Criminal
Criminal
Vox Media Podcast Network
Reviews
via Podcasts
My Favorite Forever
This is my favorite podcast to listen to! I am more on the way younger side and I don’t really like podcasts but this one is incredible! I always fine it very intriguing and interesting. I very muchly recommend and enjoy listening to it! There r some episodes that I wish I could listen to but that’s not its fault I just have restrictions because of my age. Otherwise I highly recommend listening to this podcast!!!😊😃✨✨
Read more
#Flag/Singer/Shark#7🌌
“Sort Of”
I could not listen to this Prime Minister episode due to the constant use of “sort of” by the interviewer. Awful!
JR Bones
Great storytelling. Great voice!
My sister and I were just talking about Phoebe’s mesmerizing voice and the obviously in depth research y’all (I’m in Texas) do. I introduced her and some friends to Criminal by forwarding the episode about Butter vs Margarine. Ridiculously interesting. We never knew!
Nobiliwart
Prime minister episode
I love this show and phoebe is a master at story telling but it’s hard to listen when you have guests who use “sort of” And “kind of” throughout their entire dialogue as fillers. It’s very distracting and it takes away from their message
Daliazmama
Interruptions
I couldn’t even listen to a whole story. Maybe here great…who knows. It was constantly being interrupted with stupid ads read in the same flowery voice as the stories.
Maisy1925
I miss the original Criminal
Like others have mentioned, Criminal used to tell the most original and interesting stories. I loved it. I love Phoebe’s voice. But it has changed. It appears you and your team are no longer producing the same quality storytelling that kept me listening
t.m.a.c.
ICE
You should have done a survey to see who you may offend by doing this story. Encouraging people break the law by following/ posting/ and interfering with government officials is wrong. If people were here legally and didn’t break the law or live on government assistance then it wouldn’t have come to this! Do better with your research! How many Americans were killed by illegal immigrants? How many illegal immigrants are on government assistance and hasn’t paid a dime into it and abuse it? Let’s see those facts. Do that research. And you will see why ICE does what they do. Again do better. Thanks in advance.
Read more
1999CARS
Crazy
That please continue is a podcast. It’s the most boring conversation you overhear that you immediately tune out. I love criminal but I’m astounded that anyone enjoys please continue. Stop pushing it on us.
pod2020
Please Continue is a waste of time
I lasted a few minutes. Why? Why? Why should I be interested in random chat about Phoebe’s life? Criminal is such a stunningly well produced podcast. I can’t believe that Phoebe would think like this show has value. I’m really puzzled.
Podcast Evangelist
This show endorses AI now? :(
I used to really love this podcast so I was truly disappointed to hear advertisements for Artificial Intelligence in one of their recent episodes. I don’t know if I can trust a publication that accepts advertising revenue from AI, and that kind of tacit endorsement of something I think is genuinely harming humanity. Come on team, I know you are better than that!
coco_coquine
Love it!
I’ve been listening since 2017 and somehow they keep surprising me with the wonderful, under appreciated stories they find/tell. Thank you so much for making my workouts and dishwashing sessions so enjoyable. I still look forward to each new episode
Addie317
5 stars
My favorite podcast. Wonderful storytelling.
Christine2333333
Why
Why are you being so extra with “dot calm”? You know good and damn well that you’re saying it wrong on purpose just to appear unique, but you’re not unique you just come off sounding like an idiot
Dittyknitty
I’ve been listening since the WUNC days
’ve been listening since the WUNC days and this new format of interviewing journalists who rehash their sun writing is unsatisfying and feels lazy. Please bring back the old Crimibal.
rave.
Donor 106
I just finished listening to the latest episode, Done 106. Outstanding story and piece of reporting! I have *always* loved Criminal, and though I have listened for years, I feel like things have really been cooking lately. Bravo! Thanks for a beautiful show.
Clemmy86
Great content
Interesting and engaging stories. The only note which can be kind of annoying is Phoebe’s odd pronunciation of the letter “o” in some words especially when she says .com which she says a lot.
ALF_86
Skipping a lot lately
Listened since 2019, lately, I have not listened as much. Every episode comes to be about people wrongfully jailed versus all the interesting criminal episodes that used to have me excited for a new episode every week. Seems to be coming very wokeish. It really used to have really unique stories that had me waiting for Fridays next episode. Now I go months before I click on something.
Ka27272
Storytelling or Sermonizing?
I wrote a critical review of Criminal some time ago, after years of being a loyal listener. At the time, I felt the show had drifted away from the thoughtful, curious storytelling that originally made it so exceptional. I worried that the stories were becoming increasingly shaped by a particular political lens, at the expense of the nuance, ambiguity, and genuine curiosity that had once made the podcast so compelling. Over the past several months however, Criminal has consistently returned to the kind of storytelling that made me love it in the first place. The stories feel fascinating for their own sake again. There is room for complexity, strange details, moral ambiguity, history, human nature, and the unanswered questions that make a great story linger in your mind. Most importantly, it feels like the show trusts its listeners again. It presents interesting people and complicated circumstances without constantly needing to tell us exactly what we should think about them. So, consider this my correction: Criminal is back on my regular listening list, and I’m very glad I gave it another chance.
Read more
laqiur22
Missing the firsthand reporting
Love the show as it’s existed for years, but lately every episode has been a replay, an interview with another journalist, or a “bonus” with the hosts talking about their personal lives. What happened to the firsthand reporting we all love?
Sandysnark
Mesmerizing, heartbreaking
As always, a podcast that draws you in, even if it’s often hard to digest. The story of Brian Bechtold is tragic from beginning till right now - how can people support him to break free from psychiatric confinement?
Devonvnoved
Nobody cares
Nobody cares what goes on between the two hosts. I thought this podcast was about criminals snd crime not a stupid reality show that is BORING af. You guys don’t have very entertaining personalities. Stick to the storytelling, thats what ppl come for.
Datintmasta
Wow
“Everyone in this room is now dumber for having listened to it. I award you no points, and may God have mercy on your soul.”
Sinor Jefe
Phoebe's speech patterns detract from the show so much...
I enjoy this show and love the variety of subjects. The depth of research is admirable and very interesting. Phoebe seems like a genuinely caring person. But over time, Phoebe has created pretentious speech patterns that are getting more pronounced and numerous as time goes by. If you listen to some of the earlier shows, you hear her talking in what most of us would call a normal manner. Later on, she says that she was surprised that people were commenting and complaining about her various speech affectations, in spite of how obviously put-on they are. I don't understand why she wants to create this fake voice, when the material is consistently top notch.
Read more
PamTNC
I judge anyone who doesn’t like this show
Like, what is wrong with you? You don’t like thoughtful looks into human experience told in the most soothing voice possible? Thats weird, bro.
Littleworldcunningly
Long-time listener
Host Phoebe Judge and her brilliant team have created the best True Crime podcast out there, minus the gore/sensationalism that most podcasts of this sort are guilty of. The stories are always empathetic, tackle a broad base of crime and are heavily researched. Phoebe’s interviews are both engrossing and she may have the most soothing vocals of any host.
Willa N.
The Best
The absolute best. Examines what does crime mean? Stories are presented with empathy and professionalism. Most are also ok to listen to with my preteen (screened by me first of course). We especially love Animals Really Going For It.
Hoj215
Voice of an angel
I just wanted to say regardless of the story just listening to your voice brings a smile to my face. Your voice feels like home. Your personality is amazing and I am so glad I found you. Thank you for being you!
Tigiloo
best podcast of all time
been listening for 10+ years, the only podcast i’ll ever recommend to others. incredible journalism and storytelling - I learn something new every episode!
emdewdew
Stop with the voice
Her fake voice, lisp, and emphasis on every third or fourth word has gotten progressively worse over the years. Finally unsubscribing because I can no longer bear hearing one more “dot calm.”
PodcastJunkie25
So much to learn
Great podcast. So much to learn about human behavior, crime, and history.
Mfm157
The Reason I Love Podcasts
This is the show that got me hooked onto podcasts 10+ years ago. Phoebe and Lauren should be very proud of themselves - journalism at its finest!! You go girls!!!
LKiffy
One of the best podcasts in this area!
I’ve listed to this podcast since podcasts started and it never disappoints. The stories are so very interesting and not like any other podcasts in the crime genre. Strong recommendation!
dembelkee
🩵
i love this show so much it’s such a treat when it comes out on fridays
Juliet Denbaugh
You and Lauren today
Oh my Gah!!! I love you and Lauren. I love your camaraderie. I love the inflection. I keep hearing and Lauren’s voice and Lawrence said would you get your teeth done if you were celebrity and you were like oh me. Oh my gosh, I’m over here rolling I truly do not like podcast for people chat. I don’t like chatting this. I want the beef of the story. But you guys are changing my mind. I really love you guys together. It’s like your sisters or something. I really think it’s hilarious and when you were talking about the neurosis and you’re like OK refresh my memory and Lauren was like private… Oh gosh, I’m over here loving the heart I sense between the two of you. Although you do make me feel old saying that you’re only 42 because I’m over here at 52. But that’s OK. Carry on you’re wonderful! You’re both wonderful! Thank you.
Read more
Melissa080808
The Experiment, And Other Musings…
I’ve been listening to the show for… years? Has it been out for years? It truly seems like a long time. I enjoyed the show a bit more when it was the silly, strange, unexpected crimes (cough—like the episode that’s only gets released once per year, with the riotous, crimeless crimes—cough…need …more). Good cough; hint cough. Things have been bordering a bit too political, even if it is through a historic lens. I listen to enough current news podcasts, I don’t turn this one on hoping to hear more of the same (except… plot twist… the one you’re unveiling happened in 1805, or 1972, or 1935…). What I did want to say, is that I appreciate you releasing a ‘subscribers only,’ episode for the rest of us—and—well I have yet to finish listening, I am strongly advocating that you do not ask people to attend live shows of personal narratives. We tune in for, exactly that—Criminal, or This is Love—not a memoir (no matter how funny). Please, I do not mean to be rude. Do understand what it is that makes your audience interested in listening to your podcast instead of another. Once you’ve captured that, I would suggest staying in that lane rather than diverting to non-fictional narrative work or pseudo stand-up comedy. (Again, it sounds very rude, and I do not mean for this to sound rude). Experiment, by all means! But remember why we listen each week.
Read more
K.S. in the PNW
No
The fake stuttering is like nails on a chalkboard. Unfortunately many of us cannot listen to this podcast because of it.
Denirui
So engaging!
I truly enjoy the stories that Phoebe shares. As well, her voice is phenomenally hypnotic. I think I’d listen to her read the phone book (for those of you old enough to understand that reference). All joking aside, “Criminal” is a very engaging podcast. And yes, sometimes she shares quite gruesome stories, the way that she shares them truly pulls the listener closer & closer. Congrats Phoebe! You are amazing at your craft.
Read more
SPWilds
Great stories, voice kills me
Amazing stories, so well researched, but the SNOBBISH VOICE. I hate the fake stutters, dot calm, everything about it. Nails on a chalkboard to my ears. Sounding so forced and academic
🍭🐞
Engaging and Entertaining
Phoebe and the Criminal team are so skilled at bringing out the human aspect of the stories they cover. There is such an array of topics from intense to humorous, current to others well in the past. All are engaging, immersive and told with heart. Phoebe’s way of inquiring is both sensitive and to the point.
Snoslyde
Phoebe is amazing
Phoebe has an amazing voice and she explains things amazingly so everyone can understand what happens.
MHA lover123
Unfortunate
Thought Pheobe and Lauren were chill…then I heard on the ep today they’re doing ads for AI? I’m super disappointed, it gave me the biggest ick and I honestly don’t think I can listen anymore. I really thought they of all people would be on the right side of this…guess I was wrong.
carnivore59
My Number One Reccomendation
This is my absolute favorite podcast. It is so well put together and well researched. I do not understand how production is able to release episodes this often. Phoebe has the most incredible way of telling stories. I love how different each story is, it’s such a unique format.
E Murd
:)
I keep putting off the show for a bit but every once in a while i like to come back and listen to new stories
MyBrainDoesntBrain
That voice!!!
How do people get past the super annoying voice and actually listen to the story????
anilkapg
“DA-HT CALM”
The originality of the stories shared and intricate telling stand out in this genre. However, I MUST warn my fellow sensitive people that the host’s voice (especially her particular way of saying dot com) can be very annoying when too repetitive, or when she speaks more than the subjects. Someone else said she cannot stand the “Miss Priss” voice, and it’s valid. Also valid, is the way PJ verbally recoils awkwardly and honestly, snobishly, while visiting the Texas body lab. My mom died of ALS and donated her body to science, and it was really off-putting to hear PJ being so disgusted about the research. Do better, but keep up with the original stories. Thanks!
Read more
lahaland
Absolute favorite podcast
Well written and produced and I love that the stories are usually are less straightforward crime or there’s something unusual about them
ardilicious
My favorite podcast in the world
I genuinely love this podcast so much but the only thing is there are so many repeat episodes especially because I love the show I go back and I listen and so I’m always so excited for a new story so sometimes it’s kind of the same story again other than that love the work, even went to see the live show!
dggesd
To Love or Hate a Podcast
It’s as simple as that. You’re either going to love or hate this podcast. Not because of the content - if you have any interest in true crime or history, you will be interested enough. What will either hook or repulse you is the host’s voice. Some people find it as soothing as “warm fudge.” Others find it pretentious and affected. The content is great, despite the constant reruns of old episodes. I binge this show once a year because I could not tolerate it on a regular basis. “Dot calm” will either seem a cute quirk or nails on a chalkboard. Don’t subscribe to Plus to solve that mystery - the host claimed to have been unaware she was doing it until listeners pointed it out. There was merch about it. That’s it. That’s the review.
Read more
ToucheDeF
Cecilia
Thank you for sharing Cecilia’s story and journey. ❤️
PNWgenxlibgramma
Her Voice Made Me Think It Was Satire
The stories are good so I’m going to try really hard to quit hyper focusing on why the hell this lady talks like that. What a distraction from great material. And I’m pretty sure she has to try to be that annoying. Why would you intentionally ruin a good product? No one’s natural speech pattern sounds like this.
Bgisurja
Load more