LessWrong posts by zvi
LessWrong posts by zvi
zvi
“Fertility Roundup #5: Causation” by Zvi
52 minutes Posted Jan 2, 2026 at 10:01 pm.
Data has to be read “vertically” (longitudinally), not [...] ---Outline:
Household Composition
Timing
Developmental Idealism
Pessimism
Baby Boom
Paperwork
Car Seats As Contraception
You Can't Afford It
Yes The Problem Is Often Money
Housework
Greedy Careers
The Appeal of Child-Free
Motivation
Grandparents
Expectations of Impossibility
Isolation
Decoupling
South Korea
World
Various Places in Trouble
China
Russia
Europe
America
Kazakhstan
Israel
Consequences
Unfounded Optimism
History
0:00
52:49
Download MP3
Show notes
There are two sides of developments in fertility.
How bad is it? What is causing the massive, catastrophic declines in fertility?
What can we do to stabilize and reverse these trends to a sustainable level?
Today I’m going to focus on news about what is happening and why, and next time I’ll ask what we’ve learned since last check-in about we could perhaps do about it.
One could consider all this a supplement to my sequence on The Revolution of Rising Expectations, and The Revolution of Rising Requirements. That's the central dynamic.
Household Composition
What is happening? A chart worth looking at every so often.
Timing
Michael Arouet: No way. WTF happened in 1971?
This is United States data:
The replies include a bunch of other graphs that also go in bad directions starting in 1971-73.
Developmental Idealism
Lyman Stone, in his first Substack post, lays the blame for fertility drops in non-Western countries primarily on drops in desire for children, via individuals choosing Developmental Idealism.
Lyman Stone: Five Basic Arguments for Understanding Fertility:
Data has to be read “vertically” (longitudinally), not [...] ---Outline:(
00:46) Household Composition(01:06) Timing(01:37) Developmental Idealism(04:47) Pessimism(05:51) Baby Boom(06:53) Paperwork(08:24) Car Seats As Contraception(11:14) You Can't Afford It(12:23) Yes The Problem Is Often Money(12:57) Housework(15:13) Greedy Careers(18:24) The Appeal of Child-Free(19:30) Motivation(22:06) Grandparents(25:26) Expectations of Impossibility(28:04) Isolation(30:00) Decoupling(31:45) South Korea(39:20) World(39:54) Various Places in Trouble(40:51) China(44:25) Russia(44:39) Europe(45:34) America(46:43) Kazakhstan(47:10) Israel(48:56) Consequences(49:49) Unfounded Optimism(50:56) History(51:44) Implications ---
First published:
January 2nd, 2026
Source:
https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/SSQDuWDsbXH3kujPb/fertility-roundup-5-causation
---
Narrated by TYPE III AUDIO.
---Images from the article:Apple Podcasts and Spotify do not show images in the episode description. Try Pocket Casts, or another podcast app.