Who the Hell is Hamish?
Who the Hell is Hamish?
The Australian
Reviews
via Podcasts
Unbelievable!
This really hits home for those of us who have been drawn in by cons and narcissists. Hopefully, people will hear this and see the warning signs. Great reporting!!!
Racheltexas70
Fascinating
Great podcast. Was completely hooked from the beginning. Awesome job
Jra4776
Jane
I was so moved by the interview with Jane, my heart broke for her. I have to admit, I got choked up during the sentencing
dicoold
Heroic reporting!
This is one of the most compelling podcasts ever. To listen to each segment as more victims of psycho Hamish come out with their stories. And best of all, to get the satisfaction of hearing his sentencing! I truly hope this story reaches the world - to help people have healthy skepticism and avoid the heartbreak of being taken by crooks.
Insightnapa
Good!
Good podcast! Kept my interest.
Picy203
‘Jane,’ strong beautiful soul
Sorrow for all the victims. Jack & Bec sound like wonderful people. Jane too is intelligent, articulate, as the interviewer said, wise beyond her years. They are sharing her lessons and hard-won acceptance. That any of them would do the interview shows they are bravely processing the appalling exploitation done to anyone is the orbit of this creature. The genuine, empathic nature of the vulnerable victims is like a scent he followed as a predator. Telling the story publicly, especially underage at the time victims, may seem unorthodox to some but I think the benefits outweigh that and serve as an enlightening tale. Hopefully they will use this experience to become more powerful aware people. They will have scars for sure but still have open & wise hearts.
Read more
andrea_in_brooklyn
The point was made, the only criminal is Hamish
The story is well told and the podcast is intriguing. While I agree with many other comments in the reviews about the victim mishandling during the Jane bonus episode, I found it equally empowering at the maturity and insight she displayed. I also do applaud the narrator for letting that empowerment be spoken in her own words. Personal opinion, but I’m not interested in hearing a journalist tell a young woman how she should feel. He created a space for her to be honest and open, and it felt as if she found the experience cathartic (and she was clearly well received). It’s also important not to discount the other victims of this sociopath. Jane’s story stings because she was so young, but I feel just as deeply for the victims who thought they should have known better, who cant rely on naivety as a coping mechanism, and who have less time to recover from their victimization. At the end of the day it’s a well researched heartbreaking story that displays empathy towards the lives effected. Love to those involved & kudos to the production team.
Read more
gordito&co
Excellent!
So sad that Hamish wasn’t caught earlier. Interesting to hear how white collar crime is sentenced. Hamish destroyed so many lives. Podcast was well done. I was hooked after the first episode.
Run42019
Great
Great pod!! Feel sorry for Jane, but she was just a child. For the life of me I can’t figure out why these people fell for this! Call it a good dose of US midwestern skepticism, but I was taught the if it seems too good to be true it probably is.
Emberdreagon
Utterly maddening
It is absolutely insane that this was able to occur for such a long time. I have an unbelievable amount of compassion for the people's lives that hamish all but destroyed. I was so happy to hear even the small portion of the judge's verdict. Also, June. Listening to this bright, young, enlightened woman speak was heartbreaking but also such a pleasure. June, you are a bright light with an amazing future ahead of you.
Read more
ms.say
What a sociopath!
Great storytelling about the abuses & manipulations of a cunning sociopath. People need to be wary of these people. They’re out there & they look just like us.
jcd1969
Excellent
An excellent podcast. Focused, well edited, and evenly paced. An engaging and interesting story. I highly recommend it.
McNancy1
Worried about Jane
I am enjoying this podcast and only have one episode to go. However, I am very concerned about the portrayal of “Jane.” I am very concerned for Jane’s view of what she “did.” Jane is 100% a victim of Hamish, if not a victim of the worst kind. She was an underaged “child” who was sexually, emotionally, and financially taken advantage of by a much older adult man. Jane was literally sex-trafficked. Jane did not have the capacity to make true “conscious” choices, as she says, in the circumstances she was in. I’m not sure what Australian law is, or what the age of “consent” is, but Hamish should be charged of this crime he committed against this girl. I’m disappointed that your show didn’t raise more flags and more disgust over this relationship. I hope and pray that Jane gets the deep therapy she needs.
Read more
AnthonyTrask3
Five star content, one star editing
This podcast was riveting. Fascinating subject, excellent interviews, sooooo compelling. What was difficult was the wet mouth noises/drinking/swallowing sounds REPEATEDLY, especially on the bonus episode. 🤢😬🤢😬🤢 Those sounds have no business being so LOUD and in my ears. Were I sitting next to the person, I would not hear them with such crystal clarity. Please editors, take heed.
Risa Ann
Super interesting
Well done and such insight into people - sociopath and otherwise.
Laukelmomof3
Fantastic
Well put together and well narrated I'd have gotten some friends together and gotten my money....and he'd not be well afterward
carreratim
Good job to the Australian!
Great podcast! All of the podcast I have listened to from the Australian have been excellent. This one was no different. I enjoyed all of the episodes. I definitely recommend this podcast!
AbbyOzols
A sad story well told.
Do your homework on the people you meet and do business with, and listen to your instincts.
lekkerkontje
Revictimizing the victim
The “bonus” interview of Jane is repulsive. The interviewer is just as much of a creep as Hamish. Completely infects every previous episode. “Hey, can you describe in excruciating detail every aspect of your abuse at the hands of this man? Oh, you’re reluctant to? I’m going to press harder!” Unethical. And just plain disgusting.
DottieUnderwood
Mostly Good
Overall, great podcast. However, the audio quality on the interview in episode 10 is unlistenable. Podcast would be better without it.
Track star!
Statutory Rape?
New York - The age of consent is 17. It is illegal for anyone to have sex with someone under the age of 17. Hamish should be guilty of Statutory Rape during the Princeton/NY trip with the minor he was grooming.
J5OK
Team Jane
Having experienced something similar (to a much smaller degree) I just want to say how impressed I was with Jane’s honestly and maturity at only 23 years old. Jane if you are reading this- you seem like an incredible person who deserves happiness and peace. This is only a short chapter of your life. I’m rooting for you!
SadBride1
Jane is a victim.
Who the hell approved the Jane interview? Greg, your heavy breathing only made the whole debacle of an interview with Jane more creepy. It also felt strange and voyeuristic when Greg started asking Jane (so poised and mature by comparison) about the sexual abuse she suffered. And yes, Greg, it was abuse! Jane is a victim. She was groomed and then psychologically, emotionally, and sexually abused by the literal psycho you’ve been profiling in your podcast. Before the Jane interview, I was really intrigued by this story. That’s the only reason you’re getting 2 stars.
Read more
OverIt52019
Well told
Excellent reporting on this terrible person. I really appreciate the respect that the narrator gave to the people he talked to and about.
ciaradawn
NONE of this was Jane’s fault
Had to stop listening when Greg Bearup totally botched and mishandled the interview with Jane. Hammish was a MASTER manipulator and willing to engage in statutory rape and pedophila to defraud people, yet Greg says to Jane “ya know we all make mistakes when we are 17, it’s just that your mistakes were amplified by this guy.” No, Jane is not to blame here. But Greg did a great job retraumatizing and victim-blaming her. Almost as wonderful of a job as the United States Senate Judiciary Committee did with Dr. Ford and Brett Kavanaugh. What a disappointment! Go watch Abducted in Plain Sight, or read about how Robert Berchtold kidnapped his 12-year-old neighbor, Jan Broberg, *twice* and had sexual relations with her until she was 16 because they had to “stick to the story,” and then tell me that Jane is to blame for Hammish Watson’s treachery, duplicity, callousness, and psychopathy. [[TO JANE! This is not your fault! You were psychologically abused and manipulated by a psychopath before you’re prefrontal cortex had even fully developed. (It’s fully developed around 25.) Sending you all the love and good vibes, if you read this Jane!!]]
Read more
c1228g
Good yarn
Good yarn about an overlooked and underreported destructive crime. There are thousands of Hamish’s out there. Would like more detail about how Hamish groomed his victims with definitions of gas lighting, etc from the psych. Thought it was great that the interviewer let the victims tell the story. Disagree with other reviewers that “Jane” was victimized by interviewer. It’s obvious to me that she requested the interview and it’s a part of the healing process to be a part of this. Jane-you made no choice. You were not complicit. Hamish is a psychopath that enjoyed the game of sleeping with you in front of his wife. It was his way of gaslighting her and making her think she was crazy. Psychopaths enjoy the manipulation-stealing whatever people hold dear and ruining them. Money, self worth, dreams. Shame on the police and shame on Hamish’s family for not talking about him and giving the victims any insight into this psychopath!
Read more
keewee42
5 stars for Jane, 1 for interviewer
I was disturbed listening to the interview with Jane with how callous the interviewer was. You may have been interviewing a very young “adult,” she was telling a story of a child who was perpetrated on by an adult and you blamed her and highlighted her pain. Most adults with decades of experience fell prey to this man and this was a 16/17 year old being placed in impossible double binds. While I understand her feelings of responsibility to her family, it is painful thinking there wasn’t someone there to protect her when she needed it most. I hope she is finding her path and self worth. This interview allowed her to tell her story, but you, the interviewer, rubbed in her pain. That was cruel and for what....
Read more
Dana :D
Good with a caveat
A good podcast telling an interesting story, but the host’s interview with Jane felt exploitative and icky.
Lilly36333725
Poor Jane
Not impressed with the last “bonus” episode and the interview with Jane. Jane was a child who was groomed & I feel the host failed to fully grasp that. Hamish is fully to blame for the situation with Jane and any other explanation or perspective is misguided.
kcgf925
Too short
Very interesting podcast, but I expected more episodes.
bobfromaccounting18
Remarkable young woman
Those who are crying foul over this series are not paying attention. He does not call it a “relationship” until Jane first calls it a “relationship.” He does not call it an “affair” until Jane first calls it an “affair.” It is Jane, not the journalist, who conceded that she knowingly and conscientiously entered into an activity that she knew was wrong, and that she was complicit in the subsequent duplicity (her words, not his). Those who would shelter Jane under a “victim” status deny her own freedom to tell her own story, and completely devalue her expressions of regret and sorrow. Her story is touching and heartfelt and sincere, compelling because she is so sorry for what she did. The magnitude of Jack’s and Beck’s forgiveness—and the depth of her sorrow— is lost when Jane is denied the dignity of expressing her own regret. Her present healing is not found in her ability to extract herself from the wrongdoing, but in acknowledging her small part in it. She is a remarkable young woman and should be treated accordingly. Those who would shift all blame from her, unwittingly suggest that there is nothing she could have done differently to avoid the outcome. In other words, they force her into the role of a powerless victim, the very thing they think they are protecting her from. This series is just outstanding journalism.
Read more
USA Poddict
Irresponsible and infuriating
The host’s treatment of the discussion of Jane’s experience with Hammish with Beck, Jack, and her grandparents was irresponsible, but his interview with her was absolutely infuriating. To allow these people to discuss their point of view without giving the audience the proper context of understanding it was abuse, not an affair, is bad journalism and a dangerous way to frame the manipulation of a teenage girl. His interview with Jane herself took it to the point of complete lack of journalistic integrity, basic decency, or a fundamental understanding of abuse and victimization. “We all make mistakes at 17” does not describe her experience of being groomed and violated by a man 30 years her senior. This host has no idea what he is doing and should never be allowed to handle a story of such sensitive nature again.
Read more
SevenDaysBlog
The Bernie Madoff of Australia
The story as told by the victims.
Ldonelson
Victim blaming
Jane is a victim in every sense of the word - and instead is treated as an adult who made a bad decision. This kind of portrayal of child sexual abuse is not only inaccurate but dangerous. I now have doubt if Australian legislation and policy in child sexual abuse cases is on par with international standards because of the gross misrepresentation of the victim in this podcast.
MS0679
Starts strong, but wanes over time.
Loved the first few episodes, but it got much more repetitive and boring over time. Additional episodes didn’t seem to add to the story, but rather reinforce existing themes, to the point that it felt like beating a dead horse. Ended up giving up in episode 8, but wish I would’ve stopped a few sooner.
Cortneyl308
Hamish is no Gatsby. And Jane was sexually assaulted.
This is a superb series; I also loved The Teacher’s Pet (and sincerely hope that monster Chris Dawson finally sees justice). But PLEASE STOP BLAMING UNDERAGE VICTIMS OF SEXUAL ASSAULT FOR THE ABUSE. Jane (like Joanne in the Teacher’s Pet) was absolutely set upon by a predator, and I wish that the host would understand that she is a victim that Hamish abused in the most vile manner. Stop asking her questions like she just made choices about a “bad relationship” etc — Jane was the victim of a crime, not a woman who made bad decisions in an adult relationship. FFS. I really hope Bec and Jack can understand that Jane was ABUSED. At some point Hamish is compared to our (as in we Yanks) literary figure Jay Gatsby. Yeah, they both told lies about their histories — that’s where the similarity ends. Gatsby was a true romantic who fought for everything he had in life to win back Daisy (he actually served honorably in WWI — he’s not lying about that detail) and EARNED his money (even though the market and all of that speculation was very Wild West at that time). He wasn’t stealing money from vulnerable grandparents or preying sexually on a teenager while claiming to be her father. Ugh. Hamish is a disgusting predator. He’s no Gatsby — only in his own mind.
Read more
LydianalaMode
Affair?
Really love this podcast and teacher’s pet, but someone needs to be accountable in this case for calling June’s relationship with Hamish an affair. Jane began going to the dreaded household as a freshman in high school. How is being groomed by a trusted father figure an ‘affair’? A journalist ought to know the definition of a word. Hamish abused Jane, who was morally his own daughter.
aaaaaaa name
Great
5 stars
Sstinds
irresponsible host
As a lot of other reviews have pointed out I was consistently uncomfortable with the treatment of Jane, Hamish’s most vulnerable victim, and the host’s comments during her interview. For one, labeling the manipulation of a child at the hands of an adult man as an “affair” rather than grooming is extremely irresponsible. Everyone besides the host seemed to understand this. Jane showed a truly admirable amount of strength and maturity during her interview, but was constantly undercut by the host. It felt like he was trying his hardest to guilt her. “We all make mistakes when we’re 17.” Really?! That was appalling. Major kudos to her for dealing with those useless and unprofessional interjections. Irresponsible treatment of victims quickly turns true crime reporting into exploitation.
Read more
cbm12
Figured it would be good and I was right!
I listened to The Teacher’s Pet and thought it was really well done, so when I saw that this podcast is also from The Australian, I knew it would be good. And it is!
Asdfqweruiophjkl
Binge listen
I loved this Podcast, binged it all in a day. In reading the reviews many where being hypercritical of the portrayal of Jane. Worried that she was be cast in a negative light, however this podcast is clearly about Hamish's victims and she is one. The way the Australian presents it is engaging, he shows how people were feeling when everything was happened. (Ie the “affair”) By the last episode we’ve caught up and fully know Jane was being groomed and a victim. Great podcast, great journalism.
Read more
tmb30
Who the hell is hamish
Had to stop listening....keep up the good work
hairpatti
Bravo
Very well done!!!
Mjdnjskd hs
Fantastic
This was the best story telling podcast I have ever heard. 👍🏿
Mathu7777
Amazing with One Caveat
This podcast is incredibly well done, and it’s first-class journalism and storytelling. The only reason I’m giving it 4 stars is because of Jane’s portrayal as having had an affair with Hamish. She was 16 when he began grooming her for her grandparents’ money. Words like victimized, targeted, stalked, or even raped would be more accurate.
Ypsi8446
Jane
I hope “Jane” reads this and knows that she is so strong to be working so hard to be able to forgive herself, and know that our past mistakes do not define us, and she is helping countless people, including myself, to tell her story. I have nothing but admiration for this young woman, and you make us all more brave. This podcast was an excellent insight into a depraved mind, and hopefully makes us all a bit more wise in our financial dealings.
Read more
KerryN1218
Jane
I truly hope “Jane” understands that absolutely no blame can be attached to her. She was a child. A child who no one protected. She was groomed & manipulated by a grown man. A grown man who many wealthy adults trusted. She was lied to, raped and took advantage of when her brain and body were still developing. The woman who she lived with should have had her move out or move to her grandparents home when she knew her husband was taking advantage of Jane. Her own grandparents should have been more involved. Perhaps child protective services should have been more involved. Again there is absolutely NO blame on Jane. Jane I hope you live a beautiful life moving forward. I hope you know this happened to you and you did not cause this. I hope you find a man who is kind and loving to be your partner and you both do amazing things together in this world. I think you will be an inspiration to many young women who have survived abuse. Blessings to you.
Read more
13CJB
Binge Listen!
Such a devastating story for so many people. “Jane’s” bonus interview was particularly heart breaking. Such a young age to be effected by such and evil man, in no way her fault, but the devastating guilt she must feel is palpable. I wish there had been more interviews like the bonus episode where we could get a lore in depth feeling for the individuals involved, what they went through and are still going through today. Overall, a great podcast!
Read more
mama_epps
Who the hell is Hamish - Bonus episode Jane
This is a fantastic podcast. I have thought son throughout but the amount of respect shown to “Jane” with the publishing of this bonus episode is astounding. She is an incredibly strong and beautiful person and while it may not impact her directly I feel that she should her from everyone how much she is not at fault and I wish I could give her any strength I have to help her forgive herself. Thank you!
Read more
Hnljen
I was groomed too
Hearing “Jane” was like listening to my own thoughts and feelings finally articulated in ways I never could. Hope that manipulative bastard suffers.
Killerdevdasi
Load more