White Collar Advice
White Collar Advice
Justin Paperny
He Shook His Head and Got Nine More Months
1 minutes Posted Aug 12, 2026 at 3:28 pm.
0:00
1:09
Download MP3
Show notes

Did you ever see Animal House? Thank you sir, may I have another. Someone asked me why a defendant would shake his head in front of the judge while the victim was speaking, and why the judge gave him an extra nine months for it. He had had enough. He didn't believe the victim was actually a victim. Think about what was stacked up behind that head shake: a plea agreement he didn't agree with, Department of Justice press releases that were made up, banks firing him, losing his job, losing friends, not working well with his lawyer, not vested in the probation report, the sentencing memorandum, a terrible allocution. It hit him while the victim was speaking and he couldn't take it anymore. Had he identified what success was, he would have kept taking it a little longer. Nine additional months in prison.