Good pod

Anything with mush is garbage

Let’s mush mush

Marty needs to go, he’s a rat

Jake 10/10 Rico 7/10 Mush 0/10 Kick mush off and you get your 5 stars back.

I’m just going to be frank and say this was probably one of their best episodes outside of March Madness. The fact Rico wasn’t there to mope and complain the entire episode gave the crew a chance to be fluid and work through topics. I’m not saying this to complain about Rico either. I’ve come to endear Rico. However, the crew cohesion is better without him.

…a very difficult listen. These guys don’t know anything about the game. Going after Titus & Tate is a bad look, especially when you don’t hold a candle to them and are only being propped up by Barstool.

If you like listening to people dumber than you(not Jake) and much better off than you complain constantly. This show is for you

Would rather listen to someone fart into a microphone for an hour

Jake’s the only one with any idea what he’s talking about. Mush and Rico are painful. Save yourself the time and listen to Titus and Tate.

Why take an expert in Jake and put him in with Marty? You remove the obvious hole in this group and it is instantly better. And if the excuse is Marty's comic relief, good lord, a played out fake character isn't it. Maybe see if Larry the Cable Guy is looking to reach a younger audience if you're going that route.

Surprised that Barstool attaches their name to this podcast. Jake seems to be the only one even attempting to deliver decent content, unless Big Cat stops by to rescue the episode. Doesn’t come close to competing with Titus & Tate as the go-to college bball podcast.

Everyone is great on the show except Marty makes it almost impossible to listen

Do not listen to this. Everyone unbearable to listen to. Shocked they’re allowed to make this.

Awful and obnoxious.

One of the worst sports podcasts Ive ever listened to. These guys don’t care about content of quality. The one guy knows his stuff but my god this was a waste.

Marty’s tough to listen to (all the Twitter drama stuff aside) and this just isn’t a good product. It’s sloppy and lazy and tough to value his opinion when the lack of pride in his podcast is glaring. Wish this wasn’t the case. I want it to be fun and funny but it’s just unprofessional and well below the bar.

Great people and content

I’d rather listen to my wife complain all day than the 2 idiots on this podcast.

He can barely speak and knows almost nothing about college basketball. One listen and I’m done.

Love Jake, great pod for bball fans

One of the worst sports podcast ever made. Mush is the most untalented mumble mouth, whiney little man. I don’t think he watches basketball because he knows NOTHING.

Can’t listen to that 🤡Marty. Office gold fish have bigger brains and provide better content.

Jake and Reags, grab whatever you can and run as far and as fast away from those two hacks as fast as you can!

Get rid of mush. Bad brand for barstool. Jake and Rico are great. Mush is a fake gambler who hates teachers.

Jake deserves better than having to clowns who just talk about Duke 24/7. Jake deserves better.

He just talks too much and can tell is not a college basketball guy. Love Rico and Jakes knowledge though. He might also be special

Gotta have less marty. I get he is the dumb friend you keep around for laughs but he is a tough listen for anything longer than a couple minutes. Truly want to be a fan but he makes it hard.

No laughs

Marty mush should not be an employee at Barstool. He actually does nothing enjoyable. I'd rather listen to Billy football over this guy

Wanted to give this a try with the tournament about to start. Not a great podcast. Rico would be a nice complimentary piece on a podcast with a stronger host but Marty is tough to listen to and Jake/Reags should stick to blogs.

Great ep with Fanta

Rico is a piece of trash should be kicked off this show!

Honestly just get rid of Marty mush. Love Rico’s personality and Jake’s knowledge. If they had a better complimentary host this podcast would take off.

If this show wasn’t a Barstool product it would have next to no following lol it is so bad. When they give their takes it’s as if they aren’t even watching

Saying you know what is going to happen beforehand and Jake pretending to be unbiased is a joke

Rico is a star but the other 3 are just not Podcasters that will have success. Jake is boring never funny or entertaining. Marty tries hard and misses consistently and Reags should stick to blogging. This podcast could work if you switch out 1-2 of these guys (Jake,marty) for actual talent.

I think DP is being to hard on them. I really love this show.

So annoying. There is one guy in particular that is full on unbearable. Might improve if they cut him loose to be toxic and uninformed elsewhere.

Fantastic Pod! I love hearing the different takes from 4 different types of people

If Rico wasn’t such an immature baby, and didn’t care about dumb stuff… he would actually be tolerable.

Marty knows nothing, and didn’t go to duke (obviously if you have heard him speak) yet only follows them. Rico thought Gonzaga was a wagon last year. Morons

5 stars just for Jake’s rant on Rico

Only reason I listen to this is because Rico is entertaining. Jake bring knowledge, Rico brings personality, Mush brings nothing. If you want this pod to be successful get rid of Mush and add someone else.

Jake is one of my favorite people at barstool. He’ really knows what he is talking about and seems like such a good dude.

I would listen to this show if Rico was booted. Please dear god. Rico is brutal.

Jake is a bonafide true upcoming talent in college basketball media. I mean it when I say he could be the next generation of Rothstein, Norlander and others as he has the knowledge and passion. Pairing Jake with the likes of Marty and Rico is doing him a huge disservice and I couldn’t fault him if he chose to leave Barstool because of it. I can’t get past Marty and Rico on this show, therefore I’ll always choose other CBB pods over it. If Jake had a better supporting cast, that likely wouldn’t be the case.

Great POD - I love the passion

Rico is the funniest and the best gambler and best human on earth. Pledge master dan is a fat bully.

This podcast is trash, Marty and Rico are two of the dumbest people at barstool. This podcast should be hosted by Jake and big cat, the two best college basketball minds at barstool