Elliot and John watch "The Cat, the Bat and the Very Ugly" from THE BATMAN. When nostalgia for 1992's BATMAN RETURNS leads to another Catwoman/Penguin team-up, it's up to the Caped Crusader (post-Conroy, pre-Bader) to cage his animalistic adversaries! Is this Dark Knight worthy of the cape and cowl, or should he pass on the mantle to John Blake already? Plus: Why doesn't Elliot care for Selina Kyle? Listen to find out!