I think James/Eliot both have good football knowledge and have great on air chemistry. However, ESP's tendency to make small things sound like a really crucial thing is really starting to stand out. Today's episode is a perfect example. ESP: my one takeaway from camp....sloppy. Even though two weeks ago he was one of the ones pushing the narrative of "was any eagle having a bad camp?" And he has this take all because of a training camp fight (which are super rare btw and rarely ever happen, especially at a joint practice....lol). Like I get it's not the best look but it sound more like he's trying to make some drama to discuss on the pod and frankly that's just really annoying and obvious when it's happening. But like I said, I do love this pod. I will continue to listen every episode. And I will occasionally vent about this same topic again. That being said: 5 stars