Not My Fantasy
Not My Fantasy
Cullen Callaghan and Hannah Sylvester
Journey to Bethlehem (2023) (feat. Katie Little)
3 hour 1 minutes Posted Dec 24, 2025 at 2:14 pm.
0:00
3:01:48
Download MP3
Show notes
Happy Holidays from Cullen and Hannah and friend of the pod Katie! This season we controversially stretch the boundaries of our genre to slouch towards Bethlehem with our boy Milo and the team behind Glee and High School Musical. We explore the real war on Christmas, the history of the festive season and even do a seasonal Bible study. (Making Cullen a new favorite of Hannah’s mom) Will our religious upbringing clash with the fun bops of this musical? Will we reignite the wars between Catholics and Protestants? Find out in this seasonal delight of an episode. 
 
Listen to/Read Katie’s Recommendations 
Unchurchable 
A Well-Trained Wife: My Escape from Christian Patriarchy 
 
Please if you can, donate to https://www.chirla.org/ to support safety and justice for immigrant communities. 
 
Research for this episode:
The Gospel of Luke 
The Gospel of Matthew 
The Catechism of the Catholic Church on Mary 
Historicity of the Nativity Narratives - Secular 
 Historicity of the Nativity Narratives - Christian 
History of Christmas 
The Banning of Christmas 
Cullen Hates to Admit that the history of Augustus, the Three Kings and the Church of the Nativity was primarily from Wikipedia. 
====================================
 
Watch Us on YouTube!
 
Follow Our Adventures on Social Media:
 
@notmyfantasypod
Instagram
TikTok
 
Research & Writing by Cullen Callaghan. 
This episode was edited by Hannah Sylvester.
 
Cover Art by William Callaghan
Intro Music: "The Quest" by Scott Little.