Family Secrets
Family Secrets
Family Secrets
Reviews
via Podcasts
Background music :(
The background music is distracting and feels manipulative - people's stories are powerfully on their own!
Noëlle Close
I used to be a fan
I jumped on tonight because listening to Family Secrets has been a fall thing for me since the beginning. I stopped listening because the stories weren’t intense any longer, just boring authors without a real secret and the ads were ridiculous. I decided to read reviews before listening and I’m glad you all saved my time. Seems like she doesn’t care about her original content anymore. I wish someone else would pick up this idea and have normal people on telling their real family secrets.
Read more
Christiedt
Too many commercials
Waaay too many commercials ruins the podcast. Was not always this way. To make is worse, the movie commercials are evil scary and not conducive to winding the mind down for sleep. Over time more and more added. Would be five stars but with this over load of of hyped, fast-speaking ads it is a three star. Not worth it to listen anymore.
YoBejeweled
We are the Short Family
Why on earth would you keep the family name of a violent rapist? Sad that he would even consider it.
Steve in West Palm
Hi Dani, my name is Kari I need your help with something.
Hi Dani, Can you please write me back, I need some advice on something if you can please write me back. Love the podcast and your books. I am looking for someone. I am on instagram at @karibell2 Thank you Kari
karibell2
Tremendous Blessing
Because of you, I faced my own family secret; Me. This show is soooo moving and grabs my heart every time. I visualize them all and made a friend from an author that you have had on your show. Thank you for your service and continued sharing.
KREWSKontrol
I love the Podcast.
Thank you Dani for shedding the lights on some stories. It provides me an insights to many people lives around us. We always see the tip of the iceberg. But there is more in our lives that we hide.
Fred Rhody
Great podcast
Just wondering if Dani S. is finishing the idea of this podcast n not adding anymore episodes to this remarkable show. We love this show, Dani !!
Claudia, the Teacher
When is the next episode
I love family secrets. It’s therapeutic for me more aware and mindful that all families have family secrets.
TheDesirable1
Not the same
Like many other reviewers here, I’m so disappointed in how awful this podcast is now. I started listening in 2019, and it was absolutely amazing back then. Now, it’s just writers reading passages from their books and telling long boring stories about their childhood. I keep waiting for the big secret reveal in every episode, but it never appears. So long Family Secrets. I’m no longer a fan.
KristliJ
Fewer author stories
This pod used to be GREAT!!! Until she pivoted to all authors. Just bc they write doesn’t mean they have the best, most interesting stories to tell. And TBH a lot of them are…whiny. I would love to hear from your average Joe again, who has the best story. Maybe Dani thinks their story telling is less artistic but I totally disagree.
Ejohnson7
Healing
This podcast has been very healing for me.
cxftygb
Have You Ever Seen A Body Like This
I listened to most of this episode this afternoon and really don’t want to finish. I found Lou to be really repulsive, a man so hollow inside that he could only imitate the looks of others and intimidate his family to convince himself that he was important. Maybe the end of the story redeems him in some way, but I’m not willing to spend another minute hearing about this nothing of a person.
Nicknameless player
Guest names
Interesting show. I wish that the guest names would be included in the episode description.
jhgshhshs
Poor Little Rich Girl
Do you bother to research your guests, or do you just believe every bs story? You should be embarrassed. Belle B is a joke, and so are you!
DeeMean212
I Used To Love This Podcast
…and now it’s so completely boring I can hardly get through each episode and each season this phenomenon seems to get worse. Please go back to what you were doing in earlier seasons when you had more normal/regular people’s stories. Another listener said it best, get some people on to tell their stories, not just read the cliff note version of their “bestsellers”.
Kimber L
Sop for the rich
Is every memoirist a prodigy? The first ten minutes of every episode is someone blathering about how special they were as a child. I’m sure it’s not just egotism. Or the fact that these memoirists grow up rich and catered to. Really disappointing how this podcast is just about rich peoples’ supposed struggles. Oh boohoo my story was criticized in college. Traumatized for life now.
Meh9873
Strangers
As a divorced mother who actually has to work, this episode is so out of touch. You went to elite schools and became a lawyer. You inherited money. You had two homes. Try living off one salary without alimony or child support and having to pay rent that is exponentially more than you can afford. Try paying with pennies to buy groceries because that’s all you have. This episode is a slap in the face to single mothers who are actually trying to make ends meet.
Read more
Check1check2check3
Disconcerting
Hi Dani, in the band of men episode, I heard your laugh while discussing the atrocities faced by these boys, now men. It didn’t sit well. It’s also really disturbing to have the Disney cruise adverts on the episode because of the context. The ad glamorizes leaving your kid in Mickey’s care while adults can go get a massage or have a drink. Then in the testimony you hear what happened to these kids who were left alone in this man’s care.
Read more
luckiley
Instant Binge
Just found Family Secrets and couldn’t stop listening. These stories feel both singular and shared — proof that the most personal truths are often the most universal. Beautifully told and utterly captivating.
With love Janice
Excellent
Family Secrets documents how family histories shape so many lives bringing to light powerful dynamics, generational pain and paths towards healing. I highly recommend.
GAÉ BOOK
More stories less authors
I have really enjoyed listening to this podcast from season 1 until now. I have noticed that there seems to be mostly authors giving cliff notes of their book as of late… I don’t love that as much.
NyrobiJ
The Homeschooled Episode
The Homeschooled episode was incredibly underwhelming. Kept waiting for something interesting to happen, instead the author continued to aggrandize the mundane.
frissjan
Should We Do This
This is my favorite podcast by far. Just finished listening to should we do this and I thought it was so inspiring. She is so inspiring. I just love this story so much.
Lbrooks9
Powerful
Wow ! I just finished listening to WITHOUT TELLING ME for the second time and shared it with so many people. The reason I listened again was because I didn’t want it to end and I wanted there to be more and more. What a beautiful heart rendering true story from the heart. This should be a movie and so right , back those days the family secrets were taken to the grave ! Thank you Dani for sharing , all the best for 2026
Read more
shellsdbn
Powerful episode
I just listened to All Without Telling Me on Christmas day. What a poignant story of your father's second marriage. My father was also married 3 times, the third to my mother. There is so much I don't know about the first two. How helpful it was for Dorothy's sister and others to be able to fill in some of the story of your parents pain. Thank you so much for sharing your family story.
Miller CS
Interesting, but ...
I've listened to Family Secrets since it began. I no longer catch every episode. Curious if anyone has been, or will be, interviewed who is *not* a writer. Nothing against writers at all. But I'd appreciate a larger scope of humanity.
sunshine meadows
Bob Dylan’s potential offspring
The whole point of a secret podcast is to TELL A SECRET I also find the story odd, you don’t “care” if he’s your dad but you’re profiting off people being curious about it ? You want to be a “novelist” but your best idea is some TMZ sort of gossip spun into a heartfelt message? Also it’s not the smartest idea because I thought about buying the book just to find out but with a simple google I was made aware you never do Also, I find it really selfish of his mother that this man just wanted a sense of who his father might be (as do us all) and his mother refused? Even while dying!?! She couldn’t even give him a vague answer like “he might be I don’t know” or “I dont really remember who it could be, it was a one night thing with a stranger” or even “I have a feeling it’s him but I’m afraid for Dylan to find out” some sort of honest answer but to just flat out refuse?does anyone else not find that wild and extremely selfish? She can say all night and say that it was about “finding his path” and “she’s the only parent that matters” because she was there. What I really think it is she knows it could be him and didn’t want to get in trouble or didn’t want to admit her part in any of it. But also rest in peace, I don’t mean to harp on the dead. This story annoyed me so much
Read more
Marbear43
Tangled Up in Blue
Sam’s Mother Story Sam’s mother achieved what all mothers only dream of. His recognition of his mother’s unconditional love, her unwavering values, and her unspoken story, gives him the freedom to discover and to be who he really is. Thank you Dani for bringing this interview to your audience. Your thoughtful questions seems to frequently cause your guests to dig even deeper in their own stories.
Read more
BrCarmen
So is Dylan his father or not?
As listeners, we can’t possibly know what the narrator is really feeling and going through. After that whole episode, we as listeners really wanted to know if his mother revealed if Bob Dylan is his father or not. If not, I find it hard to believe that he doesn’t want to know who actually is. Or if he does know, and isn’t telling the listeners, then this really isn’t about “Family Secrets”, is it? It’s about selling your book, Sam?
Read more
crp7376
I miss the OG - what happened?!
I was an early and enthusiastic listener of this podcast - absolutely loved it and excitedly awaited each new episode and season. I am so disappointed to say that it has gone steadily downhill and now is “meh” at best. I keep waiting for a “turnaround”, but am becoming increasingly disheartened. The title, “Family Secrets” now doesn’t even seem to fit - it would be more aptly titled, “Interviews with Memoirists” as the podcast seems little more than a platform for new writers to promote their work. The most recent, “Baby X”, was so blah that I almost immediately unfollowed. Please (!) return to the OG days of wonderful interviewing and story-telling!!
Read more
BrynneSays
I love Dani, not the ads
I am all for ads and the financial gain. However, this season, I noticed that the ads are on steroids. One of the ad breaks in the episode, baby X, was six minutes long and I didn’t keep track of the others, which were also very long. I am driving when I’m listening to the podcast and it’s difficult for me to bypass the ads safely. If there is a way to reduce the ad breaks or how long they are, this would be a five star podcast. I love it so much. I would be willing to pay for ad free. Dani, thank you for bringing such wonderful stories to our lives and I hope my feedback is helpful.
Read more
ag91011
Echos of my Childhood
Kate Price’s story touched me and brought back some good and bad memories. Everything that she had to overcome in her life would floor most people; she is an admirable person.
CollinsonClaire
One of my favorite podcasts, but…
…was anyone else disappointed by the Season 13 Opener? After waiting all summer and half of fall for the launch, I found myself quite bored.
LS6
Acting on top of acting
There is no middle ground in a genocide. This is not about ethnicity, it is about humanity.
K___r___a
Disturbing and Concerning!!!
Overall I enjoyed listening to this podcast and pop in every so often. However, the Maddie Corman episode was very disturbing. It made me very uncomfortable to hear CSAM talked about like regular p**nography. I also felt that the the husband’s crimes were discussed as though it was just a p**n addiction, which is a big downgrade. There is a big difference between consenting adults and CSAM.
Jaye123
Great content at times, insufferable Host
Hard to listen to Dani at times…
Best game ever and Glitchy
Sadly it’s just not the same
I’ve listened to the podcast from the very beginning and couldn’t wait for the next episode. Although heavy at times with difficult realities, it was great story telling and interesting stories that always resulted in reflection, great empathy, and understanding for others. Now it’s riddled with authors promoting their books and seems to have a very particular agenda. I’ve held on hoping for the show to return to its previous glory but to my disappointment it doesn’t seem that will happen. I’m moving on.
Read more
BrandyK🤩
The Family Business
The show with Sophia talking about The Family Business...what's the name of her book? I can't find it and I don't see a link for it.
Gannettem
Family Secrets has changed to Author’s Secrets
I’ve listened to this podcast since the beginning years ago. There was a nice balance of ordinary, everyday people with their unusual secrets. Now, every podcast secret story involves an author’s manuscript or book release. This podcast has morphed into a book selling promotion. What is Dani’s reasoning? Is she being paid by the authors? I’m done, there are so many other excellent podcasts to choose from now.
Read more
sjtreat
Please link authors’ info in show notes
I can’t exactly say I “enjoy” this show, because it often can be quite heavy, but as someone whose family had a panopoly of its own secrets, I appreciate it. The tone of the show is soothing and, at its best, can be quietly cathartic. My one constructive comment is to kindly ask that Dani please link to the guests’ books in the show notes or on the episode web page. I find that I need to follow breadcrumbs dropped in the episodes to suss out enough info to actually locate and purchase the books discussed. We should not be creating barriers to reading, imo! I’m sure there is a reason for the more opaque approach, but it’s aggravating to this listener.
Read more
RubyMR
What Happened?
I loved listening to this show in the past but it’s drastically different now. The first couple of seasons along with Dani’s own story was interesting. However, the focus on these wealthy & book aligning people with story unrelated to most people is disappointing. Get back to real secrets that most people can understand. In the era of the rich and ultra wealthy blatant cruelty, overwhelming showy consumption at the expense of everyone else while destroying the world no one is interested in their fantastical tales.
Read more
Phd and Brown
Say More and Talk Less, Please! No more whiners!
I have great curiosity, respect, and empathy. I just don’t have all the time in the world. (The 2-part episode with Sarah Willis Fisher may be what ends my listening habit of Family Secrets.) Also the Susan Walter episode was just garden-variety whining. Ugh. This is a podcast, not a therapy session.
Gaithersburger
Who’s The Girlfriend?
This episode was painful. If there was a point it was lost along the way.
Marvelous Marvie 79
Love this show
I love this show. Such a great idea and interviews are always well done. I particularly like that it introduces me to writers and their memoirs. Love memoirs. My only criticism is the seemingly innumerable commercials.
oakhh3
Apropos Autism
Episode from 24 June 2025 is so appropriate and timely to the recently coined “epidemic of autism”. This episode is wonderfully executed, gentle and so very educational. Autism is a spectrum. All the best to the author.
Kdiddlz
Perfect Happy Family?
Another name dropping author, shilling her book, while pretending to be east coast-intelligencia after she drunk her parents koolade about the need to appear “perfect” at all times. This, leading to having to cope with the life and behavior of a messy sibling, which she keeps saying needs to stay “private” within the family. Who are you kidding lady? You were ashamed of Dave as was your whole family, as he was nothing more than a blot on your wonderful, beautiful, intelligent, high status, revered, perfect, family and life. Geez. You sound like all the other idiots I’ve met in nyc who don’t realize they live in a huge ghetto. I couldn’t finish this episode either. Real happiness is not about status or money. It’s about family and helping them, relating to them, having empathy. Boring, boring, boring. I’m out Dani until you go back to the format of season 1.
Read more
frustratedtryingtobuy
One horrible episode!
I LOVE listening to Family Secrets. But I don’t understand what the secret was in the latest episode ‘Happy Family’. It sounded to me like she had a pretty incredible life women and mothers would die for. How lucky she was to be able to stay home with her kids (in San Francisco no doubt). A supportive husband, great childhood, opportunities, etc. we all give up ourselves when we have children. I had to work FT when I had my kids when I wanted to stay home with them. Sad about her brother but depression is in every family! And kids get sick and have problems. There was no secret. Just a wasted hour of listening. Bummer.
Read more
&$)(;:;$@"
Touchstone
A couple of years ago, I was confronted with a mind blowing family secret. And right then, I found this podcast. Processing the facts that had been kept from me at the same time I could check in with Dani and her guests was a gift that kept me sane, made me realize I wasn't alone, and helped me name feelings and manage situations for which I had no play book. Thank you to Dani, and all her guests. Your honesty, insights, and hard won clarity was (and still is) a meaningful and important touchstone for me You helped me meet a very difficult moment with more compassion and kindness than I might have otherwise.
Read more
Highwater Heels
Audio issues?
I’ve really enjoyed this podcast series and Dani’s books. However, the most recent episode had audio problems - I think exacerbated by the somewhat difficult speech patterns of the respondent, Sarah. Her answers were difficult to understand at times. Editing processes should have corrected this.
Formerly Fast
Load more