In this “Theology Unpacked” episode, Dr John Moffatt SJ follows the story to Jesus’ first trial before the high priest and the council, comparing how each Gospel narrates this moment and drawing out the theological importance of the judgment theme.
Mark and Matthew present an informal trial focused on Jesus’ identity, Luke reshapes the scene to emphasise political motives, and John offers a uniquely fragmented account in which Jesus’ claims have already provoked judgment long before the hearing.
Across all four versions, Jesus’ self-revelation in a moment of utter vulnerability becomes the catalyst for condemnation, while the leaders frame him as a political threat to be handed over to Rome.
📧 Follow us on Substack
📚 Explore the wide range of reading materials in the Heythrop Library🤓 Join online or in-person courses at the London Jesuit Centre
If you find our podcasts helpful, please consider donating to the London Jesuit Centre.

