When Brewster High’s beloved Ultimate Frisbee star mysteriously disappears, a group of students start to suspect that the story they’re being told about their team's First-String Disc Boy is a lie. With an intrepid reporter for the school paper leading the charge, they decide to do some digging, eventually uncovering a number of suspicious threads about the school administration that don't quite add up—a sports gambling ring; a dangerous gang of bikers (okay, cyclists); and a torrid student-teacher affair. As our crew gets more and more consumed by their quest for the truth, their personal lives crumble and our fearless leader, Clara, becomes completely unhinged.