Was John Todd really an occultist? The evidence suggests that he was. Why, then, did he invent so many lies about wiccans, druids, and other occultists whose circles he traveled in when we converted to become a fundamentalist preacher? In this episode, we interrogate Todd's theory that H. P. Lovecraft wrote about actual occult practices, compare Todd's career to the "Satan Seller" Mike Warnke, and follow Todd to the mental health facility where he lived out the end of his days.