The guys examine the 100 year old German mystery, of who killed the Gruber family and their maid. The odd facts of the case have led many to believe that their cause of death was supernatural. Could it really be ghosts that killed the Grubers? Or will guys come up with a more plausible solution? We drink every time we mention farm words if you want to play along responsibly, and remember, keep your doors locked.

The Guys tackle the case of The Watcher, a stalker who terrorized the town of Westfield New Jersey as recently as 2017. This episode proves a true crime case does not need to be filled with blood to be terrifying. Will the guys crack this cold case? Definitely not, but they'll name a few suspects and drink a few beers while doing it. Make sure to let us know what you want to see next!  

The guys discuss the  tragic case of Timmy O'Bryan, an 8 year old boy who was killed by poisoned Halloween candy. They talk about the Halloween Poisoner urban legend and the effect Timmy's case has had on the holiday 50 years later. Will the guys name a killer? Or will this be another case that goes unsolved? This week's drinking game is to drink any time we mention candy on the show! Please only participate if you are able to do so both legally and responsibly. Have a happy Halloween!!!  

On the inaugural episode of Criminally Drunk, Jake recounts the tale of The Axeman; a serial killer of who terrified New Orleans 100 years ago. Brendan and Cory join the ride, giving their takes and drinking some beers along the way. Will the guys be able to crack a 100 year old mystery? No, but they might come close!