Tell Me Something Now
Tell Me Something Now
Tell me something now
Movie Review: Joker 2
9 minutes Posted Oct 4, 2024 at 2:31 pm.
0:00
9:59
Download MP3
Show notes

Reviews of Joker: Folie à Deux

Joker: Folie à Deux, the sequel to the 2019 film Joker, has been released to mixed reviews. While some critics praise its ambition and the performances of Lady Gaga and Joaquin Phoenix, most find it a disappointing and tedious retread of its predecessor.

  • The film as musical pastiche: Critics agree that the film's musical numbers, while unexpected, are largely unsuccessful. Caroline Siede of Girl Culture describes them as "25% away from reaching their full potential", while the reviewer for A Movie Guy calls them "repetitive". Spectrum Culture claims they represent "empty symbols of some old Hollywood style" that the film never fully commits to.
  • Critique of societal sensationalism: Folie à Deux attempts to satirize society's obsession with violence and spectacle, particularly through Arthur Fleck's trial. However, most reviewers find the critique heavy-handed and ultimately hypocritical, arguing that the film itself revels in the very sensationalism it condemns. Men’s Journal states, "Joker: Folie à Deux wants to critique a system that rightfully deserves to be gutted and inspected for its obsession with sensationalism but instead becomes the very thing it wants to reject."
  • Character of Harley Quinn: Lady Gaga's performance as Harley Quinn (or rather, Harleen Quinzel, as the character is never explicitly named as such) is generally well-received, with critics praising her charisma and musical talent. However, many note that the character is underdeveloped, relegated to the role of the "Manic Pixie Dream Girl" trope.
  • Director Todd Phillips' stylistic shift from Scorsese homage to musical pastiche is jarring and ultimately unsuccessful.
  • The film's attempts at social commentary are muddled and unconvincing.
  • Joaquin Phoenix's performance, while committed, is overshadowed by Gaga's.
  • The film suffers from an incoherent plot and a lack of focus.
  • Despite a few intriguing ideas, Joker: Folie à Deux is ultimately a tedious and forgettable experience.

Key Quotes:

  • "Not only is Folie à Deux a Chicago rip-off, it’s a Primal Fear rip-off too, with a bit of Moon Knight thrown in for good measure." - Girl Culture
  • "The joke is, perhaps, on anyone who thought this would work." - A Movie Guy
  • "When you hold so much disdain for everything and everyone, there is nothing and no one left to root for, leaving nothing but a deeply unpleasant two hours and twenty minutes that has you desperately wanting to escape the theatre." - Men’s Journal
  • "This year’s Joker sees the pastiche that haunted the first film fully consume this project, ending up with something that feels too underthought and half-baked to stand outside of its own mimicry of musicals and courtroom dramas, while committing the worst crime of all, being tediously boring." - Spectrum Culture

Conclusion:

Joker: Folie à Deux is a divisive film that will likely appeal to fans of Lady Gaga and those who enjoyed the first Joker. However, its flaws – a weak script, uneven tone, and derivative plot – will likely alienate many viewers. It remains to be seen whether the film will enjoy the same commercial success as its predecessor.