Poorly produced and written. Episodes 1 through 5 were the same information presented in different ways over and over and had me rolling my eyes. The story doesn’t pick up until episode 6 and then by episode 8 they jump back to a separate case you don’t even care about and then leave you hanging. That episode came out in March it’s now almost May with no resolution. I only really stuck around because I listened during work for background noise but the story was pretty bad.

Annoying that u have to pay to complete the session .. so sad that it came to that. Unfollowing unfortunately. All shows are the same now smh

Payne has the best podcast voice! The best true crime, unsolved, whodunit, etc podcast there is. I love the details you’re given!

The series seems to have ended abruptly without any resolution or discussion of a resolution. And you promised Jospeh’s mother you would look into his disappearance as well.

Stopped dropping episodes and people pay to tune into these.

Feeling like there is NO justice for Flo. Keep checking for updates, new episodes, answers for all the silence. Not sure why I pay for a Tenderfoot+ subscription at all! Hurt feelers

What a scam

All the woke talking points are there. Super annoying. Lots snyde comments. I’m not trying to listen to woke commentary - there’s plenty of that on - you guessed it - woke commentary podcasts. I’m looking for true crime on a true crime podcast.

Love every season. Thanks for bringing these issues to light. Everyone making the podcast seems top notch. Season 2 episode 9- I just have to say the interview with Catfish was very interesting. I’ve never heard a more manipulative controlling person in an interview. It was very calculated, and insane. He doesn’t make sense. What a psycho. Completely capable of murder if even challenged a little.

The stories are always interesting but each episode spends the first 5+ minutes talking about the previous episode and then the last 5+ minutes teasing the next episode. Add in the ads and you really only get 15-20 min of any new content each episode. Gets very old.

Are we getting new episodes about Florence? Is this season over? Why did I pay to be a Tenderfoot member — asking for a friend. ☹️

I don’t understand do we only get 8 episode why did it stop abruptly ?

Where are you ? Where are the new episodes?

I want to hear next to nothing about Payne, how he’s feeling, what he’s thinking, etc. and more about the investigation. Please stop making this about you and focus on the victim.

I’m a huge fan of Up and Vanished and Payne and his team. Was an original season 1 fan listening in real time… Season 4 felt different. So melodramatic and so much about Payne. Particularly episode 5. It felt cheap and was what I don’t like about other true crime podcasts- when it becomes all about the journalist instead of the victims and the case. Maybe they did it to stretch out more episodes? It didn’t work.

I love Payne-always excited for new seasons, but I feel like they always end without a resolution. Nothing ever mentioned again. What happened to Krystal and Ashley? Even if you weren’t able to continue the investigation or it became cold or dangerous, tell us something. We become engrossed and engaged only to be left with questions that never get answered. Please don’t leave this season that way.

I have stopped listening to most true crime podcasts it’s gotten to be too much… but paynes is a keeper. I love the fact that you focus on one person/case per season. The deep dive is amazing. I really like that I feel we’re having a convo about it… what you’re doing is admirable. Brave too. Flo’s case touches my heart. I hope that your research really helps get things going again… but it sounds so dangerous… these people including the cops sound very sus… Alaska is definitely a different place. I’ve heard a lot of horrific stories. Anyway, I’m not all caught up yet but it sounds like at some point we reach an impasse.. I check the internet daily now to see if there’s an update about her case.. I hope there is something that we, the listeners, can do out here to help. Be safe! Thanks for everything you do

Why am I getting commercials as a Tenderfoot + member? Ugh

Season 4 has been different. It started off slow and didn't start to pick up on evidence until episodes 6-8. Even then, there is a lot of here say. There's been a lot of the case evidence episodes which feel like fillers to cover time. I'd like to hear from locals on the case and from officers involved directly. Payne can be abrupt to officers at times which I feel like can probably be a deterrent for them to feel comfortable working together. Match the feeling and tone of the officers and investigators like closing a sale instead of confronting with arrogance and an attitude that the department is doing something wrong. That may be the case but in order to open this case there needs to be collaboration. When is the next free episode going to air? It's been two weeks

I totally understand Payne needing to take a break, but can we get a heads up! lol really looking forward to the next episode!!

I was looking for a true crime/murder investigation/missing persons podcast to listen to as I go about my day… found it! I am a ‘Dateline’ fanatic and was looking for something similar, but not the same… if that makes sense. ‘Up & Vanished’ (all 4 seasons) is a GREAT podcast. I’m actually really really bummed that we won’t be able to finish season 4 until June (2024)! I wanted more… I wanted to know what else happened! It’s original, it’s organic sounding… the crew also doesn’t vier off the topic… but they tell the story in such a way, that… where, as they introduce their content, you’re invested! There are also definitely moments that will make your mouth drop. Payne Lindsey keeps you genuinely invested in the storyline by giving you the entire story… all the facts… remaining unbiased… but authentically devoted to helping & advocating for the family… genuinely working to help find a resolution for/to the case. He also kind of has a ‘Keith Morrison’ type of vibe (which, I personally enjoy). Each season solely focuses on one case, one person. They are truly directed at attaining every piece of information they can surrounding what has happened. The show doesn’t drag on by inserting comedic bits… by, having discussions regarding personal opinions & theories… it’s also isn’t repetitive, retelling the same facts over & over. Now… I will say… I would really enjoy it if, as time goes on, they were to do updates regarding each season (each case). I’d truly like to know about any new information, persons of interest, if any charges have been filed, etc.. I am also really hoping they are already prepping/looking into continuing with a season 5 (… Season 6, 7..). I binged every season, day after day… now, I’m all caught up & can’t wait to hear what’s next!

Payne: no one cares about your narcissistic inner monologue

I listened to the 4th season about the Alaska disappearance. First two or three episodes were very slow and boring. When it got interesting, the podcast ended abruptly without any conclusion or idea of why. I listened to part of the first season. Over half of each episode is commercials and recaps of prior episodes. Again, it was slow. I have unfollowed.

No one does True Crime like Payne. Thanks for all the good work you do for these victims and their families, stay safe!

Podcast, Payne and team are actually in the field working hard to investigate and solve a crime!! I’m praying for the 2 victims in this Podcast!!!! Extremely grateful for what this team does! Thank You!

The episodes start with ads, end with ads, and are abruptly interrupted with ads. I’m not motivated to time it but probably 30-40% of the content is advertising. I skip ahead but because some of the ads are done by the host it’s not easy to find where the ads stop and podcast begins again. Too annoying, I’ve stopped listening because of it.

This is so different and exciting because it's happening in real time. JoAnn

Payne is so full of himself after season 1 and he’s really rude to anyone he deals with in law enforcement. These episodes are overly long without going anywhere.

Was hoping that Season 4 was building towards something since it had been so slow, then suddenly we are told there is nothing new until June. Hard to believe this crew thought they had anything close to enough material for an entire “season” Hoping things are better in June…not holding breath.

I have to say, Season 1 was great and set a high standard for this podcast, Season 2 was pretty good as well, but from. Season 3 on it became weak and all about Payne making money, so many commercials, and to lift it up his ego. Season 4 come on, it’s not about investigating a crime and telling the victims story, especially after episode 7, is like another listener said: Payne Patting his own back for his “great and courageous work”. Please, it was just what a journalist should do and many serious journalists do every day. And man, so many commercials that just felt that this season was about you guys making that money and not caring much about the story. I saw in the comments many others sharing my feelings about this podcast but maybe Payne don’t care losing listeners like us. I don’t even have the will to continue listening this season. I hope Payne go back to the roots, meaning season 1, and deliver a serious season 5.

I just started listening to this today and I’m hooked! Great storytelling!

Great podcast but the background noise aka music is annoying as all get out! Please stop with the crappy background noise.

After the first 5 minutes I was hooked! You are doing good work 😉

You are there’s nothing I want

Payne, please consider focusing less on yourself and more on the victims and the facts. The loss of lives is a serious matter. As a long-time listener since your early work on Up and Vanished, I had hoped to see your growth in becoming a professional investigative reporter. However, across several seasons and many Tenderfoot podcasts, the focus often seems to be on you. This comes across as self-serving and disrespectful to the families and loved ones of the victims. While it's commendable to use your platform to address injustices, it's important to remain true to the responsibility that comes with it.

I don’t understand why a podcast dedicated to helping the families of missing persons is so determined to engage in click bait. I feel like they should just do a fictional murder mystery series where the host can feel like a hero and leave real people with real stories alone.

I think the host thought the audience would appreciate all his “insight” but it comes off as boring filler. There’s so much contemplation on “what to do next” and I find myself screaming at the screen because it’s so obvious at points and doesn’t need to be discussed with the audience. Any true crime fan could tell you the answer to many of his “contemplations”. The part where he fully gives himself away to on Facebook was hard to listen to. He let a lead slip right out of his hands. Additionally, I would expect more interviews with the people of nome rather than 4 episodes of chasing a lead that the host then destroys before our ears. Take this break as an opportunity to actually focus on the facts of the case and what the people who live there have to say, rather than boring speculative commentary. It feels like he is attempting to direct a movie rather than be an investigative journalist. I will say the families seem very appreciative which gives me hope this can turn around. The case itself is interesting and there seems to be a lot of thread to pull on, which is the only reason why I’m still listening.

These stories need better tellers—not hacks who trade in every known writing and narration cliche. As appealing as a convenience store rotisserie hot dog.

...or, alternatively, She said he said....This podcast highlights and brings public attention to missing person cases, but doesnt provide any real resolutions. Few of the interviews are from first-hand eyewtitnesses; the ones that are do not seem to be verified, and most are rumor--something that somebody heard from somebody. Most--like the rambling, delusional Catfish account could be seriously edited. That said, this podcast does provide a tragic, eyeopening view into tiny rural communities scattered throughout the country.

Season should have been called “Bears Don’t Eat Backpacks.” The second I heard it, I said what are we doing here?

Good journalism, but the ad to podcast ratio is pretty miserable. Be prepared to skip forward a lot.

The other seasons were so well done. This season is very boring and predictable.

Just wrapped up episode 8 of Season 4 (my first season) and I have to agree with a few other reviews I’ve seen here; the podcast host cannot help but make the story about a missing woman from Alaska all about how brave and courageous he is to be tracking the story. Still enjoyed it overall, but come on man. Sounds like you stumbled upon the concept of journalism and proceeded to pat yourself on the back for pursuing it. 3/5

I just read a review of this podcast that complained about you doing unsolved cases instead of cases that were solved so that the listener could have a resolution!? you have got to be kidding me. These families have had a real life loved one disappear and they most likely has been murdered. How do you think they feel? Payne you are doing the real and difficult job that is needed for missing and murdered people. Not to mention assisting families that have little help, if none at all. Thank you.

Why won’t episode 8 play? Can Apple please fix this. It’s been down for five days

The podcast seems masturbatory in that it refers to itself over and over again as if a major player in the lives of the missing or deceased. There’s an arrogance about this that is matched only by the general ineptitude of the host to approach the subject matter with the care and grace it deserves. I fully believe that cases touched by this show have been negatively impacted by its meddling.

Love this podcast so much & I’ve been a follower from the beginning. Payne and his team does amazing work. They’re so dedicated to getting justice for the victims of the cases they cover. Payne uses his platform to bring awareness to smaller cases and without him we might not have the answers we do today. Thank you for your work!!

This series has been on my top listens and I’ve had it saved to catch every new episode. But every episode after episode 5 has felt like fillers that end with a good hang line to end the episode to make you coming back. Unfortunately all the quick to conclusion responses and lack of content is making me unfollow the show. I wish Payne and his team the best in their quest to get answers for the family and friends of the missing people in this series, but the podcast has lost me.

I’ve been a fan of the prior series of this podcast, but the 4th season is plodding and doesn’t hold my interest at all. Plus, the whole “Omg we’re pretending to be someone else tee hee!!!” pseudo-drama feels like two 7th grade boys crank-calling people after school.

A talented and dedicated team of researchers. seious and important investigative journalism and work