Hour 2: Tommy has the nerve to say both sides have a valid point. The Yankees keep pace with the Rays. What really went wrong for the 2026 Mets. Are Mets fans more anti-Stearns or pro-Pete?

Was it fair for the Mets to think Pete Alonso will decline soon?

When the lights dim, After Hours with Tommy Lugauer keeps New York sports talk rolling. The show blends listener-driven conversation with thoughtful analysis and honest reactions to the day’s biggest stories. From late-game takes on the Yankees, Mets, Giants and Jets to broader league discussions and fan calls, After Hours is equal parts recap and release valve.Tommy Lugauer provides the perfect close to the sports day with his unique takes, fun conversation and connection to the audience.