Long time, no see! Welcome to our scariest episode yet. This time Cyndi starts us off with the story of Timothy King and the never caught Babysitter Killer. Up front warning: this one's hella sad. Niko doesn't lighten the mood though, because he (unfortunately) opens our mind up to The Rake. The frightening creature that's probably in your bedroom by now. Have fun!

Got any spooky stories? Send all your scary experiences (paranormal OR true crime) to us at [email protected] with the subject "Scaring is Caring" or "Listener Story" for the chance to be featured in our monthly bonus episodes!

Find us on Instagram, Twitter, and Facebook @truthandscare!

Theme Music: Sarah O'Heeron (@shutupsarah on fiverr)