Still love you guys, but please stop bringing up Jews…

Fantastic pod but wish there was a bit more hair between the boys.

I’ve been listening since 2016, this is the only show that i want to start caught up on. Extremely entertaining while theorizing about interesting topics that people may have never heard about before or topics that are super relevant in todays world. Either way you’ll find something you love here, and they will get you itching to dig further into these topics. Its been an awesome 10 years boys.. Here’s to 10 more🍻

Great group of guys talking about everything interesting. Their vast library of episodes (mostly found on their first feed: Alien Theorists Theorizing) has filled my days with banter, laughs and thoughts. Definitely my favorite podcast. If I had to rank my favorite to least talkers I’d say: Zel, Mush Mouth, Dan, Andrew, you know what I mean? Thanks for doing this. PS - best episode is still the Val Johnson one. “I haven’t told ya about my eyes, but yeah, they are burnt.”

Very good!

This podcast is nothing but “Big Whale” propaganda.

I tried to rate the old feed on my wife’s phone but she caught on and stopped me. To make it up I’m rating the new feed 0/5 stars. This time I’ll steal my daughter’s phone to rate the show.

These guys use to have the beans, most no longer do, but it’s ok, only need beans when you making bean casserole so I’m here for it.

Super funny and kinda educational

I appreciate you boys. Here for the rebrand and ain’t going anywhere. The new show is #RonPondApproved thanks for keeping it going!

Funny, non-stop laughter, some thrills, great chemistry!

Been listening since the beginning looking forward for new fresh theories

Been following for years amazing great podcast everything same same but different!!’n

Been listen since the beginning. Them Eyes have been On The Skies ever since. Love these guys. Great content, great banter.

The only podcast I have continued to listen to after all these years! Keep up the great work guys!

A+

Awesome podcast. Been listening to these guys for over 7 years and they have always been entertaining.

I’ve been with them since almost the beginning. Their podcast s amazing and they are funny! They give a lot of info! Thanks guys for keeping with it! -Chrisa

This podcast brings me so much joy. It’s a comforting mix of silliness and seriousness, and never fails to make me laugh. The crew strikes an excellent balance between facts and theories.

I have been listening to this podcast for almost a decade. Love it Everything from Aliens to Conspiracies. It’s all great give it a listen!

Have been listening to the Theorists for eight years now and have been a Patreon sub for three or so. They’re consistent, informative, and fun. Highly recommend for anyone interested in potentially learning something while having a good time.

If Joe Rogan and Ancient Aliens had a love child, and that child was raised on cheap beer, conspiracy forums, and endless laughter—it would be the Theorists Theorizing podcast. These guys somehow manage to go from serious UFO investigations to arguing about which cryptid would win in a bar fight, all in the same episode. One minute you’re questioning the fabric of reality, the next you’re crying from laughter because someone compared Bigfoot to their ex’s uncle. The best part? It’s like hanging out with your smartest, funniest friends… if your friends also believed that lizard people are running Costco. I came for the UFO theories, but I stayed because these dudes make my morning commute feel like a late-night basement hangout with too much Red Bull. Highly recommend—unless you’re allergic to laughing in public and getting weird looks from strangers. Sign up for the Patreon best content 💪🏼

This podcast is my favorite when I run out of Last podcast on the left. All the guys are great and witty, but that Braden guy seems a little sus. I think he’s there as like a make a wish thing.

Funny and not too serious. Great for a spooky laugh when winding down after a long day. Pretty sure Braden can’t read though.

They are amazing. Been a listener since the ATT days. The whole team is great and the dynamic is wonderful. Hilarity ensures from a paranormal Canadian slant (except Dan)! Shows great!

This podcast is like a conspiracy theory sleepover hosted by your funniest friends. Theorist Theorizing dives into pop culture rabbit holes with just the right mix of chaos and cleverness from cryptids to celebrity drama, it’s always a ride. I had a UFO sighting a couple years ago that was completely unexplained no answers, just questions and I was searching for a podcast that could speak to that kind of mystery. I stumbled across this show and haven’t left since. I listen on my way to work and while I’m at work, and it’s become part of my daily rhythm. The hosts riff off each other with sharp wit and genuine curiosity, making even the most absurd theories feel oddly plausible. Highly recommend if you love smart nonsense, unpredictable tangents, and a place where the unexplained feels right at home.

Ive ben listening to these guys for about a decade now and their new show is better than ever

The most well researched and informative conspiracy and theory podcast out there! Not only do they take the time to make great theory content they are HILARIOUS. Don’t sit on this! Get listening!

The boys on this podcast are dangerously funny. Their jokes hit like a pickup line that actually works, and their theories sneak into my head like sweet nothings. Honestly, I’d let them theorize on any part of me, no questions asked.

are beauties! Followed them for over 5 years and they always keep it fresh. They’ll have you laughing, pondering, or questioning reality depending on the topic. They bring unique points of view to get the gears turning. Give ‘em a listen!

Really enjoying the show so far. Definitely appreciate the interplay between the hosts!

Love the show, keep it up.

Always has been and always will be

Been listening for years before the rebrand and have enjoyed every episode. The friendship they have is extended to the audience while they break down every wild theory they come across. Even though they joke that they are “a bunch of dummies,” they always supply plenty to think about.

Hands down the best pod to theorize with while pounding a couple of space beers. These beauties crank up the Space News, get deep into interdimensional butt stuff, and somehow make government cover-ups sound like campfire stories with the boys. Trust nothing. Probe everything. 10/10 would be abducted again.

These guys host an amazing show, blending varying ideas and hilarious jokes right in with the facts of the case files. It’s always a great time.

I have been listening since 2018. I love the show because of the genuine connection the hosts have with one another. This makes for good conversation and great bits. This show is the only show I have a Patreon for. It is 100% worth the money. They have an insane amount of extra content for a very reasonable price.

Been listening for 10 years. Cant get away from these boys. Even in a name change/relaunch. This show is awesome, they cover fun topics and the way they discuss them makes it entertaining, not boring!! Sit back, have a brew, and listen to your new best buds :) with love, from your HISTORIAN

Simply the best. These ultra classy and equally silly gentlemen are self deprecating and have the ability to keep me entertained for weeks at a time. They make me laugh daily giving me the illusion that I have friends irl! I recently took my “pickle baby” sticker I received as a Patreon member and got a pic with it in front of the Sphinx for muh boys. One day I’ll figure out how to join their Discord server and share its glory. They are all my spirit animal and are undoubtedly The Impractical Jokers of the podcast world. I love Conan and the Smartless crew but The Theorists Theorizing is my overall comedy podcast pick to date. Keep at it you beauties, the world is a dark place and you boys are the light.

Braden and Andrew were right, Happy Gilmore 2 was bad. Thank you for not being an npc. Also the show is cool too. Don’t get your panties in a wad Zel. Long time fan. Prolapse me.

Best podcast ever!

Excited for this new era! Let’s go boys!!

Sit down crack a beer and keep those eyes on the skies. Listen to the boys and take their life lessons to heart. Dans an android, Zels a vampire, Andrew is a mongoose, and Braden is Craig. Intrigued? Follow along and be a part of the cool kids.

Ten more years of good times and thoughtful theories

These fellas really know how to put together a pod. Zels sound quality is great, Dans research is always on point, Andrew brings the street cred and Braden… well.. the Budweiser sweats speak for themselves. Seriously, my favorite podcast for almost a decade!

Continuing to follow these amazing fellas! Love the pod cast! You guys always put out great content. Although I don’t personally know you It’s been great to accompany you and hear how you have grown as people. Good luck with this new era.

You won’t find a better group of guys theorizing about theories.

Greatest show since Siegfried and Roy, LFG! 🔥

Y’all have been great, helped me carry through some hard times when I just needed to laugh here or there or something interesting to get my mind off of other stuff, keep up the good work

Braden is so knowledgeable, wise & most of all, handsome. Zel is cool. Dan is a little quiet. Andrew is….. my sandwich is ready, cya. In all seriousness, these guys are amazing. I came here looking for a loose end pod and these guys are it. Bringing both knowledge and laughs. Perfect combo. Cheers to a great rebrand/launch 🎉🥳