Sinister and Sarcastic
Sinister and Sarcastic
Drew, Bailey, and Lacey
Episode 147: Haunted by the Devil: New Jersey's Satanic Panic
55 minutes Posted Sep 28, 2025 at 5:20 am.
0:00
55:49
Download MP3
Show notes

Dark whispers swept through New Jersey during the height of the Satanic Panic. In the shadows of the Watchung Reservation, the mysterious death of Jeanette DePalma sparked rumors of ritual sacrifice. In a quiet suburban mansion, John List carried out murders he believed were commanded by God. And in the grip of obsession, Patrick Michael Newell blurred the line between devotion and darkness. These chilling tales reveal how fear and faith twisted into terror in the Garden State.