Reviews
via Podcasts
Great show
I love your show! It’s intelligent, well researched and very respectful. I’m from Wisconsin and lived in Appleton when Laurie Depies disappeared. I always wanted to know if her case had moved forward.
I look forward to listening to more of your programs.
Stevens Point Girl
just great
Just recently discovered this podcast love you very much. Very easy to listen to and very informing and entertaining. Would highly recommend for all you’ve been westerners. keep up the good work.
Dominic Aces
Awful
These guys must say the same thing 100 times. They repeat themselves over and over. In Episode 10, literally immediately after recapping all the “evidence”, they say “let’s recap the items we’ve found.” Riddled with grammatical errors and they frequently make misstatements (saying October when they clearly mean August). Very poor editing and these guys do NOT know how to construct a podcast.
T2JSC
Binge worthy
Just finished Season 2 in one day. Hosts handle the homicide case and the role of forensic anthropology in a calm, thorough and thoughtful way. Hoping they return for more Seasons. I listen to a lot of true crime pods; this was one of the best. I learned a lot.
Tune inner
B. O. R. I. N. G.
Hosts DRONE on and on and on and on…get it? Plus, the first episode was 13+ minutes of just themselves!!! Their voices have little inflection, enthusiasm and intonation. Very hard to listen to even tho I wanted to hear the story. Can’t go on.
zsazi
fact check
It was Michael Douglas, and Sharon Stone, not Richard Gere.
Boo-booo1
Nurse
Too much talking.. omg! Terrible!
ssns112
Excellent
The guys do a great job covering this case…very detailed and not overly speculative. Growing up in the Fox Valley and being a teenager at the time of Laurie’s disappearance, this case has always been close to my heart and she comes to mind often. I’m grateful you guys are covering it.
SuperRegularMom
Wisconsin ❤️
Love this podcast! Think about doing Connie Boelter next - such a weird, crazy story.
jessicagbach
Interesting but redundant
Interesting content but the hosts do all the talking. I’ve heard other podcasts like this one that play clips of court recordings, interviews, etc. to vary the voices heard in each episode. It gets a little redundant just hearing the same two voices the whole time. (It also sounds quite scripted which also gets annoying.)
dilouley
Free Lectures from the real deal Professor K
My major at UWO wasn’t anthro, but the best classes I had were Anthro classes with this professor. I’m stoked to be able to listen to a dense interesting anthropology podcast and furthermore I do not know of anywhere else you can find in real time cases being worked on by a professional anthropologist and see cases and even a body hunt come to a close. It’s just amazing this sort of thing actually exists and it really makes me feel proud that it’s from my own alma mater. Cheers professor! I hope this review helps to spread the pod and provide at least enough revenue for you to crack a juicy IPA on me albeit not in a very direct way hahahahaha God bless!
Read more
Ron Wood0101
Bravo!
The way they cover these cases is great! I love their deep dives and being a Northeast Wisconsin resident my entire life these are cases I can remember the news coverage on.
Rhondarae7
Excited for season 2!
These guys are so passionate in what they do- I’m excited to see how they use their skills in hopefully solving this new case!
lizkarsten
Needs an Editor!
Starts out interesting, then several of the last episodes are nothing more than the hosts going on about technical stuff; I skipped most of each of those. Really who cares “how” you search an area for human remains. That’s a whole different audience.
Hed-Mat
They found him!
They found Starkie at high Cliff state park this September. We need a podcast update!
catfishjon777
Starts well but drags later
The first few episodes that outline the case are quite interesting. After that, it becomes long-winded, repetitive, and boring. Not much happens, frankly. The last half of the season could have been compressed into one or two episodes.
Nick Naque
Drones on
Starting to wonder if the 89 previous reviews are just students of the host. Feels a bit self-promotional starting with the excavation. Debating on whether I have the patience to see what happens. Might just fast forward.
mcslem
Highly compelling and masterfully done
Dr. Jordan Karsten and Matt Hiskies have produce a highly compelling narrative concerning the mysterious disappearance of Starkie Swenson. Despite being so new, this podcast easily matches the quality of the top True Crime podcasts in the country. Cold Case: Frozen Tundra outperforms it’s competitors in that it’s hosts are actually involved in the search for Starkie, armed with knowledge, case details and interviews that the average armchair podcast host would not be able to obtain. This highly unique True Crime series, which allows listeners to follow along in almost real time as Dr. Karsten and his team are in the field searching for Starkie is an experience no listener will soon forget. If you like true crime and want to be as close to the action as you can as the mystery unfolds, look no farther than Cold Case: Frozen Tundra.
Read more
JDRP777
Can’t wait to hear what happens next...
After every episode I am on the edge of my seat to know what comes next! Dr. Jordan Karsten and Matt Hiskes tell the story in a way that leaves me always wanting more. They are funny, informative, and share all the details of the case to really make you think about what could have happened. I can’t wait to hear when they start searching for Starkie’s body!!
msg30
Great New True Crime!!
I LOVE anything suspenseful and true crime related! This real crime story has you on the edge of your seat to see how this all unfolds! I can’t wait to find out what happens next! I look forward to new releases weekly. Dr. Jordan Karsten and Matt Hiskes know how to keep the listener engaged and wanting more of this case!
melmcel14
Hit that subscribe button! It’s a good one!
If you’re into cold case stories, murder stories, missing people, death or all the above! Subscribe to this super rad Podcast! It will definitely have you intrigued and stoked to keep listening!
RKY&NKO
Great Pod
Can't wait to see how the story unfolds!
Biggs___
Hook. Line. Sinker. Subscribe, folks!
This Podcast blew my expectations out of the water. Dr. Jordan Karsten and Matt Hiskes are phenomenal story tellers. It’s blatantly obvious how invested they are in the Starkie Swenson case. I’ve been an avid podcast listener and true crime junkie for years; I can say with confidence having an anthropologist and a communications major as hosts brings this podcast to a whole new level. Knowing Matt and Jordan are backed by an entire community (law enforcement included) I cannot wait to see where this story goes. Hook. Line. Sinker!
Read more
SarahDee77
More please!
I am hooked and want more! Truly leaves you with a what next feeling. I am fully vested to this podcast.
OneLoveGB
Cold case; 🔥 podcast
A thoroughly gripping podcast, and that’s based on the trailer alone!
deurtee
Cold case: frozen tundra
This is incredibly good. Can’t wait for next episode!
reggiehicks
Awesome case!
Very interesting case with great commentary! 💥
thiskes11
