Creeps and Crimes
Creeps and Crimes
Taylar Fetzner, Morgan Harris | Para Pods
Reviews
via Podcasts
thank you for the turkey sandwich
I've already done the whole review thing back in the earlier days of listening but all I can say is I've been here for years and I'll be here forever. This podcast isn't just listening to two people talk about different cases, it's yapping with besties, sharing their lives and hard truths and I've never been more thankful for this community you have both built and allowed us to be a part of. Love ya besties šŸ’œšŸ©·āœØ
Read more
Samm Sebastian
Best podcast
My favorite podcast EVER, started listening since March and totally binged every episode. Feels like I’m just listening/hanging with my besties šŸ’—
Hey_jesseeee
great true crime and creepy podcast!
absolutely love the pod morgan and taylar! I love podcasts that feel like you’re hanging out with friends while getting a creepy story!
zooweeonmymama
Amazing Listen Every Time
The hosts are engaging and fun. Their pre-story chitchat and stories they cover makes C&C by far the best podcast and a joy to listen to. The new episode drops immediately go to the top of my listen list.
Sktlnd4evr
Love this pod!
Fun and cozy like cuddling up under a fuzzy blanket with a glass of wine sharing gruesome horror stories with your besties
MAYASS
Yikes.
If you want to listen to a podcast of Taylar constantly talking over Morgan, this is it!!
Janooce
This is my second favorite pod cast
Of two. I’ve tried listening to several podcasts casts, listen to a few episodes, and lose interest. The first one I actually listened to was ā€œAnd That’s Why We Drinkā€. I fell in love with it and finished binging it a few months ago. One of the last episodes I listened to when catching up involved Morgan, and so I started at ep 1 on Creeps and Crimes. Love you girlies!!! Only #2 because I love Em and Xtine. Still 5 stars. I’m currently listening to EP 147. Keep up the amazing work!!!!
Read more
Geojustin83
Creepy and Crimey Besties
YoYo found my besties from ATWWD podcast!! Been listening since October 2025 and now I’m on episode 50!! I am obsessed with the intro especially hearing Mila I assume and Ollie the CEO’s. I love Morgan’s creepy side and as a survivor of rape appreciate Taylar’s emotions come through when she cries. Our only conflict is I’m an Auburn fan but that’s it! Can’t stop won’t stop being a fan of these amazing girls. Keep the banter and never change the format please!! Team CNC ā¤ļø
Read more
NKOTB-FAN
10/10
As a girlie who consumes lots of conspiracy, paranormal, and true crime content through many pods, C&C is definitely at the top of my rotation. And the occasional casual chats about gardening really sealed the deal for me. Oddly satisfying combo that I didn’t know I needed. Thanks Taylar (with an A) & Morgg (double the G) <3
itsbrittanyb!tch
Don't go unscripted
I understand that it is all unscripted, but if all you're going to say is like, maybe you should have a script. I listened to the Disney one that's behind they scenes and waited for 17 minutes until they started the podcast. All they were talking about was patreon and weird inside jokes. Do not recommend. 😢
Katiem1025
Love you guys!
I found C&C through atwwd and absolutely love them and enjoy the banter. Keep up the great work!!
Priestessoftheplains
love these gals
been a listener for YEARS. can’t believe i’m seeing political discourse over this podcast. they’re goated, hoes mad šŸ™šŸ½
liberalbaddie
Just another liberal podcast
Way to be original šŸ™„ just want to be popular.
RenegadeGrenade
So much fun!
Found you ladies through ATWWD. I’m glad I gave it a shot. You’re so sweet and funny and I enjoy the stories you both do. Thank you!
slndn
Love, love, LOVE
Still working my way through the back eps (finally in the 200s) but I love these ladies.
CourtneyAnaWho
⭐ Found My New Favorite Podcast Besties
I found Creeps and Crimes after listening to ATWWD and I’m honestly so glad I did. Taylar and Morgan feel like the besties I didn’t know I needed. Their chemistry is amazing, they’re hilarious, and they somehow make even the creepiest stories fun to listen to. I’ve already binged over 100 episodes (which says a lot), and it’s one of those podcasts that makes you feel like you’re just hanging out with friends while hearing wild stories. If you love true crime, creepy stories, and hosts that actually feel real and relatable this podcast is it! Love you guys … never stop!!
Read more
Cherrybomb08
i’m new here & LOVE IT
can’t even believe how long it took me to find this pod but I love yall!
I WANT THE BEST FRIEND LIST
BESTIES
I just love you gals.!!! I truly feel like y’all are my sisters. I love the rants, I love Taylar’s sideways talks. Morgan, I just adore you! You guys remind me so much of my best friend and I. Your research on both the creeps and crimes always has me HOOKED… once I’m up to date on the currents episodes, ya girl will be apart of the OG Pickme cult.!! Love ya, always.!
Kammii16
It’s a shame
This could have been a great podcast until they wanted to play politics and throw their liberal garbage around. Why can’t these podcast just stick to podcasting. I’m sure you’d have a much larger following if you did. But hey when they only have a certain population listening to their garbage maybe they will wise up.
Stolen/recovered
Stories are enjoyable, but the pronunciations are atrocious
I started listening to this podcast at episode 1, now on episode 54, after hearing a joint episode done with ATWWD. I had such high hopes for this podcast, but 54 episodes in and listening to the two of constantly mispronounce everything (multiple times in an episode) or not even attempt some words is super disappointing. I want to like this podcast, I genuinely enjoy the stories being told, but it’s so hard to listen to these episodes. I’m reallllly hoping it gets better as it goes on.
Read more
Desert Mermaid
Awesome show
Absolutely love these girls!! Their friendship is adorable and I love listening to their stories!
Oking3
Creeps and crimes is the best
Best podcast EVER! Just binged all episodes
Mdawg10283
Obsessed!!
Love Taylar and Morgan!! Lots of banter but fabulous show!
Unucnifmi
OBSESSED!!! Can’t stop
I can’t stop listening!! Keep it coming
Bayribel
LOVE
love these girls. 10/10 if you love banter
03358874322
Love!
Love the pod! I’m here from ATWWD!
KLou18
top tier podcast
i love these girls so much
Makalexis
LOVE THIS SHOW
One of my faves! Please give us more EnterTEAments!!! Also love the struggle on pronunciations cause same lol šŸ¤£šŸ’—
tab_29_tab
My new fave
I’ve listened to thousands of true crime episodes, so I’ve heard plenty of repeat cases, but Taylar always delivers something new. Her research and storytelling go far beyond even some of the biggest podcasts, and I truly think it honors the victims and their families. Same with Morgan…repeat topics are never a skip, and I always finish an episode knowing more than before. Their banter is also a plus- they’re my besties and don’t even know it. Love you girlies!
Read more
JenC530
You guys keep me sane
Started from the BEGINNING and I only am on creepy accounts Vol.4 ANYWAY you gals are incredible, respectful and absolutely make my day! Found you guys from ATWWD. Also I did in fact skip the Peggy portion cause as it began the WAVE of nausea I got…no thanks. Nonetheless I can’t wait to one day catch up to present day episodes but I’m so happy to have so much to listen to on my early morning drives to shifts at Starbucks šŸ«¶šŸ¼ā¤ļø keep thriving, and give yourselves some love cause yall deserve all the love!
Read more
bellaace9
These are my girls!
I love these ladies so much. So funny, so relatable, so smart, so pretty. Not sure if I want to be them, be their friend, or be with them but either way I’m sat and listening to every word.
rachwolf22
Heartfelt, funny, real
I’m still listening to the most recent episode and Taylar’s story is heartbreaking. You did not need to share this but I’m there are many people who will feel less alone because you did. I just started listening because of the crossovers with ATWWD and have enjoyed the few eps I’ve heard. Yall are funny, and so real - sending love and I’m digging into the back archives with excitement ā¤ļøā¤ļø
Brjgifoeisbdifi
Go to podcast
I started listening to Creeps and Crimes after a client told me about it, and I got hooked fast. Taylar and Morgan make you feel like you’re just hanging out with their friend group, and it’s so easy to get pulled in. They research and cover their cases really well, they’re fun to listen to, and it’s become one of my favorite podcasts.
karlyrhode
Besties in my phone
Love the pod and you two girls so much! I’m so appreciative of how well you girls handle not only all of the cases, but any topic, laid back or sensitive. The love you two have for each other and everyone else around you shines so bright, I’m so appreciative to have found this podcast and be able to follow the growth of it and your guy’s lives. 🄲
Calllieeefornia
Taylar we love you.
I just listed to the intro to the most heartbreaking, yet heartwarming and honest episode that the girls have ever done. Not only do I love this Pod because of the Stories but also because it is like talking to my best friends. My heart is also with Taylar after the loss of Jacky. We love you.
StephSteph38
I LOVE IT
Discovered this pod when Parapods picked it up and I cannot explain how much I love it. Yall are hysterical and I could listen to you talk about anything
maaaaadddzz
Meh
First heard of Creeps and Crimes from ATWWD and decided to give them a listen. Love the creeps portions with Morgan! Now that I’m almost 40 episodes in and it’s like all Taylar does is re-tell everything Christine and Em covers on ATWWD. She uses them as a source for almost every episode, along with Crime Junkie. Might be a good listen for others, but as someone who listens to other true crime podcasts, I can’t stand to listen to someone who just takes things from other podcasts. šŸ¤·šŸ¼ā€ā™€ļø
Read more
MeloFromHI
Pronunciations
I heard about yall from ATWWD and I’m on episode 47 right now (Ted Bundy). I understand some mispronunciations, but good gravy I sincerely hope that gets better the longer you do this. Also hope that the show evolves to where you aren’t just covering every topic ATWWD has done. I love ATWWD too, but I’m sure you can find other cases to where they aren’t constantly a source.
CasscityB
I love this podcast!
Creeps and Crimes is one of my go to podcasts to listen to. Taylor and Morgan are the perfect blend of true crime/ conspiracy and lighthearted fun stories. I found them through a cross over with ladies and tangents and haven’t stopped listening since!
Allycat032
New favorite
Love this podcast-thank you and that’s why we drink! Started from the beginning and listen everyday at work
joaniekcain1996
I’ve never left a review before but…..
I found you all through And that’s why we drink….. but I have literally skipped all my regular podcasts to binge listen to you all . I love that you guys are real and match so many of my mid-line political and religious views. I live in Nashville and I feel like I would love to hang out with you all.,, even if I may be a tad bit older šŸ˜‚šŸ˜‚ I haven’t caught up to your recent episodes but I hope you guys always keep up the fun, genuine, down to earth vibe that I love already!
Read more
Vickieriverd
The pronunciation…
Look I know not everyone is good at reading scripts or pronouncing words. But those people should consider other careers that don’t have to do both of those things constantly. I can’t get past it, I hope they take time to learn their words in the future.
Cmmch45
The best true crime podcast
This is my fav true crime podcast not only are the girls so relatable also being a true crime girly in their 20’s but they make sure to always be respectful to the victims and their families when telling their stories and spreading awareness. Hands down the best!
Alexa McHugh123
PHENOM!!
I have been listening to yinz (fellow metro Pittsburgher!) for years!! I’m a momma of three girls and this podcast helps me retain the little sanity I have left and got me through two rounds of PPD/PPA. Thank you for your genuine and authentic humor, humility and honesty! It’s so rare and refreshing!!
Dafterlife
LOVE, LOVE, LOVE!
Listening from Utah and found Taylar on TikTok. I haven’t stopped listening since! My absolute favorite podcast. I feel like I’m hanging out with my favorite girls every time on my way to work and I never stop laughing. Keep being real and down to earth girlies. #teamCRIME. šŸ˜
shaniahkim
Funny
So I love true crime podcasts and ā€œscary storyā€ podcasts and drive a distance to/from work so I’m always looking for new ones AND coincidentally came across yours from your XC clip that made me LOL so much (I’m a XC mom ~ retired 🤣🤣~who also just had my kiddo experience Rush as a sophomore from the inside (she was like~WTH is this? So weird from the other side) so the first episode I clicked on, you talked about being a ā€œrush momā€ AND how you made so many people mad with your XC clip! I just wanted to let you know I think you’re hilarious and you gained a new follower completely from that clip. And I LOVED the Rush take too! So freaking funny! Also, as many podcasts as I follow, this is my first review. You guys are great!
Read more
KJCutt
The best WOOmen ever. ā¤ļø
Taylar and Morgan are so sweet and make you feel like you are apart of their lives even though they have never met you. I am apart of their OG PickMe Cult on Patreon. I will never drop them. I will always support them. Love you girls forever.
LoganRios
Give them a listen one of my favs
GG GG Absolutely love these girls! They always make me feel like I’m their bestie. Also definitely get their Patreon so worth it!! šŸ˜šŸ’•
RyeBread_18
The BEST podcast!
Taylar and Morgan are amazing storytellers. I love when they go feral and their random rants. I’ve listened since season 2, and have officially caught up on all episodes. These girls are great and relatable. Good game girls!
RubyJean2010
🫣
Girly girls, please don’t hate me. I am an OG, Patreon member, and you’ve used multiple of my TBB submissions... But the lack of consistency lately (on both platforms) makes listeners feel like an afterthought. It’s disappointing.
Aye Peaaa
Load more