Reviews
via Podcasts
Cutthroat trout in Texas
I listened in disbelief as you and the youn gladly bungled through your podcast giving incorrect information. For example.
1. McKittrick creek has rainbow trout now. And according to some reports from the 1800s had cutthroat trout. Your guest said erroneously that they were (cutthroat trout) were reportedly out there by Pratt. It so well known and documented that Pratt put Rainbow Trout in the creek. NOT cutthroat .
It is highly probable that during colder periods, RGC did find its way into Mckittrick creek. But thus far there is no proof.
2. You stated that Rio grande chubs “have the cutthroat markings.” And are easily mistaken for cutthroat trout. However, they have the same shape and other than that they look like, well… chubs. They rarely get bigger than about 5 inches.
They do coexist in the same creeks as RGC. BUT they are not easily mistaken.
Behnke and others postulate that one the person documenting trout in west Texas was a military doctor who was well versed in identifying trout due to his long established hobby of trout fishing during his military stations could easily distinguish between a chub and a trout. Also, the fact that oral reports from others including rail road surveyors identified RGC in Texas, along with trout scales being found in a archeological site in northern Mexico in the Rio grande basin made it very likely that RGV were in Texas.
Your guest acted as if she knew what she was talking about and you, the host should be more accurate if you are going to discuss a topic.
I was disappointed and would not recommend this podcast to anyone serious to learn about this beautiful fish.
Professor berry Mckokiner. University of Amsterdam. Department of Biological Sciences. Professor of ichthyology.
Read more
Troutwanderer
