On Halloween night in 1974, Timothy O'Bryan dies after eating a Pixy Stix he got while trick or treating. Was there a stranger handing out poisoned candy or was the culprit a little closer to home?

The One With The Polygrapher

Each week, southerners Ellen Chandler, Hilary Mills, and Madison Reeves sit down to spill the not-so-sweet tea on a homicide or heinous crime that has taken place in the South. These may be well-known crimes or ones that happened in towns you’ve never heard of, but the ladies are recounting the details of the crime and sharing their initial reactions. It just goes to show - Southern hospitality doesn’t ring true for everyone.