Welcome to the latest episode of the Yore Town Podcast, where we delve into the chilling Evelyn Hartley disappearance, one of La Crosse, Wisconsin's most notorious unsolved mystery cases. In 1953, 15-year-old Evelyn vanished while babysitting, leaving behind disturbing evidence and a community haunted by unanswered questions.

The CANDY MAN: The ONLY Poisoned Halloween Candy True Crime

Yore Town Podcast is a true crime and dark history podcast uncovering
real small-town mysteries, forgotten crimes, unexplained events, and
buried history from places most people overlook.

Each episode delivers deep-dive storytelling into true crime cases,
unsolved disappearances, eerie local legends, historical cover-ups, and
strange but 100% real stories that actually happened. No clickbait. No
internet myths. Just well-researched, fact-checked episodes designed to
keep you listening until the very end.

From chilling murders and cold cases to strange historical moments and
unsettling mysteries, Yore Town Podcast blends true crime podcast
tension with immersive narrative storytelling. These are the kinds of
stories you’d expect to hear late at night—except they’re real, and they
happened closer to home than you think.

Perfect for fans of:

True crime podcasts

Dark history podcasts

Unsolved mysteries

Small-town crime stories

Long-form storytelling podcasts

If you’re searching for a true crime podcast with real research, a dark
history podcast, or a mystery podcast that focuses on small towns and
forgotten places, this is it.

Every town has a past.
Some of them don’t want to be found.

New episodes regularly on Spotify
Real people. Real places. Real stories.