The MAKE IT Podcast
The MAKE IT Podcast
Chris Barkley & Nicholas Buggs
444 - Oscar Boyson on Directing Our Hero, Balthazar, Working with The Neistat Brothers, Empathy Machines vs. Validation Machines, and Failing in Public
1 hour 23 minutes Posted Aug 21, 2026 at 9:30 am.
0:00
1:23:16
Download MP3
Show notes

This episode is brought to you by Anthropic. Claude is the AI for minds that don’t stop at good enough—it's the collaborator that actually understands your entire workflow and thinks WITH you, not for you. Ready to tackle bigger problems? Sign up for Claude Pro when you use our link – www.claude.ai/makeit


This episode is brought to you by our e-book Mastering Film Marketing. Get your copy today at https://themakeitpodcast.com/products/mastering-film-marketing. Use the Discount code: NASHFILM20 for 20% off EVERYTHING at themakeitpodcast.com


Hello, Hello! 

In this episode, Chris & Papa Bear sit down with filmmaker Oscar Boyson to discuss his directorial debut, Our Hero, Balthazar, a provocative and critically talked-about indie film that has been called the most controversial movie of the year. Oscar shares how his unconventional path — from competitive freestyle skier in Maine to Craigslist hire at the Neistat Brothers' studio — shaped him into the filmmaker he is today. The conversation spans filmmaking craft, the dangers of AI dependency, the power of perseverance over ideas, and what it truly means to get an independent film in front of audiences.


We also talk about:

  • The thematic parallels between Our Hero, Balthazar, and the 1995 indie classic Kids, including how both films straddle the line between being cautionary tales for parents and romanticized adventures for younger viewers
  • The growing role of AI tools like ChatGPT in everyday decision-making, and whether over-reliance on AI is creating a generation that can no longer think or fail independently — including the concept of "Gellman Amnesia" as a lens for understanding AI's credibility problem
  • The social media "validation machine" phenomenon, how algorithms reinforce existing beliefs and behaviors, and what that means for youth culture, mental health, and even real-world violence
  • The importance of perseverance over ideas in the creative process, drawing on Casey Neistat's famous motto — "Ideas are common, perseverance is rare" — and how Oscar applied that philosophy to his own career and filmmaking journey
  • The practical and ethical considerations of using firearms and blank-firing weapons on an indie film set in the post-Rust era, including the critical role of a professional armorer and the creative reasoning behind using blanks for actor authenticity


People, Places, Products, and Websites Mentioned:

People

Oscar Boyson

Casey Neistat

Van Neistat

Ricky Camilleri

Nate DeYoung

Josh & Benny Safdie

Greta Gerwig

Noah Baumbach

Tom Sachs

Frank Gehry

Asa Butterfield

Jaeden Martell

Stephen Phelps

Christopher Messina

Lena Dunham

Sam Lisenco

Harmony Korine

Rosario Dawson

Chloë Sevigny

Roger Ebert

Gene Siskel

Oscar Hammerstein II

Oscar Micheaux

Oscar Isaac

Oscar Levant

Dick Gregory

MrBeast

Jordan Gallant (composer)

Spike Lee

Spike Jonze

David Fincher

Gaspar Noé

Andrew Tate

Big Mike (Oscar’s father)

Elise (Oscar’s sister)

Films

Our Hero, Balthazar

Kids (1995)

Frances Ha

Good Time

Heaven Knows What

Adolescence

The Odyssey

Boogie Nights

Trainspotting

Taxi Driver

Straw Dogs (1971)

Jour de fête

The Last Temptation of Christ

Irréversible

Ex Machina

A Most Violent Year

Lady Be Good (1941)

State Fair (1945)


TV Shows

The Neistat Brothers


Platforms, Websites & Tools

ChatGPT / OpenAI

Craigslist

Vimeo

The Wayback Machine

Digital Cinema Package (DCP)

Art House Convergence


Places

Williams Center

Nashville, Tennessee

Maryland

Lower Antioch / Woodbine — Nashville neighborhoods

Maine

New York City

North Texas

Hawaii

Tribeca Festival

Nashville Film Festival

Belcourt Theatre

Regal Opry Mills


Products & Brands

Tesla Supercharger

Tesla app

Canon EOS 5D Mark II

Chick-fil-A


Concepts & References

Gell-Mann Amnesia Effect

Parasocial relationships

The Covenant School shooting

Nineteen Eighty-Four

Stoneman Douglas / Parkland

Four-walling

“Ideas are common, perseverance is rare” — Casey Neistat motto

“Movies are empathy machines” — Roger Ebert


We are humbled to have a community of creatives who care deeply about our work. And your support makes our work possible. Every subscriber, rating, and review matters. 

So, if you like what we're doing, please consider subscribing, rating, or giving us a review. Cheers, and best of luck on your filmmaking journey. #MAKEIT

www.themakeitpodcast.store/shop/support



Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands

Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy