Radio Active Magazine
Radio Active Magazine
KKFI 90.1 FM Kansas City Community Radio
Externalities including global warming, health, news, and corruption
30 minutes Posted Jul 11, 2022 at 10:06 pm.
0:00
30:10
Download MP3
Show notes
Craig Lubow interviews Spencer Graves about "Externalities including global warming, health, news, and corruption". A research paper Spencer wrote on "Externalities, public goods, and infectious diseases" was accepted without revision and published last March in Real-World Economics Review, a refereed economics journal. It's rare for the referees in a journal like that to accept a paper without revision. Spencer holds a PhD in Statistics and has spent time modeling economic data.

Externalities are costs and benefits to society that are not reflected in the price to the consumer. So people who are making decisions about whether and what to buy, when, are pushed to make decisions that may harm society, because the price does not reflect the all the issues involved in that economic transaction.

There is a general principle in economics that free competitive markets are the most efficient way known to allocate scarce resources to the extent that all the costs and benefits to society are appropriately reflected in the price to the consumer and the consumer can adequately judge quality.

Markets with externalities cannot function optimally to benefit society unless those externalities are properly internalized into the market transactions.

Fossil fuels like gasoline should be taxed in proportion to the damage they do to society. If that were done, the problem of global warming would gracefully disappear as consumers moved to consume less fossil fuels, do more work remotely via the Internet, and buy goods and services supplied using greener energy. Consumers would buy more electric cars and use more public transit. The demand for intercity passenger rail would likely increase.

Instead, fossil fuels receive subsidies, some dating back to 1789, when the very first US Congress slapped a tariff on the sale of British coal slipped into U.S. ports as ship ballast:1 That tariff indirectly subsidized the US coal industry.

When it comes to gasoline, however, current taxes on gasoline are designed to pay for the costs of building and maintaining roads. The major petroleum companies actually get subsidies estimated at roughly 28 cents per gallon, when the price of gasoline should include a pollution tax of at least 42 cents per gallon.2

Fossil fuel subsidies have been continued for five reasons.

First and most obviously, the recipients of those subsidies make political campaign contributions without which many politicians cannot get elected.
Second, they pay an army of lobbyists to convince congress to continue those subsidies.
Third, fossil fuel companies advertise. That gives media organization that accept advertising a conflict of interest in honestly reporting on any favors those companies get from government.
Fourth, the major commercial broadcasters make lots of money from selling ads to political campaigns in election years. Any information that could help politicians get elected with a lower advertising budget would threaten their profitability.
Finally, every human thinks they know more than they do. That predisposes people everywhere to accept what they get from the media they consume. The vast majority of humans would be more successful in life if we spent a little more time identifying major issues than concern us and then seeking information that might conflict with our preconceptions. This was a key insight, documented in research led by Daniel Kahneman, for which he won the 2002 Nobel Memorial Prize in Economics, even though he's not an economist. He's a research psychologist. His research documented that the standard model that economists have used of a "rational person" is not how people actually think. In so doing, he invented a field now called behavioral economics in the intersection between psychology and economics.