I would like to come to a podcast about Neopets and not have to hear about the political opinions of the hosts. This isn’t a political podcast and not everyone cares to hear you call people you disagree with a “stupid TERF” TERF is a slur and hearing you wish death upon an author of a book who you simply disagree with really turned me off to further listening. Stick to neopets. Outside of being political, it’s simply just too scattered of a podcast. When they are actually talking about neopets it’s great but sadly that’s a small percentage of the episodes lately.

I still can't believe there is a neopets podcast lol. This is a great listen, even if you don't play with the site any more.

The hosts are fun to listen to and the Neocontent is good but they have a tendency to spend too long on tangents unrelated to the site. This isn’t necessarily a bad thing but makes it feel like it’s not a Neopets podcast at points, especially during the “Getting Kacheeky” segments. If you aren’t interested in hearing their takes on non-Neopets related things you might want to have the skip button ready but it’s otherwise a nice listen.

This show is a delight to listen to!!!

The hosts of this podcast really know their neo-stuff. It’s the perfect length so you can binge a few episodes at a time and it really brings back the memories of you playing neopets. Great from the first episode!

As an older Neopets player who has been playing almost since the start of the sites creation, I absolutely love this podcast! I would suggest this to anyone currently interested in paying Neopets, playing, or even just looking for a piece of your childhood back. The hosts always make me laugh and remind me of the “old” Neopets!

It was such a nice surprise to find this podcast! I find myself saying oh yeah! I remember that! Almost every episode, it certainly brings you back to a simpler time. Thank you ladies for making this show, and I hope it continues. Goodnight Mr. Coconut!

Anyone who’s played Neopets in the past and in the present can appreciate this one. Caroline and Hannah tackle the logic of the Neopets world and its current events head-on with unflinching commentary and good humor. Fun recurring segments including Kyrii-osities, a show-and-tell of just a few of the thousands of wacky virtual items on Neopets, Getting Kacheek-y, reading and discussing absurd and/or conversation-starting Neoboard posts, and other similarly punny segments. A loving, living tribute to the site we love to dunk on. Thank you, ladies!

I’m rediscovering Neopets after many years and I love listening to this show...I guess I was a dumb kid because looking at it now- I had no idea back then of the depth and scope of all of these quests, etc. I just liked playing cheesy buggy flash games. Special shout out to the “Gettin’ Kacheeky” segment because I LOL every time, fa real! #ThemBoardsIsNUTS

I have always been a big Neopets fan from a young age (Since 2007 to be exact). Since then, I have been on and off the site periodically, but never lost my love for it. Though recently, I found your podcast! While I haven't been on quite as long as you two, you've brought back a lot of fun memories for me as well as a new found steady interest in the site! I had never really made any goals for myself on the site, just exploring and playing games was enough for me when I was a kid. But listening to you guys,I'ive found new tasks, new goals that have brought back my passion for this little side hobby. Also, you're both sweet and adorable and just entertaining to listen to! And very chill as well. Keep up the great work! <33

Heard about this podcast from a fb group I am in and I am not disappointed. If you love Neopets this is the perfect podcast to listen to while clicking around the site. I missed a ton of years on Neopets and am learning all kinds of fun backstory. Love the commentary and find myself laughing along every time.

I look forward to listening to every new Neostalgia episode! Hannah and Caroline seem really cool and have great senses of humor :)

The fact that I love both podcasts and Neopets would be enough to make this show a winner for me, but Caroline and Hannah are both so funny and articulate that it's a double-winner in my book. Keep up the awesome work!

This is a great podcast! It is also my own podcast but I'm not biased.

Keep at it ladies! This podcast is funny and perfect for a neo fan!

My favorite part of every other Wednesday. I need all this neopet info pumped straight into my veins. #blessed Take the pod on tour

Listen to it.

Just kidding takes me back to 30 minutes ago when my 3 hours were up to obsessively click my Buried Treasure link to try for the avatar which I’ve been doing for about 9 years. I’ve been playing neopets.com since 2002 also with maybe like 3 years off. I’m now a 27 year old who dresses up 2 alien cats and a Blumaroo and spends money on them to do so. Thank you for this podcast, I’m only mad I didn’t think of it myself.

I redownloaded the apple podcast app just to subscribe and rate! This is a good and pure podcast and I love it so much already 💖