In this episode of The Remake Mistake, Mike and Eric are on the naughty list with 1984’s Silent Night, Deadly Night and the 2012 remake, Silent Night. They discuss a shockingly bad Malcolm McDowell performance, squandered ideas, the season to punish, and whether or not it’s Christmas when you’re on the warm side of the door. Eric learns a hard lesson about the word “iconic”, while Mike throws another Logue on the Donal. All this and more while answering the question “was this remake a mistake?”