REvaluation Podcast
REvaluation Podcast
fteval
REvaluation Special #3: Peer Review in Transition
51 minutes Posted May 26, 2025 at 11:00 pm.
Intro
Introduction to the panel discussion and panelists
Jakob Edler on the relationships between peer review and bibliometrics under CoARA
Grit Laudel on the need for a transformative change and how to achieve it
Nicholas Vonortas on AI and peer review
Julia Melkers - our time is precious, but what are we trying to be free of?
Nicolas Robinson-Garcia on the trade-off between time for writing papers and time for reviewing them
Q&A: Is there a decline in the academic system overall?
Q&A: Incentives fueling use of AI - can these be change?
Q&A: More and more people will produce knowledge - how to communicate this in an efficient manner?
Q&A: Behaviour of publishing houses regarding AI
Concluding Panel responses
Outro
0:00
51:58
Download MP3
Show notes
Peer review is a central instrument for the self-governance of the scientific community and for legitimizing e.g. funding decisions made towards both scolars and society. However, it is intransparent and time-consuming, especially so because more and more publications are produced. Therefore, the need to increase its quality and reliability was often recognized in the past years. Today, additional challenges have emerged such as generative AI, the occurance of predatory journals, paper/review...