Show notes
This episode explores the various ways social media information is being used to evaluate job applicants and provides expert opinions on their viability and general acceptance. Special guest Dr. Shawn Bergman’s expertise in the area of social media for hiring, as well as his own research provide a great backdrop for filtering general perceptions about this hot topic. The conclusions drawn provide a useful context for anyone interested in exploring the use of social media data as an assessment tool.
Before looking at the various ways social data is used in hiring, it is important to look at the some of the issues that apply to using social media data to make employment decisions.
Concerns
There are four overall areas of concern when it comes to using social data as an assessment.
1. Problems with source materials- There are a great deal of individual differences in the use of social media. For instance, both Dr. Bergman and Dr. Handler admit that they are not very active on social platforms. It seems logical that a lack of data based on infrequent posting or not using a particular channel- could have a negative impact on an applicant’s evaluation. The potential differences in how much people post and where- represent a challenge when comparing them to others who may post frequently to many channels.
2. Accuracy- The accuracy of social media data in measuring human traits is speculative at best. Without confidence in construct related measures- the value of social data as a predictor of job performance is suspect. Of course it is possible to simply correlate patterns extracted from social data with performance metrics- but this brings us right back to the same issues raised with most AI based evaluation tools. Unfortunately, many companies making social media assessment tools do not involve I/O psychologists - adding additional concerns when it comes to the measurement of actual job related constructs.
3. Privacy- The default assumption with social data in hiring is that the individual being evaluated has not given specific consent for their information to be used. This is probably the most talked about issue when it comes to social media data for hiring, and one that will not go away anytime soon. One of the main problems in the realm of privacy is that it is often impossible for an individual to know their data is being used to evaluate them. While opting in is becoming a standard requirement- it is virtually impossible to police the use of tools that harvest and evaluate social media data. There is also the question of who owns social data. Questions of data ownership can turn the concept of privacy on its ear- requiring legal precedent and legislation to sort out.
4. Bias- There are several ways bias can enter the room when it comes to hiring and social media data. Any process in which profiles are reviewed manually presents a serious snakepit when it comes to bias. Automated tools are also famous for creating systematic biases when making evaluations. While there is some great work being done to train AI/ML to actually reduce bias, the fact remains that social media data helps keep the very real issue of bias alive and well.
Use Cases
Dr. Bergman reports that 70% of organizations use some form of social or public data when evaluating applicants. So how are they using these tools?
Manual review of profiles/posts
While the sexiest and most talked about use case centers around the use of AI based tools to systematically evaluate data from social media accounts and posts, the lowest hanging fruit when it comes to the use of social data for hiring decisions is the simple review of profiles by humans. Social media data is often used for a very low tech and manualized process of reviewing profiles of job candidates to look for inappropriate information, revealing posts, etc. This process is accessible to anyone with a...
Before looking at the various ways social data is used in hiring, it is important to look at the some of the issues that apply to using social media data to make employment decisions.
Concerns
There are four overall areas of concern when it comes to using social data as an assessment.
1. Problems with source materials- There are a great deal of individual differences in the use of social media. For instance, both Dr. Bergman and Dr. Handler admit that they are not very active on social platforms. It seems logical that a lack of data based on infrequent posting or not using a particular channel- could have a negative impact on an applicant’s evaluation. The potential differences in how much people post and where- represent a challenge when comparing them to others who may post frequently to many channels.
2. Accuracy- The accuracy of social media data in measuring human traits is speculative at best. Without confidence in construct related measures- the value of social data as a predictor of job performance is suspect. Of course it is possible to simply correlate patterns extracted from social data with performance metrics- but this brings us right back to the same issues raised with most AI based evaluation tools. Unfortunately, many companies making social media assessment tools do not involve I/O psychologists - adding additional concerns when it comes to the measurement of actual job related constructs.
3. Privacy- The default assumption with social data in hiring is that the individual being evaluated has not given specific consent for their information to be used. This is probably the most talked about issue when it comes to social media data for hiring, and one that will not go away anytime soon. One of the main problems in the realm of privacy is that it is often impossible for an individual to know their data is being used to evaluate them. While opting in is becoming a standard requirement- it is virtually impossible to police the use of tools that harvest and evaluate social media data. There is also the question of who owns social data. Questions of data ownership can turn the concept of privacy on its ear- requiring legal precedent and legislation to sort out.
4. Bias- There are several ways bias can enter the room when it comes to hiring and social media data. Any process in which profiles are reviewed manually presents a serious snakepit when it comes to bias. Automated tools are also famous for creating systematic biases when making evaluations. While there is some great work being done to train AI/ML to actually reduce bias, the fact remains that social media data helps keep the very real issue of bias alive and well.
Use Cases
Dr. Bergman reports that 70% of organizations use some form of social or public data when evaluating applicants. So how are they using these tools?
Manual review of profiles/posts
While the sexiest and most talked about use case centers around the use of AI based tools to systematically evaluate data from social media accounts and posts, the lowest hanging fruit when it comes to the use of social data for hiring decisions is the simple review of profiles by humans. Social media data is often used for a very low tech and manualized process of reviewing profiles of job candidates to look for inappropriate information, revealing posts, etc. This process is accessible to anyone with a...


