
Daniel Mills (guest star on The Aftermath) takes a break to play our favorite trivia game with Jordan Katcher. After giving us a taste of his singing skills, Daniel reminds us that a majority of these crimes are the results of white people nonsense. He has that fact down but does he have enough true crime knowledge to score a spot on the Leader Board and make it to our final episode? Play along and find out!Current Leader Board:Ryan Pigg - 12 PointsAustin Kress - 11 PointsKirk Novak - 9 PointsCreated and hosted by Jordan Katcher and executive produced by Daniel Fastenau-Jones and Schuyler Fastenau-Jones. Editing and sound design by Schuyler Fastenau-Jones.To submit your own questions, email us at [email protected] us on:YouTubeInstagramTwitterOther Lil' Bit Fastenau Shows:The Original Deadtime StoriesThe AftermathCereal KillerzCocktail Ballerina
Mar 1, 2023
22 min

Austin Kress claims to look stupid (his words, not ours) but is that attitude just a ploy to trick Jordan into thinking he won't win today's game? Play along to find out if Austin can earn a spot on our leader board and make it to the final game of the season to see who's the best at spotting a true crime and a false crime.Current Leader Board:Ryan Pigg - 12 PointsKirk Novak - 9 PointsVeronica Matthews, Jeremy Staple & Bri Giger - 7 PointsCreated and hosted by Jordan Katcher and executive produced by Daniel Fastenau-Jones and Schuyler Fastenau-Jones. Editing and sound design by Schuyler Fastenau-Jones.To submit your own questions, email us at [email protected] us on:YouTubeInstagramTwitterOther Lil' Bit Fastenau Shows:The Original Deadtime StoriesThe AftermathCereal KillerzCocktail Ballerina
Feb 1, 2023
23 min

Bri Giger, a HUGE fan of (short) Netflix true crime documentaries, pays the set a visit to see if she can correctly guess if that was a true crime or a false crime. Will Bri be able to make it on the Leader Board? Or will she just reconfirm that we simply can not trust Jordan? Play along and find out!Current Leader Board:Ryan Pigg - 12 PointsKirk Novak - 9 PointsVeronica Matthews & Jeremy Staple - 7 PointsCreated and hosted by Jordan Katcher and executive produced by Daniel Fastenau-Jones and Schuyler Fastenau-Jones. Editing and sound design by Schuyler Fastenau-Jones.To submit your own questions, email us at [email protected] us on:YouTubeInstagramTwitterOther Lil' Bit Fastenau Shows:The Original Deadtime StoriesThe AftermathCereal KillerzCocktail Ballerina
Jan 18, 2023
20 min

Longtime voice actor on The Original Deadtime Stories, Jeremy Staple, plays along with Jordan to see if he can tell whether he just heard a true crime or a false crime. Can Jeremy's personal spirit, Miss Cleo, guide him to the correct answers and a spot on the leader board? Or will he just be left second-guessing himself? Play along and find out!Current Leader Board:Ryan Pigg - 12 PointsKirk Novak - 9 PointsVeronica Matthews - 7 PointsCreated and hosted by Jordan Katcher and executive produced by Daniel Fastenau-Jones and Schuyler Fastenau-Jones. Editing and sound design by Schuyler Fastenau-Jones.To submit your own questions, email us at [email protected] us on:YouTubeInstagramTwitterOther Lil' Bit Fastenau Shows:The Original Deadtime StoriesThe AftermathCereal KillerzCocktail Ballerina
Jan 4, 2023
21 min

Krystal Mosley loves true crime documentaries and is confident she can secure a spot on the leader board after answering our favorite question: was that a true crime or a false crime? Get ready to play along and see if you would be today's top scorer!Current Leader Board:Ryan Pigg - 12 PointsKirk Novak - 9 PointsVeronica Matthews - 7 PointsCreated and hosted by Jordan Katcher and executive produced by Daniel Fastenau-Jones and Schuyler Fastenau-Jones. Editing and sound design by Schuyler Fastenau-Jones.To submit your own questions, email us at [email protected] us on:YouTubeInstagramTwitterOther Lil' Bit Fastenau Shows:The Original Deadtime StoriesThe AftermathCereal KillerzCocktail Ballerina
Dec 28, 2022
19 min

Veronica Matthews is (begrudgingly) here to answer whether what we just heard was a true crime or a false crime. As a self proclaimed loather of horror films and murder documentaries, will she be able to earn a spot on our leader board or, perhaps more importantly, succeed in being the WORST player in True Crime False Crime history? Let's play along and find out.Current Leader Board:1st: Ryan Pigg - 12 Points2nd: Kirk Novak - 9 PointsCreated and hosted by Jordan Katcher and executive produced by Daniel Fastenau-Jones and Schuyler Fastenau-Jones. Editing and sound design by Schuyler Fastenau-Jones.To submit your own questions, email us at [email protected] us on:YouTubeInstagramTwitterOther Lil' Bit Fastenau Shows:The Original Deadtime StoriesThe AftermathCereal KillerzCocktail Ballerina
Dec 21, 2022
37 min

Today Ryan Pigg takes on the famous question, "Hey! Was that a true crime or a false crime?" After discussing how everyone rates last meals as five stars blah blah blah, Ryan aims to take over Kirk Novak's spot on the Leader Board!Current Leader Board:1st: Kirk Novak - 9 PointsCreated and hosted by Jordan Katcher and executive produced by Daniel Fastenau-Jones and Schuyler Fastenau-Jones. Editing and sound design by Schuyler Fastenau-Jones.To submit your own questions, email us at [email protected] us on:YouTube: https://youtu.be/iTQdnWfzGUUInstagram: https://www.instagram.com/truecrimefalsecrime/Twitter: https://www.twitter.com/TrueCrimeFalse
Dec 14, 2022
22 min

Welcome to True Crime False Crime! In our first episode, Jordan Katcher challenges Kirk Novak to answer that age old question, "Was that a true crime or a false crime?" Will Kirk earn enough points to make it in the top three contestants this season and come back for the finale? Play along and find out!Created and hosted by Jordan Katcher and executive produced by Daniel Fastenau-Jones and Schuyler Fastenau-Jones. Editing and sound design by Schuyler Fastenau-Jones.To submit your own questions, email us at [email protected] us on:YouTube: https://youtu.be/ly4tZdbci0IInstagram: https://www.instagram.com/truecrimefalsecrime/Twitter: https://www.twitter.com/TrueCrimeFalse
Dec 3, 2022
13 min