Every week these Jay and Tony explore a new paranormal topic to discuss the claims, theories, and stories that surround them. Jay, the believer, brings first-hand accounts of the insane conspiracies to talk about the possibilities and secrets that may have been kept from us for years. While Tony, the skeptic, digs deep into the history, their sources, and their validity to try to find just how many of these "facts" can be believed. They may not agree on much, but they definitely have a good time fighting about it.