Welcome to the first episode of Tell Me When It's Over! In today's episode, hosts Lucy O'Brien and Claire Reilly lay out the ground rules: one of them loves horror, one of them is terrified of it, but each week they'll take turns choosing a horror movie to watch and dissect. Can Claire make it past the opening credits? Can Lucy convince her to love a good scare? Will their friendship survive this torture?

What better way to test the boundaries than with the 1978 classic, Halloween.