When the story of the "Long Island Lolita" (ew) broke, America was instantly obsessed with the story of a teenage girl falling so hard for mechanic Joey Buttafuoco that she shot his wife Mary Jo in the face. So much so, that three TV movies were produced in rapid succession! This week we're covering the version with Drew Barrymore, who gives an EXCELLENT performance as Amy Fisher.

Molly's joined by TV producer Jessica Shelton aka The HomeGoods Heiress (jk, but this is huge for us).

Get access to early and ad-free episodes and lots of bonus episodes, as well as our sister show, "Life Behind the 'Times" which offers a more in-depth exploration into the true crime stories that your favorite Lifetime Movies are based on!

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices