Reviews
via Podcasts
Unnecessary AI
I really want to hear this story, but why use AI voices? Why not pay voice actors to read the words? Disappointing.
ac2297
Booooo A.I
I had to stop listening at episode 4. The show mentions the use of A.I ever 5 seconds. Not only does this disrupt the telling of the story, but it’s abhorrent that the producers would opt for A.I rather than a voice actor. Do better.
Megh765
We ❤️ Becky
I think her drug of choice is drama??
But It’s true. Please Stop taking opportunities away from creatives and giving them to AI
Nadyyyyyyyyya
Why the ai voices??
I listened to several episodes and wanted to keep going, but the use of the AI generated voices finally got to be too much for me. Especially when used for the podcast host and another producer for a text exchange…you’re already recording your voices, that seems like a very weird choice. Having a voice actor, or even one of the producers read Coco’s posts and any other voices would’ve been a much better choice than generative AI for the sake of generative AI.
Read more
KH1291
Too much AI
Overall an interesting, well told story. But there was not only a lot of generative AI use, but the overly gushing about "isn't this AI SOOOOOO good" by the host was very off putting.
Bri0404x3
Interesting story, unfortunate use of AI to read…
This podcast is very interesting and tbh I binged the entire thing in a couple days. I will say I haaaate that they use AI to not only speak Coco’s posts, etc, but to literally speak the hosts text messages. I hope they read the thousands of comments hating on the use of AI and don’t do this going forward.
Olive_4766
Good reporting and presentation…
But I couldn’t get the chronic vocal fry past me. Couldn’t get to episode 2.
Modern Spinster
Not supporting AI over working actors
While it seems like a compelling and well produced podcast based on my short listen, I can support materials that are pushing out working people in favor of AI content. I appreciate the host stating up front that they are using AI generated voices to read social media posts, which gave me the information I needed to make this choice not continue listening to the whole series. Please support working artists in all mediums
Read more
doodledood4578
AI voice unethical and also not very good
This would have been a top tier scam podcast if not for the unfortunate use of an AI voice. Others have already noted the poor ethics of this, so I’ll focus on the other side of the issue, which is that it sounds bad. Coco herself has a very distinct way of speaking that is not represented by the AI voice at all. The AI sounds like a “snarky” American millennial and the host regularly has to step in to note that the tone the AI is taking is not appropriate to what Coco’s writing is trying to convey. It was really distracting and made the podcast seem cheap and lazy.
Read more
lambinawoolsweater
Stop Using AI
Voice actors exist, don’t understand the need for AI. IMMEDEATE UNFOLLOW.
JuanM3n
Wanted to like it
I wanted to like it and it started out promising but the random biases and tangents lost me. The obvious biases against the LDS church were unnecessary the plot. The ways of describing things like ‘fast Sunday’ that didn’t even pertain to the storyline were done with complete skeptical tones.
And it felt like the inclusion of OUR was just to include Lynn Packer since Coco and Tim Ballard don’t want to actually affiliate with each other. It was such a weird tangent.
I just didn’t end up feeling like I could trust the narrative because of the obvious biases even though I initially really wanted to.
Read more
thepapas02
Have the Epstein Files Taught Is Nothing?
I’ve been enjoying this podcast up until the denial of everything we are currently learning to be true from the latest release of the Epstein Files. Pizza was mentioned how many times in the latest 3 million files?
In2sea
Good story turn woke agenda
Seriously discrediting sounds of freedom? That’s what you’re using your podcast time to talk about? It sounds like yall interviewed only people to push your agenda. This rabbit hole of you debunking those trying to raise child trafficking harm is not necessary to debunk her claims of being trafficked. Things don’t have to be so black and white. Just because the right is trying to stop child pedos and trafficking doesn’t mean any left winged person has to go to the extreme opposite. This is a wild world man and wish you guys could have stayed on topic instead of bashing many people who are working for a good cause.
Read more
Sarah Bayles
Great Listen
I usually only listen to podcasts when I travel for work but I couldn’t wait for my next work trip to finish this podcast. Love the methods and reporting done by this podcast!!
Mags1128
Good Listen Overall
Overall appreciated the investigative journalism here. the ai slop was annoying, Like yall couldn't pay your cousin or some random off the street 20 bucks to read lines? It doesnt sound good. Not worth the water wasted. Placement of ads was also annoying, some episodes cutting in where it doesnt make sense. I understand ppl need ads but most podcasts make it more seamless and less disruptive. The order of storytelling was also interesting going back and forth across episodes between timelines and old characters and new characters, couldve been more cohesive. Side note: also wonder why coco didnt get hit with wire fraud from the IRS like scamanda did...
Read more
@OffbeatSheHulk
Finally
The amount of actual investigation and fact checking was such a nice throw-back to pre Google days.
More of this please
Brach0403
Gets worse each episode
It starts as a pretty informative, fact finding report but develops into grown women literally laughing at and making fun of someone who is clearly suffering from not only Borderline Personality Disorder, but likely other mental illnesses as well. And then she spends time in her episode to say that human trafficking statistics are being blown out of proportion for political purposes?!?!? WHAT? And of course a young NYC reporter would never pass up an opportunity to throw a jab or two at Trump, who the media has managed to turn into the next anti-christ.
This one is not worth the listen.
Read more
Laleesha
Please hire an actor- no need for AI
I can tell a lot of time, effort, and energy went into creating this podcast. The story is compelling, however it was a constant disappointment to be reminded that instead of doing the right thing and hiring a professional voice actor to reenact certain parts of the story, AI was used instead. In a world where there are so many professionals out there, there is no need to support an industry determined to take away jobs from talented and skilled humans. Scamanda producers used a paid professional actor for their podcast seasons, there’s no reason why other production companies can’t do the same. If you can pay for a forensic psychologist, you can hire an actor.
Read more
bonnie25
You used AI, we get it
I'm 4 episodes in and it's a really gripping story, but if I hear "we used AI to clone Coco's voice/our conversation, etc. one more time, I may have to quit listening. We get it, you used AI for some voiceovers. The disclaimer at the beginning of EVERY EPISODE is enough. Good lord. Hope you're getting paid every time you say "AI"
LLLPIX
Pretty Good
She attends the morman church because if you don’t have a job and are dedicated to the church they will pay your bills and rent.
KKNEIL77
6/2/2025
I know somebody wrapped up in her now!
Blink Blink Babe
whoa!! stinger ending!
believable was really well done and i enjoyed it a lot. the last few minutes of the last episode actually made my jaw drop. wasn’t a big reveal, wasn’t anything wild, just REALLY good producing to leave you on a bit of a cliffhanger.
wish that there was more justice for the victims :(
downtownaustin
Too much AI
Overall a solid podcast. Could definitely do without all the AI voice clones though.
KyleeHazs
Interesting story
Overall, this story is interesting and well researched. Anyone who has liked swindled, scamanda, and the likes will enjoy this.
I do agree with other reviews that the jumping to conclusions about Gregor did bother me (language translation is never perfect & I don’t really know many people who keep documents for 15+ years so? I don’t understand how that was weird to all of them). It’s super weird to be cutting slack to someone you made a whole 12 episode podcast about but then make someone else out as suspicious after one interaction.
But everyone has bias and everyone is entitled to their opinion, so that’s why I still rate it very high and still enjoyed it very much.
Read more
sunflowed
Great binge!
Listening while on an 8 hour car ride. Captivating.
Human6757
Excellent
I really need this to be a Netflix docuseries! Great story. Great reporting. Very well-done
Shy one 1000
Excellent
Excellent research, reporting, and production and a fascinating story. Highly recommend.
Amazingrace76
Riveting
A riveting psychological profile - I binged it
crazy_traveler
Loved this!!!
This story is absolutely shocking and utterly addictive! I found myself eagerly anticipating each new episode. The gripping details kept me completely captivated. It's astounding to think that someone like this could actually exist and evade justice for such selfish crimes. My heart goes out to all the individuals she exploited, and I can hardly wait to hear where she is now and what other scams she is involved in!
Read more
Gelaheath
Don’t waste your time
In the end, the hosts make scurrilous insinuations unsupported by evidence about the mother’s boyfriend, even though Coco is a proven liar. They suggest that the fact that he doesn’t have written evidence of his innocence is suspicious. This is clearly an unjust approach to judging him. The uptalk and vocal fry are extremely irritating. They go to Germany and leave a letter at the wrong address without an envelope? Seriously unprofessional behavior. Honestly, I’m a woman and a feminist, and this podcast is embarrassing for all of us.
Read more
Jo2653
Unnecessarily Hype About AI Voice
I thought the reporting was fine and very in depth. My problem was the AI voice recording and the need to talk about how great it was. I don’t understand why they had to use it for reading their own text messages and why they couldn’t have had an actor or someone in their production read the text messages and posts instead. Honestly I would’ve rated this higher if they’d used voice actors, because it was a really good podcast.
Read more
ldow1991
Host Voice
The host has vocal fry and talks so slow! But still interesting story.
HankPank19
An inconclusive unsatisfying story
To summit up quickly these reporters did a ton of work on this and didn't get to a conclusion. But they went and did the podcast anyway to justify all the work they did. Understandable. But it's like writing a movie for two years and then never writing the ending.
Also the "believe women under every circumstance" narrative is ridiculous. They say 2 to 10% of reported sexual assault is made up. And they discount that number with glee. That's not an insignificant number when you realize the effect on someone's life those accusations can have. Would you point a gun at a loved ones head knowing there was only a 2 to 10% chance of a bullet being in the cylinder? Of course you wouldn't.
Read more
Flying Davey
Interesting but too long
Good story but the constant “this is AI and isn’t it so good and so amazing?!” got so tiresome. Like, I get it. AI is good, I don’t need to hear it over and over again.
Sacmd41
Trump is the President
Why are you liberal woman so obsessed with Trump and need to bring it into everything…. Literally brought nothing to the story and was pointless. I stopped there… you lost all credibility and I’m done. Journalism is Dead! Congrats!
Andrea512atx
OK but don’t use AI
Why use AI? What a weird choice.
JLC1456
Problematic Ending
For 10 episodes, we hear about all the heinous false rape accusations Coco throws around against numerous people, real and imagined – it’s her go-to lie – but suddenly, when it comes her claims about the mother’s ex-boyfriend, we’re supposed to think she wasn’t lying in that one specific instance? It feels like the podcaster is grasping for a way to “believe women” and has decided to throw this guy under the bus in the interest of serving that narrative. Maybe he’s a bit of a gross dude, but why should we think that Coco’s accusations against him are any more credible than the multitude of others she’s made? Even as an unabashed feminist myself, I find this rather unbelievable.
2 stars because I was enjoying it up until the last episode.
Read more
JM_321
Good Story at First. Bad messaging
I was so happy to hear a different story that might be like other podcasts like, Scamanda. (Way better than this one) I hate the political vantage point this whole thing plays and the constant side choosing throughout this, not just looking at the “facts”. They should stick with the story that the title says, not create their own agenda. Also, criticizing a movie bringing sex trafficking to light is gross. Stop listening at middle of number 5!
Read more
KT.Bish
Decent until political views ruined it
Oh how I was excited for a new and interesting podcast. I love supporting women podcasters and journalists. But when they bring in extreme political personal views, continuously bring up Trump, put down a movie that was intended to shine a light on sex trafficking, I feel so disappointed.
A small percentage of people actually care about your personal political views, make a separate podcast about that. But please just tell a story and be professional about it. Leave your agenda at the door.
Hire actual actors instead of AI generated content. It wasn’t very good and had a horrible “stop start” feel to the rhythm of the story.
Read more
autisticAli
Really good but a few episodes too long
Like someone else said, the show is well done and well produced, but a few episodes too long. I listened to about 7 and decided to skip over 2
Ashleyyyyy34563
donald trump
i’m so confused why you keep bringing up donald trump?!?!?! it’s so weird
Kimmyj12!
Unkind & inappropriate
Listen to Sympathy Pains if you want to hear how an ethical clinician (Stuart Eisendrath MD) talks about psych conditions. NO ONE with credibility would discuss possible dx for a patient he hasn't seem. Extremely inappropriate. Coco is often talked about w/o sensitivity for her obv vulnerability and likely mental illness.
BK-Betsy
Such strange behavior!
What a crazy story. The entire time I kept thinking if only she would expend as much time doing something productive as she did fabricating lies and manipulating people she’d be so successful. I’m thinking she would make an excellent fiction writer!
Ireallyhatethinkingofusernames
Very thorough
Impressed with how thorough the story is and I was hooked initially. They REALLY did their research because there’s a ton of detail.
However…. The show starts to drag near the end and the story starts to feel convoluted and anticlimactic. By episode 8 I’m ready for resolution not more unanswered questions.
Kinda just want to know if Coco is for real or not at this point and the lack of clear answers is frustrating.
Also BOOOOOOOOO using Ai, pay real people!
Read more
Cass-177695
So freaking good!
I was hooked on episode one. The journalism here is top tier. This podcast is a must listen!!!
Arti (:
Loved it until…
This podcast was great. I felt they were neutral and giving good facts about Coco Berthmans story. One episode about her mom, she even said that she was taking everything her mom said at 50% because she could very well be a master manipulator. Which I thought was exactly how journalists should be. Until the very next episode they seem to joke about human trafficking and don’t give that same mind set to those who have supposedly said they’ve seen it with their own eyes. I don’t know. Seemed pretty hypocritical and typical journalism for today. So I’d take everything she says with a grain of salt. I’m curious to see if the rest gets pretty biased.
Read more
Mrob9884
Good until it wasn’t
I enjoyed about 4 episodes of this podcast. However, once it started veering off into politics it just became like many many other things put out by journalists these days. I don’t expect podcasts to be free of bias but to air opinions as fact without a balanced viewpoint seems irresponsible, especially with a subject like human trafficking. There were many statements made about what human trafficking doesn’t look like. Why not include an episode about what it does look like? That might actually help the cause. If I was a victim of human trafficking I would be offended by Coco. Sadly though, I think I’d also be offended by this podcast.
Read more
She5678
Excellent listen
I loved the story which blended true crime and psychology into a bizarre tale. The reporting was excellent and the narrator was great. People are so crazy! Loved this podcast.
jhurlimann
Budget For Actors Instead of AI
It’s just not ethical to allow widespread use of AI to take creative jobs. Even if it means getting on a platform like Fiverr and paying an amateur college student, podcasters can, and should, let actual humans do voice acting. And this AI actually wasn’t that good. Didn’t get her accent.
macbabe16
Hire real actors
You have the money to hire human beings for your production. AI actors sound like uncanny valley and it’s distracting.
Maren Morgan
