Beatles vs. Stones
Beatles vs. Stones
Justin Cox & Ryan Page
People have kicked around Beatles vs. Stones arguments since the dawn of the discourse. This podcast takes that conversation to its logical conclusion, even if it means grinding it into dust. Hosts Justin Cox and Ryan Page pit years’ worth of Beatles and Rolling Stones records against each other, one year at a time, starting in ’64 and ending in ’74. We’ll trade off defending bands from one week to another, threading a needle between friendly conversation and hardline debate, featuring pop-ins from guests. The Beatles put out Abbey Road 1969 and the Rolling Stones put out Let it Bleed. Who had a better year? Subscribe to this podcast to throw yourself down that hellhole of a debate. Proud part of Pantheon - the podcast network for music lovers.
2021: Get Back to Where You Once Belonged
We said we'd do an extra episode when the Peter Jackson documentary came out and that day arrived over the long weekend. Justin hid a camera in a flower pot and sat down with Ryan to see what he thought of it. This episode reference our original 1970 conversation a few times. You can revisit that one, which features Let it Be and a slate of Beatles solo albums that came out that same year) earlier in this podcast feed or right here. Beatles vs. Stones is part of the Pantheon Podcast Network. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Dec 2, 2021
1 hr 38 min
Tattoo You, featuring Andy Cush
In this bonus episode Justin and Ryan talk to Andy Cush (@cushac) of Pitchfork and the Late Era podcast, which looks at albums released by gigantic bands and artists in the late, often bad, sometimes good, almost always amusing, parts of their career. It’s a complimentary piece to our finale episode, which went deep on Some Girls but probably deserved a little more Tattoo You. Also covered: Santana's Supernatural and Aerosmith's Honkin' on Bobo. Subscribe to the show and share it with your friends. Beatles vs. Stones is proudly part of the Pantheon Podcast Network.   - Email the show at [email protected]  - Follow Justin on Twitter at @routinelayup Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Mar 30, 2021
23 min
Finale: 1974 & beyond + We draft our mixtapes
In this celebratory finale episode, Justin Cox and Ryan Page look at 1974 and the decades of releases that followed. After that, they run through a minefield of categories (John or Paul? Best/worst album cover? Fun stuff like that). They end the series where they began, with a draft, this time creating their own Beatles/Stones mixtapes.  Justin’s playlist: https://open.spotify.com/playlist/2mrx1ieyI6M0kiq8FbTctj?si=Nk0hSsVxRASI9HoI-XGymA Ryan’s playlist: https://open.spotify.com/playlist/2UcHG33KWk6Qjpv79SFwwq?si=H0sX8d8sTdCYEi-7tfd90w Thanks for listening to the show! We had a damn good time doing it and if you made it this far hopefully it was good for you too. Rate and review if you think others might want to find it. Beatles vs. Stones is proudly part of the Pantheon Podcast Network.  - Email the show at [email protected]  - Follow Justin on Twitter at @routinelayup Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Mar 24, 2021
1 hr 48 min
1973: Band on the Run, Goats Head Soup & more, featuring David Wild
Justin Cox and Ryan Page look at 1973, when the Rolling Stones drop Goats Head Soup and every Beatle releases at least one album. Justin reps The Stones and Ryan reps the lads from Liverpool.  Beatles: Band on the Run, Mind Games, Ringo, Living in the Material World, Red Rose Speedway Stones: Goats Head Soup At the 34-minute mark we’re joined by David Wild, who has written for Rolling Stone and The Grammys, and who also wrote the liner notes for the Stones 40 Licks album. He has some good stories and some strong feelings about Goats Head Soup. Follow David on Twitter at @wildaboutmusic. Justin and Ryan pick back up at the 50-minute mark. Subscribe to the show and share it with your friends. Beatles vs. Stones is proudly part of the Pantheon Podcast Network.  - Email the show at [email protected] - Follow Justin on Twitter at @routinelayup Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Mar 16, 2021
1 hr 13 min
1972: Exile on Yoko Ono Street, Featuring Rob Mitchum
Justin Cox and Ryan Page look at 1972, when the Rolling Stones drop Exile on Main Street and John Lennon and Yoko Ono release Sometime in New York City. The first 20 mins are heavy on the Lennon album. Don't let it scare you away! Everything after that is Exile! Ryan reps The Stones and Justin reps Lennon/Ono. Beatles: Sometime in New York City + Happy Xmas, War is Over  Stones: Exile on Main Street At the 22:30 mark, we're joined by music and science writer Rob Mitchum, who’s written for tons of publications including the Chicago Tribune and Pitchfork, where he gave Exile a perfect 10 when it was reissued. Justin and Ryan pick back up around 35:30. Subscribe to the show and share it with your friends. Beatles vs. Stones is proudly part of the Pantheon Podcast Network.  - Email the show at [email protected]  - Follow Justin on Twitter at @routinelayup Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Mar 10, 2021
1 hr 7 min
1971: Imagine all the Sticky Fingers, featuring Mark Richardson
Justin Cox and Ryan Page look at 1971, when the Rolling Stones drop Sticky Fingers and John and Paul put out a few solo albums. Justin reps The Stones and Ryan reps The Beatles this week.  Beatles: Imagine (John Lennon), RAM (Paul McCartney), Wild Life (Wings)  Stones: Sticky Fingers At the 30:30 mark, Mark Richardson, former Editor in Chief of Pitchfork and current pop/rock critic at the Wall Street Journal, joins us to talk about both bands, with an emphasis on Sticky Fingers, which he gave a perfect 10 in a 2015 Pitchfork review. Follow Mark on Twitter at @markrichardson. Justin and Ryan pick back up around 41:30. Subscribe to the show and share it with your pals. Beatles vs. Stones, Year x Year is part of the Pantheon Podcast Network. Thanks to AKG for the clean and cool microphone. - Email the show at [email protected]  - Follow Justin on Twitter at @routinelayup Part of Pantheon Podcasts Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Mar 3, 2021
1 hr 17 min
1970: Ex-Beatle Mania, featuring Christian Swain
Justin Cox and Ryan Page look at 1970, when the Beatles released Let it Be (and every member releases a solo album) and the Rolling Stones released the live album Get Yer Ya-Yas Out. Justin reps The Beatles and Ryan reps the Stones this week. Note: Justin’s audio has a fuzzed-out John Lennon quality to it on this episode. Sorry for the inconvenience. Beatles: Let it Be, McCartney, All Things Must Pass, Plastic Ono Band, Sentimental Journey, Beaucoups of Blues Stones: Get Yer Ya-Yas Out   Around the 46:00 mark, Christian Swain, host of the Rock & Roll Archeology Podcast and CEO of Pantheon Podcasts, joins us to spike this Beatles-heavy episode with some more Stones. Justin and Ryan pick back up around 55:30. Subscribe to the show and share it with your friends. Beatles vs. Stones is proudly part of the Pantheon Podcast Network.  - Email the show at [email protected]  - Follow Justin on Twitter at @routinelayup  Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Feb 23, 2021
1 hr 16 min
1969: Here comes the blood, featuring Eric Nash
Justin Cox and Ryan Page look at 1969, when the Beatles release Abbey Road and the Rolling Stones release Let it Bleed. Ryan reps The Beatles and Justin reps the Stones this week. Beatles: Abbey Road, Yellow Submarine, Manson Murders  Stones: Let it Bleed, Altamont Murder  At 28:00, Eric Nash, host of The Almost Famous Minute and Feels Like Weezer joins us to share some thoughts about his favorite album. Justin and Ryan pick back up around 31:30. Subscribe to the show and share it with your friends. Beatles vs. Stones is proudly part of the Pantheon Podcast Network.  - Email the show at [email protected]  - Follow Justin on Twitter at @routinelayup Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Feb 18, 2021
56 min
1968: Sympathy for the White Album? Featuring Whitney Page
Justin Cox and Ryan Page look at 1968, when the Beatles release The White Album and the Rolling Stones release Beggars Banquet. Justin reps The Beatles and Ryan reps the Stones this week, although we neglect to ever actually mention that. The major releases are: Beatles: White Album, Hey Jude, Revolution  Stones: Beggars Banquet, Jumpin' Jack Flash, Rock & Roll Circus   At 42:30, Whitney Page, a cultural critic from Orcas Island weighs in on the year. Justin and Ryan pick back up around 57:00. Subscribe to the show and share it with your friends. Beatles vs. Stones is proudly part of the Pantheon Podcast Network.  - Email the show at [email protected]. Any White Album defamation comes from a place of love but we respect your right to hate us for it. - You can drag Justin on Twitter at @routinelayup Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Feb 10, 2021
1 hr 22 min
1967: What is this, a freak out?, featuring Elizabeth Nelson
Justin Cox and Ryan Page look at 1967, when psychedelia abounds in the form of costumes, concepts and out-there album titles. It's a rowdy little year. Justin reps The Beatles and Ryan reps the Stones this week. The major releases are: Beatles: St. Peppers, Magical Mystery Tour & the Strawberry Fields/Penny Lane 45  Stones: Satanic Majesties Request, Between the Buttons & Flowers  At 45:30, Elizabeth Nelson of the of the Looking for the Magic Podcast and singer/songwriter behind the DC garage/punk band The Paranoid Style. Follow her at @paranoiacs. Justin and Ryan pick back up at 1-hour mark. Subscribe to the show and share it with your friends. Beatles vs. Stones is proudly part of the Pantheon Podcast Network.  - Email the show at [email protected]  - Follow Justin on Twitter at @coxjustin Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Feb 3, 2021
1 hr 25 min
Load more