In this episode of The Remake Mistake, Mike and Eric nip at 1978’s Piranha and it’s 2010 remake Piranha 3D. They discuss inexcusably bad effects, intentionally bad movies, porn star boats, and the heroic adventures of a claymation fish monster. Eric questions inconsistent piranha attacks, while Mike brings up Jaws as much as he can. All this and more while answering the question “was this remake a mistake?”