Two Off The Tee
Two Off The Tee
Jeff Shin
Are Golf Handicaps Actually Fair? | Match Play, League Drama & LIV vs PGA
1 hour 31 minutes Posted Feb 2, 2026 at 12:48 pm.
– James takes over as host02:30 – How we actually got into golf07:10 – Golf, perfectionism, and why we’re addicted10:40 – Handicap goals and improving vs maintaining15:00 – Why short game and putting separate golfers18:30 – Almost quitting golf (shanks, frustration, reality)24:15 – Match play vs stroke play for amateurs31:50 – Range mats vs grass debate36:10 – The handicap rule that caused backlash43:30 – Why the worst golfer winning is a problem50:00 – Incentives to improve (or not)58:00 – LIV vs PGA, suspensions, and hypocrisy1:07:30 – Is LIV dying?1:11:00 – TGL, simulator golf, and women competing with men1:28:45 – Final thoughts and what’s next for the club
0:00
1:31:57
Download MP3
Show notes
In this episode, James takes the host chair and puts Jeff on the spot. We break down how we actually got into golf, why perfection drives us insane, and how handicaps might be breaking amateur competition.We dive deep into:Why high handicaps keep winning leaguesWhether match play is better than stroke play for amateursThe controversial “exceptional score” handicap ruleIncentives (or lack of them) to actually improve at golfLIV vs PGA politics, suspensions, and favoritismWhy simulator golf and TGL aren’t landing with fansShould women compete with men in simulator golf?This episode is part golf therapy session, part league commissioner debate, and part reality check for amateur golfers who say they want fairness — until the rules change.00:00 – James takes over as host02:30 – How we actually got into golf07:10 – Golf, perfectionism, and why we’re addicted10:40 – Handicap goals and improving vs maintaining15:00 – Why short game and putting separate golfers18:30 – Almost quitting golf (shanks, frustration, reality)24:15 – Match play vs stroke play for amateurs31:50 – Range mats vs grass debate36:10 – The handicap rule that caused backlash43:30 – Why the worst golfer winning is a problem50:00 – Incentives to improve (or not)58:00 – LIV vs PGA, suspensions, and hypocrisy1:07:30 – Is LIV dying?1:11:00 – TGL, simulator golf, and women competing with men1:28:45 – Final thoughts and what’s next for the club