Remember cassette tapes? Remember mixtapes? Kevin and Noah hysterically discuss six songs each that they would have recorded onto a mixtape for girls when they were teenagers, and their different reasons for making mixtapes. They also give a 1-10 rating for each of their songs. Kevin talks through songs from Bon Jovi, Foreigner, Motley Crue, Poison, Skid Row, and Warrant while Noah discusses his choices of Echo & the Bunnymen, U2, 10CC, Nick Lowe, The Cure, and Peter Gabriel.