Think you remember 90s horror as wall-to-wall bangers? We put that memory on trial. After watching and rating 27 films from the decade, we map the real terrain: a handful of genre-defining masterpieces surrounded by bloated runtimes, limp sequels, and ideas stretched past their breaking point. We swap nostalgia for evidence, then rebuild our list—crowning the films that endure and demoting the ones coasting on reputation. We start with the numbers: which movies racked up the wildest body cou...