"I thought cheesecake was basically a big bowl of Gouda."

Mike finally tries cheesecake for the first time after avoiding it for more than 40 years. But before the taste test, he and Jess revisit the Long Island neighborhood where they first lived together, sharing forgotten memories, old apartment stories, and how going back to a familiar place can instantly bring the past rushing back.

Plus, they rank terrible ice cream flavors, debate tiny spoons, and give their honest review of The Cheesecake Factory.