Relationship Truth: Unfiltered
Relationship Truth: Unfiltered
Leslie Vernick
Your Faith Is Not Broken, but Your Soul might be Shattered. Here Is How to Heal It
48 minutes Posted Nov 16, 2026 at 8:00 am.
0:00
48:07
Download MP3
Show notes
Show Notes
Has the church ever made your pain worse instead of better? Maybe you reached out for help and were told to pray more, forgive faster, or simply stay quiet. Maybe the very place that was supposed to protect you became one more place where you felt silenced, shamed, and unseen.
If that is your story, you are not alone — and this episode was made for you.
In this powerful conversation, Leslie sits down with Colleen Ramser, EMDR-certified licensed professional counselor, trauma specialist, and author of the brand-new book The Shattered Soul: Restoring Wholeness and Rebuilding Your Faith After Spiritual Trauma. Together, they name what the church rarely gives women permission to say out loud, explain why trying harder has not been working, and walk through the gentle, embodied, faith-rooted path toward true healing. You will leave this episode with language for what you have been living, compassion for why you feel stuck, and real first steps you can actually take — right where you are.
Key Takeaways
 
Spiritual Abuse and Spiritual Trauma Are Not the Same Thing — and the Difference Matters
Colleen defines spiritual abuse as any person or system in a position of perceived or real authority using any means necessary — manipulation, exploitation, theological pressure, or even the withdrawal of spiritual care — to secure a desired outcome at the expense of your spiritual well-being. Spiritual trauma is what happens inside you as a lasting result, when your faith itself becomes a trigger. Understanding the distinction helps you stop blaming yourself for why you cannot simply get back to normal, because what happened to you was not a spiritual failure on your part.
 
Your Body Is Not the Enemy — It Is a Messenger God Gave You
One of the most freeing conversations in this episode is the one about the body. Colleen introduces the concept of the somatic soul — the reality that you are an interwoven being of mind, body, and soul, and that trauma fragments all three at once. When your nervous system is still on high alert even after your mind has accepted the theological truth that you are safe, that is not weakness or lack of faith. That is your God-designed body doing exactly what it was created to do. Leslie reminds listeners that God himself placed the Holy Spirit inside the physical body, and that Scripture — from Psalm 23 to Isaiah 32 — honors the body as a site of real spiritual restoration.
 
Healing Requires Small Doses, Not White-Knuckling Your Way Forward
Colleen introduces two concepts from her book that are genuinely life-giving for women who have felt like failures at their own recovery. Titration means intentionally working in small doses rather than forcing yourself through spiritual disciplines that currently feel like harm. Pendulation means noticing when something is too much and moving toward something that is life-giving instead — a walk, the quiet of nature, a moment of stillness. The way back to faith, Colleen has found, is almost always less is more. Pushing faster tends to leave unhealed parts of your story behind.
 
You Do Not Have to Go to the Wound First — Start with What Feels Neutral
For women whose trauma lives directly in the body — through sexual abuse, physical harm, or medical crisis — Colleen offers the compassionate practice of neutral sensations. You do not have to focus on the place that hurts. You can begin with something as simple as your big toe, a part of your body that feels neither good nor bad, just present. That neutral sensation becomes a bridge, a small anchor of safety in the present moment, and a foundation from which your capacity for healing can slowly be built — the way a muscle is built, one small effort at a time.
 
Reclaiming Your Voice Begins with Reclaiming Your Presence
For the woman who has been told she is rebellious for speaking up, who has been spiritually gaslit into silence, the first step is not a confrontation. It is a moment of grounding. Colleen cal